EVERTON’S OPPONENTS
Liverpool Daily Post - Wednesday 01 March 1905
Like many other well-known clubs, the Southampton club was born as the result of the enthusiasm of a few Church choir boys. They met in October 1885 and formed the St. Mary’s Football Club, Canon Wilberforce, who as then rector of the church taking a keen practical interest in the boys. Quickly they made tracks for cups local cups. The St. Mary’s club entered for the Hampshire Junior Cup and they won it in 1888, 89 and again in 1900 so that the “tin pot” became their own possession. Now they discarded the name of “juniors.” They were seniors and at the first attempt won the Hants Senior Cup. This worthy band of “Saints” was now feared by all rivals, and when they won the Senior Cup in 1893-4 people thought they looked upon the trophy as their own personal property. The Saints did not let the grass grow under their feet. They engaged J.W. Dorkin of Edinburgh St Berrrad as professional and the players undoubtedly benefited by his coaching. They have never won the Cup, but have twice been knocked out in the final. In April, 1900 after beating Everton by 3 clear goals at the Dell, to which ground they had now gone the Sotons claimed another record, for they were the first Southern club engaged in the final tie for eighteen years. Bury, however, were too clever for them by 4 goals to nil. They were again at the top of League affairs in the next year, and in the Cup tie Everton had their revenge with a victory of 3 goals to 1. In 1901, after Everton had been beaten by Liverpool at Goodison in a replayed tie- the score was 2-0-the Saints reproduced their cup-fighting form, and beat Liverpool by 4 goals to 1, prior to which they defeated the ‘Spurs after three meetings. They had sweets of victory over Bury, their former conquerors, and worked through to the final again, only to return defeated after a drawn game, by a goal margin. They comprise the real hope of the South this season, and, therefore one realise how strong will be their efforts to justify the trust. The match at Goodison will probably provide the tit-bit of the round, and by the way, Mr. W.C. Cuff, Sharp, Sugg, and Bullock are being inundated for tickets. A record crowd is looked forward to. There is no increase in the 6d portion of the ground, but the cheapest stand and promenade is 1s 6d, the next highest 3s (inside the reserved portion) and the highest 5s (for reserved and numbered seats). All the first team members and Tom Booth, R. Balmer , Rankin  and McLoughlin went to the brine baths at Northwich yesterday, in charge of a director and Trainer Elliott. Settle’s injury it appears was a blistered heel. He will be ready for service by Saturday. The men place no moment on the defeat of their visitors on Saturday, by West Ham, because all reports agree that the losers were the better team, and that defeat is likely to nerve them up for more serious work.

CHAPTER TWO OF THE EVERTON CUP CONTEST
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 01 March 1905
A DAY AT THE GROUND
By Bee
Chapter Tow in the story if the Everton v. Southampton cup tie concerns the Everton men. I went to Goodison yesterday and saw John Elliott put the men through their paces. The groundsmen were busy getting the turf in the best possible condition, and were busily engaged gently raking the ground. It appears that the ground has not been rolled with the heavy roller for over three months. The rake, I learnt, acted simply, and was the cause of a better drainage. Certainly the playing space appeared to be greasy, but not at all so bad as one would have expected after the downpour we had early yesterday morning. I am told that rain fell very heavily, but cannot vouch for the fact, for the simple reason that -well, we’ll pass along. The office cat ran round the ground as a sort of preliminary to the players, and then the men strolled up to the ground for the afternoon’s course of training. In the morning, the men had been out in the country for a walk. Now, mostly, the reserve quantities entered the arena and, after a quiet jog round the ground, set off for a few sprints of about a hundred yards each. McLoughlin, Rankin, Dilly, Roberts, Wildman and others were present. Then Young came on the scene.
A HAPPY FAMILY
He went along in fine style. He doesn’t look over well in health, I hear, and we really ought to remember when criticising him the many bumps he has to put up with without saying a solitary word. “Jock” Taylor was soon on the go, and when Sharp saw him travel something under ten yards as a start off he jokingly told him that the sprint was far too long, and that he must not exert himself so strenuously next time! Yes they are indeed a happy set of fellows. Good fellowship means much towards success in football. McDermott and Crelly got through their work in energetic fashion, and what surprised me most was the way Crelly sprinted the “hundred.” For a player of his bulk he is very speedy. Abbott to my mind, has tried perceptibly of late, and, in fact, I have rather favoured the idea that he should have a week’s rest. However, he covered long and short distances with every satisfaction yesterday, though his heel was slightly sore. Settle was looking on, but I know he will be quite fit for the great encounter. Makepeace, too, was on the easy list. Balmer I did not see, but believe he is quite well.
ROOSE’S POSITION
The nimble Roose was not there, of course. He stays in London, and from one Saturday to the other never sees a football. This makes his ability all the more remarkable. Most custodians have much practice during the week in their goals, but not so Roose. He goes on with his medical studies, just as Ashworth proceeds with architectural engagements at Fenton, just outside Stoke. Hardman is another who does not train at the ground. He resides at Blackpool, and is always as fit as can be. Now the men went to the gymnasium, which lies under the grand stand, and ball-punching, skipping, &c, was the order for the moment. The course of training seems to be rather light, but just enough to keep the men from getting stiff and stale. The groundsman found a coin when walking across the field, and he is keeping it safely stored in his pocket. He looks upon the coin-and the cat, I suppose-as a mascot.

FOOTBALL JOTTINGS
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 02 March 1905
When the “Echo” correspondent went to the Goodison Park to see Everton training, he saw Young go along in fine style. McDermott and Crelly got through their work in energetic fashion, but what surprised him most was the way Crelly sprinted the “hundred.” For a player of his bulk he is very speedy. Abbott has tried perceptibly of late. However, he covered long and short distances with every satisfaction, though his heel was slightly sore. Settle was looking on, Makepeace, too, was on the easy list. The nimble Roose was not there, of course. He stays in London, and from one Saturday to the other never sees a football. This makes his ability all the more remarkable. Most custodians have much practice during the week in their goals, but not so Roose. He goes on with his medical studies, just as Ashworth proceeds with architectural engagements at Fenton, just outside Stoke. Hardman is another who does not train at the ground. He resides at Blackpool, and is always as fit as can be.
Afterwards the men went to the gymnasium which lies under the grand stand, and ball-punching, skipping &c., was the order for the moment. The course of training seems to be rather light but just enough to keep the men from getting stiff and stale.

CHAPTER III. CONCNERS THE PERSONEL OF THE SAINTS
Liverpool Echo - Thursday 02 March 1905
By Bees
A POEM TO SHARP
Chapter III of the story is concerning the Southampton players, their training, &c. the Saints express themselves as pretty confident and hopeful about their cup-tie with Everton. George Molyneux, who, of course, went from Everton to the southern organisation, thinks his men are quite as good a team as our men, and, it is added, “be ought to know.” After the surprise defeat by West Ham, fifteen Saints went into training. As before, they put up at the Clump, to-day they go to Chester, which place they leave on Saturday morning for Liverpool. The players in special training are- Clawley, goal; Benson and Molyneux, backs Lee, Dainty, and Houlker, half backs; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards; together with Meston, Mouncher, Harry Wood, and A. Turner. Barring accidents, however, the same side that beat the Wolves will do duty at Goodison Park. The visitors hold out no especial hope when they refer to the clubs beaten on the Everton ground this season;- Aston Villa, Bury, Middlesbrough, Newcastle United, Notts County, Notts Forest, Preston North End, Sheffield United, Stoke, Wolverhampton Wanderers, and Blackburn Rovers; but they realise that cup form is incomparable with League form, and so take heart. It is a strange coincidence that the custodians on Saturday Clawley and Roose-have both kept goal for Stoke.
CLAWLEY ON “KEEPING.”
I am here going to give a few words of Clawley’s to the juniors. I make no apology to the senior readers; I think they will also be interested in what he says;-
George Clawley in physique is a magnificent athletes, with clear-cut feature and a determined yet open countenance. He stands well over 6ft, as possessed of immense strength, and is as agile as he is powerful. Asked “What is the most important qualification of a goalkeeper”? Clawley replied; “Nerve and presence of mind. A goalkeeper without nerve is like a ship without a rudder, bound to go adrift. But strength and agility are also most important and height is an immense advantage, I have made many a lucky save through being tall,” added Clawley, with a smile. “Height benefits a goalkeeper in this way. Suppose a well-directed shot comes flying along well over his head. A short man’s only chance is to jump to stop it with his hands; but a tall man can either pull the ball down or turn it over the bar. To do this in the midst of the noise and excitement of the game requires both nerve and agility, I can  assure you. A good goalkeeper should be able usually to intercept a ball without thumping or kicking things. Sometimes it is essential to do one of these things, but a player who is constantly having recourse to these tactics is, generally speaking, an unsafe man in an emergency. Players should live quietly and cleanly and do everything in their power to develop lissomness as well as strength. Their arms should be as active as a boxer’s, and their whole frames should be injured to fatigue and be capable of standing a sudden strain, whether of exertion or of temperature. Boxing or any exercise than engenders nerve is excellent for the footballer, for the team that possesses the best nerves, other things being equal, will win.”
It was in Staffordshire that Clawley first became known to fame as the custodian of Stoke. Then he joined Southampton, and after a brief sojourn again with Stoke, settled down as the Tottenham goalkeeper, after which he returned to his old love.
Here are some points about the chief of our visitors;-
Molyneux was capped against Scotland in 1901. He is a sound and reliable back; a principled player.
Meston was born in Arbroath in 1871, stands 5ft 10in, and weighs 12st. regular place, right half, but useful in almost any position.
Harry Wood was born in 1877, which makes him 28 years old. He became an international in the nineties. Played for Walsall Swifts and Wolverhampton. He holds out well for an old ‘un.
Bluff has suddenly dropped from the clouds. He has rapidly made a reputation. Certainly belies his name. he was unable to play last week. A star turn in shooting.
Harrison shows little individuality, but he is a shootist of the fierce type. Born at Winchester in 1881, he was collared when only in his teens by the club he still represents. One has to see him more than once to appreciate him. Weighs 11st 10lbs, and is 5ft 10in, in height. “Jock” Taylor will have to be very wide awake. Lee was not good enough for the ill-fated West Bromwich club. The Saints saw through different glasses and with beneficial results.
Dainty and Houlker will rival the Everton halves in the matter of skill. Thet never give up bothering, and as feeders of their forwards they are very accurate.
MIDNIGHT EXCUSIONS
Two excursions have been arranged for by Southampton, and though trippers will have to leave home at twelve o’clock midnight their enthusiasm will doubtless be noticeable on the afternoon of the match. A Southampton man has sent Jack Sharp the following;-
Oh, Everton, on Everton, oh, why did you aspire
To beat the Saints at football far from their native shire?
The Saints have done the “wandering,” and the ‘tis often said
That in the South we’re weakling ‘tis by the South you’re dead,
It matters not to Saints upon what ground they play.
They can always beat the “Toffeeites” at home or fat away.
Tisn’t the first time you have met them, but you know now jolly well.
That you’ll killed all the “wishes” if you meet them at the Dell.
For on that historic battle ground, where Saints and sinners fight
You will find that “Southern weakling” are at football “men of might.”
For they mean to get the Cup, and they have been very near.
So you’ll have to eat more beef and you mustn’t drink much beer.
Everton members went a walk out Sefton way yesterday morning, and in the afternoon there was little doing. Taylor sports an ugly-looking black eye through a collision in Saturday’s match, and has to wear a shade over the injured member. The Scottie is persistently getting his nose or eye damaged. Without him in the half back line we should not know where we were. Fortunately, he is one of the stamp of players, who has to be very badly smacked before he is unable to turn out.
INTERNATIONAL CHANGES
Correspondent wants to know whether there is a likelihood of change in the composition of the next international team, as compared with last week’s. one rather fancies there will be. Though Balmer was better than Carr, yet he does not seem to have caught on, and Williamson’s one slip may result in the inclusion of Linacre or Baddeley. The half-back line may remain as before, but forward there must be changes. V. Woodward has been spoilt through changing about from inside to centre position. S.S. Harris is not good enough also. Bond and Bloomer are safe and F. Booth should be given another trial.

EVERTON F.C.
Liverpool Echo - Thursday 02 March 1905
The following players were to-night chosen to represent Everton F.C on Saturday against Southampton.- Roose; W. Balmer and Crelly; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman. The reserve are Rankin, R. Balmer and McLoughlin.

FOOTBALL ITEMS
Liverpool Daily Post - Friday 03 March 1905
The following players were last night chosen to represent Everton to-morrow against Southampton;- Roose; W. Balmer and Crelly; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman. The reserve are Rankin, R. Balmer, and McLoughlin. Everton members went a walk out Sefton way on Wednesday morning, and in the afternoon there was little doing. Taylor sports an ugly looking black eye through a collision in Saturday’s match, and has to wear a shade over the injured member.
Southampton are now at Chester, which place they leave tomorrow for Liverpool. The players in special training are; Lawley, goal; Benson and Molyneux, backs; Lee, Dainty, and Houlker, half-backs; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards; together with Meston, Mouncher, Harry Wood, and A. Turner. Barring accidents, however, the same side that beat Wolves will do duty at Goodison Park.

CHAPTER FOUR REFERS TO FINAL WORDS AND ESTIMATES
Liverpool Echo - Friday 03 March 1905
SELECTED TEAMS
Over at Chester, yesterday, I saw the Southampton footballers at their hotel, where they put up util to-morrow noon. All the directors secretary, and thirteen players, together with the trainer, were looking forward hopefully to the morrow to bring them much fortune. I was told by Secretary Arnfield that there was a large crowd to see them off from Southampton, and they gave the players a most enthusiastic send-off. As the train steamed out cheers were raised in lusty manner. Euston was reached at about a quarter of five. Dinner was had en route, and a rather strange committee-room was formed in the saloon. While the train-dashed along towards Chester the directors close the eleven to represent them, and these are the men they decided to reply on;- Clawley; Benson and Molyneux; Lee, Dainty, and Houlker; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser. Meston and Harry Wood were first reserves. The reason why only a couple of reserves have been brought up is that the Sotons have a  second team engagement to-morrow with Reading away, and their team have a home engagement. The team selected is that which beat Wolverhampton Wanderers in the second round at Molineux ground by three goals to two. Mr. Arnfield expressed himself very hopeful that a similar score on the right side might again result. He said- “Of course, some players play better on their own ground, but our men have made quite a name for ‘away’ victories. They play just as well away’ in fact, I rather think they are a trifle better in their displays on other clubs’ grounds than at the Dell. In the last tie our men were always the better side, especially after the interval. Southampton are fit to last, and they will fight until the whistle goes. I do not care how strongly Everton goes-it is no walk-over. All our boys are fit, though one or two are suffering from very slight colds.” Then we talked of football in the South and Mr. Arnfield pointedly said- “The first and second rounds of the English Cup ought to teach those who will taught that there is as good football outside the North as in the North.”
Mr. W. Fletcher, secretary of the Chester F.,C., met the team at the station, and placed his club’s enclosure at the Saints disposal for training purposes. The visitors, however, completed their special training at home, and to-day will only indulge in a stroll to Eaton Hall and back. In the evening, after dinner, they will visit the local baths and will probably go to the theatre.
Everton have chosen their usual side, the changes from last week being Settle for McLoughlin and W. Balmer for his brother. To-day the men were at Hoylake in the morning and to-night they are going to one of the local theatres.

SOUTHAMPTON’S VISIT TO EVERTON.
Hampshire Advertiser - Saturday 04 March 1905
The Saints have again donned their battle array, and gone "on the warpath" down Everton way. Where they may be trusted to make a fine flight! When meeting the "Toffee-ites" in their great might.
Maybe, they will have to go all the way.
If Fortune's to greet them at close of the play;
But they think they can manage to get through the round.
And bring back the laurels, as well as renown.
"Yi! Yi!! The Saints!" their supporters all cry,
You always play plucky, and never say die;
We trust that success may fall to your lot
And that you will finally "collar" the "pot"!
There's plenty of room for the trophy down here;
And we shall be proud of you - that much is clear;
The renown of the South's in your keeping to-day;
So please win the match -we hope that you may!
Yi! Yi!! Yi!!!

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 04 March 1905
The Southampton team selected to play against Everton is that which beat Wolverhampton Wanderers in the second round at Molineux ground by three goals to two. Mr. Armfield the secretary when interviewed at Chester score on the right side might again result. He said –“Of course, some players play better on their own ground, but our men have made quite a name for ‘away” victories. They play just as well away; in fact, I rather think they are a  trifle better in their displays on other clubs’ grounds than at the Dell. In the last tie our men were always better side, especially after the interval. Southampton are fit to last, and they will fight until the whistle goes. I do not care how strongly Everton goes- it is no walk over. All our boys are fit, though one or two are suffering from very slight colds.”
Everton v Southampton
English Cup (Third Round) at Goodison Park 3.30
Everton.- Roose, goal; W. Balmer and Crelley, backs; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbotts, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Southampton- Clawley, goal; Benson and Molyneux, backs; Lee, Dainty, and Houlker, half-backs; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards.
Referee Mr. A.G Hines (Notts), Linesmen Messrs J.R Schumacher (London) and M.T Roberts (Derby).

EVERTON v SOUTHAMPTON
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 04 March 1905
ENGLISH CUP TIE AT GOODISON PARK
McDERMOTT SCORES FOR EVERTON
SETTLE ADDS A SECOND
By Pigeon Post and Telephone
The popularity of the Cup ties as well as that of Southern football teams was powerfully evidenced to-day by the wonderful amount of interest which was engendered by the meeting of Everton and the Saints. Liverpool and its citizens seemed with one accord determined to witness and acclaim the encounter. The Saints are doughty cup fighters, and the warmest partisans of the Blues were fain to admit that, League leaders though they be, they might not take the slightest liberty with their visitors, who have a great reputation for achieving victory “away.” As a matter of fact they defeated the Wolves at Molyneux grounds. The Southampton contingent came on from Chester to-day and reported themselves at full strength and fit and well and brimful of confidence. Everton were also at full strength, and quash cripples were convalescent and eager for the fray. Every element which could ensure a great game was present and the crowd watched the opening of the mighty drizzle between North and South with almost bated breath. It was the Sotons’ first visit to the Goodison Park enclosure, and the football fates had explained that the hopes of the South for Cup glory should be kernelled us today’s encounter. Mr. A.G. Hines was director general of affairs and the men took their places as follow;
Southampton- Clawley, goal; Benson and Molyneux (captain), backs; Lee, Dainty, and Houlker, half-backs; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards.
Everton; Roose, goal; W. Balmer (captain) and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Linesmen Messrs J.R. Schumacher and M.J. Roberts.
When Harrison led off the spectators approached 50,000 a monster gate. The weather was delightful but the ground a little heavy. The saints pressed immediately but they did not get very far before Abbott nipped in and checked cleverly. The Sotons pressed on the left, and hands against Everton gave the visitors a still further advantage but Crelly was on the watch and Roose pick up at his leisure. Then the Blues came away in brilliant style and swarmed round Clawley. Young testing him with a splendid straight drive, which the Soton custodian cleared in fine fashion. Sharp and McDermott put in fine work and the Saints defence was severely pushed on their wing until the leather went outside. The Blues dashed the leather in from both wings, but Molyneux was all about on guard. Then came an attack up the centre, but it had a weak finish and Dainty shifted the leather smartly. Southampton were now well penned in until Webb and Bluff made a big effort to get away on their wing, but the attentions of Abbott and Taylor proved too much for them, and Sharp gave a foul, but even this advantage did not help the Saints for the moment, but they came again on the right when Abbott worried Webb, but he passed to Fraser, and a splendid swift centre to Hamson was badly missed by the Southampton centre. Then the Blues returned to the attack in fine style. Soon afterwards Harrison lifted the ball over the Everton goal, after which Everton ran down prettily but Young was beaten before he could get in his shot. More pretty play by the home contingent brought them back to the Southampton quarter line and then the ball was landed out to Sharp who was beat by Molyneux. The visitors left wingers then darted away, but offside was against them and after midfield play Hardman darted away on his own, and gave a lovely swinging centre, Young could not get at the ball properly and Sharp dashed in, but was all at sea when he should have shot at goal. A couple of minutes later, however, the Evertonians went swinging down again, and Hardman put the ball across to Sharp who worked down and then McDermott came in and scored a lovely goal some sixteen minutes from the start, the success of the Everton men being signalised by a deafening outburst of cheering. Almost from the restart Southampton burst away, and Harrison netted the ball from an off-side position. There was no holding the Everton men as they attacked time after time notwithstanding a sturdy defence. Once Settle got well placed close in and shot for all he was worth, but Clawley proved himself a capable custodian by saving brilliantly; also he did just afterwards in answer to a running shot from Young. The Sotons were now kicking very wildly and seemed to be held at all points by the Blues who attacked finely all along the line, but Molyneux and Banson put in sterling defence. Fraser and Hedley attempted vainly to break away on their wing, but were held fast by Makepeace,. Clawley was playing a fine game in goal, and saved some grand shots from Young at close quarters. Still the game continued all in favour of the Blues and the Saints never looked dangerous. Settle headed another attack, which though checked for the moment ultimately proved successful. A severe hustle in midfield ended in favour of the visitors’ half-backs, and the ball went out to Fraser who gave the inside men a rare chance but Bluff shot very wide indeed. Clever work on the left wing culminated in Settle forcing a corner, which was well placed by hardman. The ball dropped on Settle’s breast and was going into goal when Clawley made his effort. The goalkeeper touched the ball, but failed to stay its progress and it tumbled into the net, this coming at the end of about thirty -two minutes’ play. During an attack by the Southampton men Crelly was slightly injured and the game was stopped for a time for “repairs,” Hardman continued the pressure on the left, and Abbott, took a free kick which was nicely placed, but Dainty headed away smartly, and the leather was crossed to the Saints’ left wing, but once more Fraser was held up by Makepeace. Then Taylor slipped away, and Everton commenced a fierce attack in the centre, from which Clawley and Benson had a rare gruelling but the Southampton man emerged victorious. At last, Bluff and Webb did get going, and made fine headway, supported by Dainty, who finally received from Webb, and tested Roose. The Southampton front now worked much better, and Roose had to respond to a smart one from Hedley. After the ball had rebounded from Culley’s movement. As half-time came near the crowd were evidently on good terms with themselves and the game had certainly been one of a kind to give them satisfaction. Everton had played with their old dash, the defence on both sides had been good, while the Southampton forwards had shown some rattling good play. However, the score at the interval was a fair reflex of the play all round. There was tremendous enthusiasm during the interval over Everton’s success, and they played such a masterly game that Southampton looked quite second-class. Restarting, Southampton opened out their attack on the left but Balmer was well up and checked their progress until they transferred to the right wing, where Crelly was also successful in preventing any further advance and Hardman took up from Taylor and tried a shot which was a little wide. The Saints then came along on the right but Wenn did not centre judiciously, and Crelly removed the pressure. Sharp next took possession, and put across, but Young was offside from taking Hardman’s pass. A foul in favour of the Saints followed, but they could not make an effort of any class. Some particularly close work by Fraser and Hedley was attended to by Makepeace in a masterly manner, and the ball went forward to Sharp, who lost in a race with Houlker, who tipped the ball forward to Clawley the latter clearing. Later on, however, Taylor and Settle indulged in pretty passing but the last-named was hustled off the ball by Dainty and Houlker, who sandwiched him. Them followed some admirable football from McDermott, who was aided by Settle and Hardman and Benson had finally to concede a corner. This proved abortive, but the Saints were still penned in their quarters until Clawley brought of a grand save from Settle, who had shot in with terrific force. Everton placed three corners and then after a breakaway by the Saints at the end of which Roose kicked clear, the home team came clean away and Settle scored a third goal for Everton in brilliant fashion. Final Result; Everton 4 goals, Southampton Nil.
THE GATE
The gate amounted to £1,612 41,000 paying for admission.
POINTS OF THE PLAY
By F.E.H.
To-day the citizens of the greatest seaport in the word have given themselves up to football. The very air is tinged with Cup tie contests and nought else is of importance.
From the stroke of noon thousands of all-leased workers set off towards Goodison Park. For once in a way all roads lead to Everton, I can best describe the scene by adapting Browing to the occasion. There was a rustling that seemed like a bustling. Of merry crowd jostling at pitching and hustling men’s feet were pattering and their those clattering. Eager bards clapping and eager tongues chattering. Like fowls in a farmyard when barley us scuttering. On the ground itself what a scene! Fifty thousand people- packed perspiring and fervid. People and pence roll in continuously, and at half past three even the turnstiles had retired. Southampton appear first, and are warmly welcomed, but the roar that greets the Evertonians a few second later shakes the stands to their foundations. Balmer won the toss and this is signalised by repeated cheers, the magnitude of which can only be heard to be believed. The Southrons, start with their faces to the sun and immediately press strongly, a foul against Crelly letting them dangerously near Roose. The ball, however, goes over the bar, and the home team move down. Useful half back play gives the forwards possession, and Young puts in a glorious shot, which brings out all Clawley’s abilities.  Next a series of brilliant exchanges on the part of both forward lines, but all without effect. Players, one and all, wonderfully cool and collected considering the excited horde which surround them, and the footwork so far as of the highest order. The Hampshire men break away on the left and from Fraser’s pass Harrison has the ball at his feet, and only Roose to beat. The crowd holds its breath, and the Saints came forward misses the kick. It is thus that goals are lost. This escape serves the useful purpose of stimulating Everton. Hardman rushes down the wing and passes across to Sharp. The Lancashire cricketer mulls it but the outside man’s fault is ably atoned for by McDermott, who though slow is sure, and nipping in he nets the leather. This success comes after sixteen minutes play, and it sends the great majority of the spectators nearly frantic with delight. After such an exhibition of enthusiasm not even our worst enemy could charge us with being phlegmatic. Holding a point in hand, Everton proceed to show what their mettle really is. Their cleverness in combination compels admiration even from the visitors, and one brilliant effort ends in another grounder from Young, which Clawley literally only saves by his finer-tips. Play is now going all in favour of the home side, who are undoubtedly quicker on the ball and cleverer in their method. There is, however, the usual laxity in finishing well, and several fine assaults end in smoke. The above reproach has scarcely been written before the home side proceed to make amends. The left wing work their way down, and a corner is forced. Hardman takes the kick and Settle breasts the ball towards Clawley, who tries to check it, but fails-result, another goal for Everton. Renewed cheering and visions of the Crystal Palace loom larger than ever upon an already roseate horizon. Everton now “all over” their opponents, and for a time they ease up. This leads to the visitors making play on the right, and Crelly, in checking Bluff and Webb, is badly winded. Cessation of hostilities for a few moments, and then another brilliant attack on the Southampton goal, which ends in Clawley saving miraculously from Young. Further pressure by Everton, who seem to hunger for a third goal before the interval. The Saints, however, seem to be imbued with the same spirit, for they rush down, and Hedley sends in one of the old Sheffield shots. Fortunately for Everton, Crelly is in the way, and the ball bounds off his body towards the centre line. Half-time; and the home side proud and satisfied leaders by two clear goals- a very fair index of their merit as compared with that of the men from the rival port. The interest being mainly occupied in getting a little elbow room, but the tension is renewed as the players reappeared. Everton at the outset go off with a rush, and Clawley saved from Young at short range. A little later Hardman and Settle forced a corner, and this looked promising when Sharp headed over the bar. This is followed by an even more determined attack, and Settle has an open goal before him, when he misses the ball and Hardman rushing in shoots wide. The home side are still asserting themselves strong, and there is no doubt even in the mind of the most prejudiced as to which is the better team. This is emphatically demonstrated when, after a brilliant bit of forward play, Settle adds a third goal. The Southampton defeat was complete when just on time, Settle scored the fourth goal. Altogether it was a great and glorious victory for Everton and in commiserating with Southampton I conclude as I began with an “After life’s football fever they sleep well.”

EVERTON 4 SOUTHAMPTON 0 (Fac Game 49)
March 5, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
Fa Cup Round Three
EVERTON ENTER THE SEMI-FINAL
RUNAWAY VICTORY AT GOODISON.
The vast crowd of Everton supporters at Goodison park went away on the best of terms with themselves, and after the most benignant of blessings conferred upon their “pets”. They were thoroughly satisfied at the result, as well as with the brilliant manner in which the team as a whole performed against Southampton in the Third round of the F.A.Cup-tie, the outcome of which is that Balmer and his merry men enter the Semi-Final stages. After Saturday's display by the locals, one's confidence is inspired that they will figure in the final stages, and then there will be some shouting. May these anticipations be realised, to the extent, of course of winning the trophy. If they can do this, as well as maintain their proud position at the top of the League table, truly it will be a proud day. A victory of 4 to none over the cracks of the Southern League, and indeed what is regarded as one of the finest of Southern teams, was a tremendous surprise. Such a wide margin was certainly never looked for, and there were those who even entertained fears as to what Everton would do. The “Soton” had been playing very consistency and strongly in recent games, making short work for the “Wolves” in the previous round. Everton, although right as regards results in recent League matches, had not shown the scoring power expected of them.
HOW THE GAME PROGRESSED.
But all this was changed on Saturday. The Evertonians were in both a scoring and winning mood, and matter matters hum. Truth to tell they were discovered quite on the top of their form. Their victory was thoroughly deserved. The first quarter of an hour or so gave indications of a very stubborn sort of struggle, the visitors opening in encouraging style. The initial attack of the home team came a little later, at which the Southerners were somewhat, affrighted. After some maneuvering by Settle, the insatiable McDermott gave Crawley a teaser, which, however, he managed to keep out. It was hereabouts that the Southampton half-back line showed some of their best tackling, but unfortunately they did not keep it up for long. It was disheartening to the visitors to see what was an open goal thrown away by the centre (Harrison). Poor thanks to the clever Fraser, who had made a fine effort a considerable length of the field, and then passed. This non-success, and the aggressive work by Everton, may naturally have had very discouraging effects on the visitors for the remaining part of the game. At any rate, after McDermott had opened the account 16 minutes from the start, the “Sotons” never seemed really to look up again. Fraser did his best to pull matters together, but his efforts were not asconded, and before the interval the Southerners were two goals in arrear. Settle being responsible for the second goal. For some time prior to this the attack on the Southampton goal had been tremendous, and how it escaped so lightly was a marvel. The contrast between the teams in the second portion was more marked than ever. Everton's brilliancy again asserted itself to the discomfiture of their opponents, who were not given the chance to get away much, and when they did they were never dangerous. How different from what their recent displays must have been! But they were meeting forwards, halves, and backs much smarter, and clever than their own on the day's play. The Goodison brigade never slackened, and further success was bound to come, and come it did, for Settle, taking advantage of a little slackness by the opposing backs got in and scored a splendid goal. The pressure was unrelieved until the very latter stages, it was in the concluding minutes that Everton's inside left, put on another goal amidst thundering cheers from the solid phalanx of interest spectators.
SETTLES “HAT-TRICK”
Unqualified praise must be tendered to the whole of the Everton brigade. They played fully recognising that there were important issues depending upon the match, and that seemed to be their objective all through. The front line has seldom been seen to such advantage. Their movements were full of animation, and as was often the case proved quite irresistible; after the early stages of the game they found little difficulty in getting through the opposing halves. The two wings men, Sharp and Hardman, were quite at their best, both centring with accuracy, and also sending in shots which were not far off the mark. Sharp, too, was a great success in the way he harried first Houlker and then Molyneux, Young played a very persistent game, often troubling Clawley, whilst the two insides, Settle, and McDermott were often out on their own. Settle's part was one of exceptional distinction, for he was credited with three of the goals-no mean feat, in a match of this order. Invincible correct and judicious was the play of the halves, it is a long time since the Southampton forwards found such a tough half-back line. Harrison will no doubt remember Taylor for a long time. Balmer and Crelly were also very safe, and Roose had a somewhat easy time in goal.
CLAWLEY'S CLEVER CLEARANCES.
After their recent behavior it was extraordinary how Southampton fell away. They appeared at times quite helpless. Fraser was by far the best of a weak and straggling front line, which was soon routed. His big stride and speed stood him in good stead, and some of his runs were apt to be dangerous. On the whole, none of the side seemed to get thoroughly used to the Everton style, neither did they attempt any effective policy of checking the dashing home movements. The halves were better in the first half of the game, but offered little resistance in the later stages, and with the exception of some occasional good kicking the backs did not create a favourable impression on the day's play. Southampton have Clawley to thank for not having a heavier score against them. The way he successfully dealt with a number of dangerous low shots was surprising, and altogether he proved himself a custodian in the first flight. The match was a great attraction, and according to the officially report 41,000 people paid admission, bring in receipts amounting to £1,612. Teams: - Everton: - Roose, goal, W.Balmer, and Crelly, backs, Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott half-backs, Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards. Southampton: - Crawley, goal, Benson, and Molyneux, backs, Lee, Damty, and Houlkers half-backs, Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards. Referee A.G.Hines.

EVERTON IN EXCELSIS
Athletic News - Monday 06 March 1905
By Tityrus
The ground man at Goodison Park us reported to have passed Friday night within the playing enclosure.  Surely he was not frightened of Southampton emissaries scaling the hoarding and preparing the pasture to their own liking?  It is reported that cricket pitches have been doctored at Harrogate, In Australia; and other haunts of civilization and sport, but even professional footballers –those much misunderstood men –have never yet been guilty of clandestine practices of this character.  Perhaps Weston, the caretaker of Goodison, was running about with a sponge soaking up the rain.  Really, one never knows.  Still, I suspect that his vigil was the result of nervous restlessness, which, happily, did not affect the team.  The ground was in splendid order, and when the sun burnished the spectacle of 50,000 people concentrating their eyes on that carefully tended turf the scene was calculated to live in one’s memory.  All sorts and conditions of men assisted at the battle of the Leagues.  There were clergymen, doctors, and dock labourers.  A man with a broken arm in a sling braved that crowd.  There was no mistaking the partisan, who is, after all, the very salt of the game.  Evertonians wore their colours in rosettes, and some had blue and white silk hats.  The Southerners were more subdued.  They found that a lily-of-the-valley blended beautifully with the scarlet blended beautifully with the scarlet petals of the geranium.  But such a combine of red and white was perishable-like the team which wore those bi-coloured jerseys.  The players came bounding on full of hope and happiness.  The rival captains –William Balmer and George Molyneux- possibly thought of the days when they were fellow backs for Everton as they tossed the coin – what time the man with the camera was snap-shooting.  Balmer won –an incident which might have been taken by the ancients as an omen.  It was a tell-tale, for Everton passed into the semi-final stage just as easily as Balmer called the upper side of the metal from the Mint.  The “Saints” were found woefully lacking in strategy and science, and had we not known that they can play football we should not have believed it.  They were not recognizable as the same eleven who whipped the Wolverhampton Wanderers.  But even great Cup teams are like “ships that pass in the Night.”  They are here today and gone tomorrow.  Southampton utterly failed before the hosts of Everton.  Let us see how they were undone.  The Southrons flattered at the outset, and there seemed every promise of a delightful struggle, but Everton gradually assumed ascendancy, and never relaxed their grip of the game from the time that McDermott surprised Clawley with a swift ground ball, which Clawley nimbly fielded.  Sharp showed his pace and his power in middling, despite the harassing tactics of Houlker, but McDermott’s hesitation and dribbling away to the wing when he was in possession near goal neutralized the attack.  The well-built and dashing Fraser was deftly plied, and he responded to many calls with dexterous dribbles and accurate centres –from one of which Harrison ought to have scored, while when he was lacking, Dainty dawdled, and Hedley hesitated until the defensive divisions were prepared for any bombshell.  Everton were next keeping their adversaries on the stretch, but when Hardman put the ball near goal Sharp overran the object.  Still at the end of a quarter of an hour McDermott opened an account for Everton.  It was in this way.  Hardman returned a pass from the centre, and we saw a spirited rush by Young and McDermott, who played to each other like jugglers.  On, on they went, until quite near goal, when McDermott thought that the moment had arrived to lift the ball over Clawley’s head into the net.  And he did so.  But Clawley, by saving his charge at short range from Settle and Young, showed that he was a worthy man to hold the fort.  Fraser was again the stormy petrel, but Everton soon proved that the “Saints” were not in the hunt for honours, for they outclassed their opponents, and another goal materialized at the end of about half an hour.  Hardman, ever in the thick of the fray, forced a corner off Benson, and the lithe, large-hearted Blackpool youth dropped that ball in from the flag just like an artist making a long losing hard at billiards.  Settle was supporting the post nearest to Hardman, with his face in that direction and Clawley was near the far post, ready to spring like a panther.  As the ball dropped Settle just brushed it with his hair, and it curled off his cranium round the post.  Clawley advanced with a seven league stride, but he could only just touch the leather.  He could not hold it.  Again and again Hardman boded danger, and again and again Clawley was the savior of the side.  Dainty and Fraser prevented Roose from contracting a chill, but at the interval Everton were still two goals ahead.  The second half was a replica of the first – only more so, as our friends across St. George’s Channel would say.  The “Saints” began well, but they died away, and the home team were nearly always on the aggressive, taking barren corner-kicks and shooting Rugby goals.  But such persistent pressure was certain to meet with its due reward.  This came when Benson let in Settle.  The sturdy Cumbrian-Lancastrian is the wrong man to give half a yard of space, and in a twinkling, he was at the back of Benson, and with an oblique ground drive the ball was spurned into the net twenty minutes after the change of ends.  All interest in the match evaporated with this point, but just before the close Sharp tickled the ball long, beat Houlker and Molyneux, centred, and Settle crashed it into the net for the third time.  Settle has a useful head.  So Everton won by 4-0. 
Had the match ended at half-time I should have been inclined to say that we had seen a splendid and a spirited exhibition of the art of football, but the longer they played the more the “Saints” deteriorated.  The pace was palpably poorer in the latter period, for Everton, had little to gain by piling on goals, and Southampton had given up the ghost.  They had left their hearts in the dressing-room.  Hearts are as necessary as boots with soles worthy of Orlando Furioso.  The tie was far too one-sided to be described as thrilling, but there was much fine football by the Evertonians.  It was generally believed that the game rested with the forwards of the Lancashirians.  They were given every opportunity by the half-backs, and the Everton forwards responded nobly to the occasion, the movements were swift and sinuous, and nearly always goal wards.  The contrast between the two sets of forwards was much marked.  The Southerners forward line of the “Saints” were off and they were never allowed to find it.  The Everton half-backs saw that they rarely had any scone; but the Southampton middlemen failed entirely in their duties.  The only policy for them was to bustle the Everton attacking brigade; but the Southrons had not an ounce of bustle.  If they had, the team as a whole were successful in concealing it.  The only man who tried to bamboozie the home forwards was Houlker.  He remembered the time when as a Blackburn Rover he had many a feud with Sharp.  They had a manly never-say-die duel, and first one and then the other conquered.  Sharp was in fighting trim, and his robustness was much enjoyed because it was so legitimate.  Southampton would have fared better had they had more like Houlker, for even their backs lost their self-possession.  Every man in the Everton eleven excelled himself.  Their footwork was superb, and it would indeed be difficult to point out any pronounced weakness.  Such form as they displayed is calculated to win Cups- and it seems about time for Everton to carry off the most coveted trophy which has twice eluded them like a will-0-the –wisp.  The game was continually opened out by Young in the centre and everything that he did was successful.  The young Scotsman was quite brilliant, his neat passes to McDermott and Settle being only equaled by the way he flashed the ball out to the wings.  It seems hard to bestow more praise on one wing than the other, but Settle was in international form and Hardman a grand partner.  Settle can accomplish so much in so little space, and by his exact timing of a pass he can draw his adversaries to him until Hardman has a clear course.  That is maneuvering.  Hardman reminds me of E.J. Leighton, who used to play for Nottingham Forest.  He is built on the same lines and has the same style, but he is always buzzing about and throwing himself at a man twice his size in the most fearless manner.  He has speed and his centres are right on the goal every time, as Clawley can testify.  Everton have not had a left wing like this since the days of Chadwick and Milward. McDermott, a wizard on the ball, plays his own peculiar game to perfection, but he should lay more forward.  As I have already suggested, Sharp was the hurricane man of the right.  In another year Makepeace will have to be considered by the International Selection Committee.  With a cool head and busy feet he is a most industrious purveyor of passes.  When he understood Fraser this fine outside left found a stumbling block in his path.  Harrison could give Jock Taylor a testimonial.  The Dumbarton veteran never spared his foes, and he played all the ninety minutes, while Abbott plodded along in his cumbersome style and never gave in when he was beaten.  The Everton defence always inspired confidence.  W. Balmer has a style of his own, but his rushes never failed, and time and again he came through with the ball and took it along till he saw who to pass to.  There are occasions when Balmer seems to travel like a whirlwind with his head in his chest.  But his eyes are glued on the ball and anybody in his track has to either give way or fall down.  And yet Balmer is not by any means a rough back.  His judgement is admirable, and Crelley is following in his footsteps.  Once or twice Crelley came to the rescue when there was a possibility in the first half of Southampton being troublesome.  While Roose had an easy hour and a half.  Clawley’s post was not a sinecure. Vigilant and active, he has a splendid reach, and fields well-especially those short, sharp shots, which require so much celerity of movements.  Benson was apt to be flurried and not nearly so reliable as at Wolverhampton, while Molyneux is slow.  Of the half-backs only Houlker played a clever game, and nether Dainty nor Lee made proper use of their physique.  The Southampton forwards were feeble.  Bluff, who has earned so much kudos this season, was merely second rate, Harrison was generally off-side, and Hedley grew tired.  Few chances were given to Webb, but Fraser tried to turn the tide.  Still, single-handed efforts could not be expected to pay.  Southampton certainly met their masters.  Everton; L. R. Roose; Balmer (W.) (Captain), Crelley; Makepeace, Taylor, Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P.Hardman.  Southampton; Clawley; Benson, Molyneux (captain); Lee, Dainty, Houlker; Webb. Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser.  Referee; A.G. Hines, Nottingham. 

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 06 March 1905
Everton fairly excelled themselves in their tie in the third round of the Football Association Cup competition and Southampton were afforded an opportunity of judging what the present leaders of the League can do when on their merits. A continuance of this form means the acquisition of the national trophy, and there is now a splendid chance for the team to store for those disappointments of past days which gained for Everton the reputation of inconsistency. The ground was rather holding on the surface, but this did not seem to affect the home players, who moved about with greater ease and facility than their opponents. There was likewise no comparison between the pair in actual play, and Southampton were beaten quite as decisively as the score of four goals to mil against them seems to demonstrate. From the start Everton played superior football, though Fraser made some commendable efforts and one centre from his foot before either side had scored, left Harrison with only Roose to beat, but he failed to gather the ball. This was the finest opening the Southampton gained in the match which had it been utilised, might have changed the fortunes of the game. Everton, however, were frequently dangerous, and only the fine goalkeeping of Clawley saved his side from an utter rout. When, after seventeen minutes McDermott beat the Southampton custodian, the ball coming to him from Young, who had practically paved the way for the goal, the fate of the visitors was sealed. From this time they were fighting a hopeless battle, and the Everton half-backs never allowed them to get into working order. From a corner kick, well placed by Harrison, Settle got his head to the ball just as Clawley was clutching it, and the second point was credited to the home team. Of the many fine clearances achieved by the visitors’ custodian, one from Young, who headed into goal from almost under the bar, was the best of the afternoon, and how the keeper managed to get the tips of his fingers to the ball almost passes comprehension. The second half was not so interesting as the earlier portion, for the issue was in the safe keeping of Everton, and no one knew it better than the Southerners. Their attempts were spasmodic, and rarely occasioned Roose any anxiety, whereas their own defence was frequently in difficulties. In clearing a long return Benson failed to keep Settle away, and, the latter whipping round, smartly placed the leather into the net. Sharp was somewhat neglected in the later stages but just on time he got the better of a tussle with Houlker and centre so accurately that Settle easily added the fourth goal. There was not a weak spot on the Everton side, and Southampton were unfortunate in finding the Blues at the top of their form. The forward were keen and incisive in their movements and the defence was never at fault. Where all did so well it seems almost invidious to specially mention any individual, but Settle deserve more than passing notice. He was absolutely the finest forward on the field, his best style, and the movements between the three inside players were at times bewildering in their intricacy. Their efforts were ably seconded by the speedy winger Hardman and Sharp whose centres were always boding danger, and the former gave Benson a rare gruelling. The precision and accuracy by which the home forwards repeatedly assailed the Southampton goal was most invigorating to behold, and the footwork was at times as near perfection as it is possible to obtain. Hesitancy there was none, and when once the whole line got fairly under weigh they required some stopping. The only fault in the closing stages was a tendency on the part of McDermott to hold the ball too long, instead of transferring to his partner. Equally effective in their particular sphere were the Everton backs, and the key to the situation was found in the grand exhibition given by the trio of half backs. Abbott has not played such a game for weeks and the crack Southern forward Bluff was initiated into a few mysteries which left him helpless and forlorn. Taylor was the same irresistible force that he has been throughout the season, and he simply smothered Harrison, who was never able to get his forward moving in anything like connected fashion. Makepeace had an awkward opponents to deal with in Fraser, but he never faltered and maintained the high impression which has been formed of his abilities. The utmost sympathy prevailed between this lone and the members of the front rank, and the ball was transferred from one to another with remarkable accuracy and with the greatest ease and judgement. Further in the rear Balmer shaped like an international, and he timed his clearances with commendable skill, whilst Crelley was equally effective, and the pair presented an almost impenetrable barrier to their opponents. Roose had a few shots to deal with, but in comparison with his vis-à-vis he had a very easy afternoon. The Southern Leaguers were very disappointing and they never seemed likely to gain even a share of the honours. In the forward line there were occasions when glimpses of what must be their real form was witnessed but their movements were badly finished, and almost invariably terminated in some ignominious fashion before they could get within shooting distance. When they were at Wolverhampton a fortnight are they gave a splendid exhibition but they met a trio of half backs at Goodison Park that never gave them the slightest chance of drawing away, whilst their defence was unceasingly battered by the overwhelming advances of the home forwards. This gave the visitors intermediate line little opportunity of settling down to judicious action with the men in front of them, and only Houlker came out of the ordeal with credit, for the others were commonplace. Molyneux was the better of the backs for Benson was erratic, and hesitated in clearing his lines. The outstanding feature in defence was Clawley, and it was no disgrace to him to be beaten only four times. He saved some shots that appeared almost impossible to reach and in the first half especially displayed keeping of the highest order. Everton are now landed in the penultimate stage, and they have only to reproduce the same form to go even further. Whatever be the result of the draw this evening, there are two splendid ties assured, and it would be a capital arrangement should Everton and the Villa clear each other and meet in the final. It is eight years since they last met at the Crystal Palace, when the Villa won by 3 goals to 2 all the points being gained in the first thirty five minutes. Given the opportunity of avenging this defeat, it is not too much to expect that Everton will accomplish it in no uncertain manner.
Attendance 41,000 Receipts £1,612

SOUTHAMPTON SETTLED
Liverpool Echo - Monday 06 March 1905
EVERTON’S MASTERLY EXHIBITION IN THE CUP, THIRD ROUND
NOT ONE WEAK SPOT
By Bee
The 41,000 people at Goodison Park on Saturday saw Everton simply swamp their opponents in the third round of the Football Association Cup tie by a score of 4 goals to nil-the same record as was registered against Stoke in the previous round. Those supporter’s who did not go to the Potteries can gauge what they missed, for Saturday’s display was almost identical to that against the Saints. Southampton came with the reputation of having beaten Wolverhampton at Molineux and Millwall in the earlier rounds, together with the Southern League champions. Therefore we were bound to have a great respect for them, even though we were playing on our own ground. What a dismal upset of calculations! We looked for a keen contest-one in which honours might have ended evenly, or else for a margin of the narrowest possible. However, Everton straightaway got into their stride which always means that a defence be labelled “great” if it can hold up against them when in this happy mood. Almost immediately after the ball had been set rolling (with Everton having the very material advantage of having the sun at their backs) McDermott put in a shot. This was indeed a hopeful starting sign, and it was followed by most excellent work- and results. McDermott got the first goal after a quarter of an hour had passed. Hardman was the initiator of the movement. He put in one of his accurate centres, and when Young received he quickly passed out to his wing man and Clawley was beaten in quicker time than it takes to tell. Had Young or McDermott delayed their movements one second the point would probably not have come. It is a delightful duty to report that the forwards concerned did not dally one moment, for herein lies the crux of goal-getting, and its benefits were richly reaped on Saturday by the Blues, who once set on the road to success, marched like victors and swept the enemy  clean away. It was an extremely clean sweep, for four times was the Southampton goalkeeper passed, and even so he might quite easily have had another four points added to his record. Clawley in one of the best custodians in the country, and not one iota of complaint can be laid at his door for the heavy defeat, the goals would have nonplussed any custodian, and besides, he saved some stinging shots, many of them long teasers, which are always troublesome to get away. Settle eclipsed all previous performances. He got three goals, and tried his level best to put the ball so that Hardman might get one off his own bat. After Saturday’s excellence it would not surprise me if Settle were chosen to represent his country once again. Certainly he has been most consistent in his play, and he is well up in the table in the matter of goal-scorers. Without Settle and Blues’ forward line seems incompetent; with the veteran in the ranks an influence for good appears. There is a lot in personality, you know, and Settle’s personality has a deal to do with the Everton forward fortunes. Bravo, Settle! A right down brilliant afternoon’s work, and well rewarded. Only in the early stages of the game did the home line show slight trace’s of hesitancy, and it was just in these moments that Houlker shone so resplendently. He does not mind “saddlers,” that is a certainty. When Everton did grip the game properly, there was absolutely no holding them, and it became almost pitiable to see the way the Everton man were toying with them just as they pleased. How much did the winning side owe to accurate passing and sharper attacks as against former dallying? Young opened out the game in most advantageous manner. He did nothing starting individually; but as a unit of a fine line he played his part almost perfectly, his marksmanship being rather at fault. The right and left wing were about on a par, all four men being in deadly form. As a division they romped around the bewildered Soton halves, and mastered their rivals times without number. McDermott has struck a capital Cup-tie vein. He might have given Sharp more opportunities in the last quarter of an hour. In the last minute he sent out to the cricketer-footballer, and, in characteristic style, Sharp tripped along right merrily, and gave Settle the chance to chalk up the fourth goal. It is a sign of the geniality of the players one to another when one sees them not only shake hands with an congratulate the scorers of a goal, but also the member who worked the opening. To Sharp and Hardman these instances of appreciation must have been extremely pleasant. Half-back our men were as usual though Makepeace found a regular Tartar in Fraser, a man of splendid physique, smart in sprinting, and able to use his feet ibn tricky fashion. At back, also “as usual,” Balmer and Crelley were beyond reproach, while Leigh Roose had only one shot of any sting during the whole of the game. Southampton’s form could not have been true. But Everton make many a renowned club’s form look untrue by their remarkably fine forward play and staunch defence. So it was on Saturday. The Sotons met their masters and were hopelessly out of the bunt from the time Settle brushed in that corner so nicely placed by Hardman. Clawley saved them from a much heavier defeat, for the home forwards plied him with long shots, short shots, and shots from all angles, even the backs taking it upon themselves to attempt to augment the score. During the latter half it was an incessant bombarding of the visitors’ goal. Molyneux was the better back, but this does not imply much, for Benson was flabby and unreliable. Houlker was the best of the halves, and Fraser of the forwards, but as a combination they were a motley crew- on Saturday’s form, of course. The ground was well filled, and every credit is due to the officials in charge for the able manner in which the undertaking was carried through. Even the poorly-clad old dame of quite sixty summers, near the Press box, could see quite easily, while one fellow with a broken arm didn’t keep away from such a promising match. Seaforth soldiers helped to make the scene all the more bright, and the band might have done  likewise only they were so gentle is their efforts. One of the “Hatters” causes amusement by trotting on to the field and wishing Balmer the best of fortune. This innovation is not to be commended. The two S’s have been wiped off the Cup slate in decisive manner. Would it not be strange if Everton were drawn against the only remaining S-Sheffield Wednesday? The tie would be extremely popular and interesting, because a trial run could be witnessed on Saturday next, the teams meeting then. The Woolwich home fixture and away encounter with Everton have had to be put off, together with the Nottingham Forest match, so that the Blues will have their work cut out to fulfil their programme in the required time. It will means a heavy strain on the players; but here’s the best wish for them in their endeavours. Never before has there been a semi-final in which stronger clubs appeared. Everton, Newcastle, Villa and Sheffield Wednesday or Preston- a combination worthy of the Cup. Whoever succeeds, there must be a grand final round.
THE GATES
The grounds at Everton, Birmingham and Bolton were taxed to their utmost capacity to accommodate the vast crowds anxious to participate in the proceedings. At Deepdale, however, the number of visitors was insignificant compared with the others. This, no doubt, was in consequence of the Preston club authorities making 1s the lowest charge for admission,
Attendance and receipts
Aston Villa 47,000 £1,634
Everton v Southampton 41,000 £1,618
Bolton Wan v Newcastle 45,000 £1.471 15s 6d
Preston v Sheffield W. 12,000 £625

ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL MATCH AT WREXHAM
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 07 March 1905
WALES v  SCOTLAND
For the first time since the institution of matches between the two committee under Association rules. Wales yesterday at Wrexham succeeded in beating Scotland. They won by three goals to one, and thoroughly deserved their victory, which naturally aroused great enthusiasm among the 6,000 people who assembled on the racecourse to witness the struggle. Although rather windy the weather otherwise proved favourable and the ground if a little soft, was in fair condition. In addition to the two changes in the Welsh team which had been previously announced, an alteration had to be made in each side yesterday, Kennedy taking the place of Quinn as centre-forward for Scotland, and Davies coming into the home eleven in place of Atherton who was suffering from influenza Davies being an outside right, Meredith went inside. Assisted by the wind in the opening half, Scotland had a good deal the better of the early stages, and had not Roose been in fine form between the posts they must have run up[ a score which would have placed the issue beyond doubt. But the Welsh goalkeeper defended admirable saving cleverly in the first twenty minutes from Kennedy and Walker and twice from Robertson the shots sent in by the last named severely testing Roose, who had to handle on several other occasions. The Welsh forwards did not often get very far, but there was an understanding between their inside forwards which the Scottish front rank, with much individual skill, lacked. A pass from Templeton to Kennedy led to a scramble in front of the Welsh goal, and Roose being unable to get to the ball it was very lucky for Wales that it should have rolled over the line just outside the post. An injury kept Robertson off the field for a few minutes, and it was during that player’s absence that Wales met with their first success. The point was almost entirely the work of Granville Morris, who dribbled through very nearly and centred to Watkins, who, at close range, sent the ball into the net, just inside the post. Davies nearly gained a second goal, and a corner to Wales followed, but then the Scotchmen, who were three times pulled up for fouls, forced several corners, from one of which Roose was desperately hard put to save his charge. Still at half time Wales could claim a lead of 1 goal to nil. Within two minutes of the resumption the home side secured their second point, Granville Morris, who shortly before the interval, had been badly kicked, dribbling into a good position and scoring with a low shot at fully twenty yards range. For some time after this the Scotchmen kept the play well in their opponents half, but although they forced several corners, it cannot be said that they were often dangerous. At length Wales roused themselves and after a goal by Watkins had been properly disallowed. Morris hit the bar. The ball came out to Davies, who centred and Meredith rushed it into the net. Less than a quarter of an hour remained when this occurred. Directly afterwards Scotland met with their only success. It followed upon a free kick, and was obtained by Robertson with a long shot. Roose got his hands to the ball, but failed to prevent it going through. Except that E. Hughes nearly beat Rennie, the subsequent play produced no remarkable incident, and Wales were left with a victory by 3 goals to 1., for their success the Welshmen were mainly indebted to Granville Morris, who at inside left played a superb game.
Wales.- L.R. Roose (Everton), goal; H. Blew (Wrexham) and C. Morris (Derby County), backs; G. Latham (Liverpool), E. Hughes (Tottenham Hotspur), and J. Hughes (Liverpool), half-backs; Arthur Davies (Middlesbrough), W. Mereditth (Manchester City), M. W. Watkins (Sunderland), A.G. Morris (Notts Forest), and A. Oliver (Ranger), forwards.
Scotland.- H. Rennie (Hibernians), goal; Jackson (St. Mirren), and A. McCombie (Newcastle United), backs; A. Aitken (Newcastle United), C. Thomson (Heart of Midlothians), and J. Robertson (Rangers), half-backs; B. Templeton (Woolwich Arsenal), H. Walker (Heart of Midlothian), Kennedy (Patrick Thistles), T.T. Fitchie (Woolwich Arsenal), and A. Smith (Rangers), forwards. Referee T. Kirkham (Bursley)
Results of Past Matches
1876- Glasgow, Scotland won by 4-0
1877- Wrexham-Scotland won by 2 to 0
1878-Glasgow-Scotland won by 9 top 0
1879- Wrexham-Scotland won by 3 to 0
1880- Glasgow- Scotland won by 5 to 1
1881- Wrexham-Scotland won by 5 to 1
1882- Glasgow -Scotland won by 5 to 0
1883-Wrexham- Scotland won by 3 to 0
1884- Glasgow-Scotland won by 4 to 1
1885- Wrexham-Scotland won by 8 to 1
1886- Glasgow-Scotland won by 4 to 1
1887-Wrexham-Scotland won by 2 to 1
1888- Edinburgh- Scotland won by 5 to 1
1889-Wrexham- Drawn-no score
1890-Paisley- Scotland won by 5 to 1
1891-Wrexham- Scotland won by 4 to 3
1892-Edinburgh-Scotland won by 6 to 1
1893-Wrexham-Scotland won by 8 to 0
1894- Kilmarnock- Scotland won by 5 to 2
1895- Wrexham -Drawn 2-2
1898-Motherwell- Scotland won by 5 to 2
1899-Wrexham- Scotland won by 6 to 0
1900-Aberdeen- Scotland won by 5 to 2
1901-Wrexham- Drawn 1 goal each
1902- Greenock-Scotland won by 5 to 1
1903-Cardiff-Scotland won by 1 to nil
1904-Dundee, Drawn 1 goal each
WALES TEAM v  ENGLAND
The following team was chosen at Wrexham last night to represent Wales;- L.R Roose (Everton), goal; H. Blew (Wrexham), and C. Morris (Derby County), backs; M. Parry (Liverpool), Hughes (Hotspurs), and J. Hughes (Liverpool), half-backs; W. Meredith (Manchester City), R. Atherton (Middlesbrough), M. Watkins (Sunderland), Granville Morris (Notts Forest), and A. Oliver (Bangor), forwards.

FOOTBALL FRAGMENTS
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 07 March 1905
By Bee
Everton v Villa! So we are denied the pleasure of seeing them meet in the final tie at Crystal Palace. It is unfortunate, in sense, for many ardent followers of the Blues had anticipated that Everton would turn the tables on the Villa for that knock-back of 1897, when everyone present agreed that finer football had never before been given in a final tie. Certainly since that year there has been no equal of it. Many enthusiasts let themselves dream a stage further. They saw the band heralding the Blues after the final round had ended with the wicked Villain put in a cell of despair! That portion of the dream which refers to Everton landing the Cup is very palatable, and I, for one, am going to stand on their going right through this year’s Cup tourney without one defeat, though of course, more than one meeting between the Brums and themselves might be necessary before a definite result was obtained. At this stage it is too early to weigh up chances, but there can be no harm in talking the matter over- and suggesting that a drawn game at Stoke on March 25 is the most likely result. Everton will go on the field with the happy recollection that Stoke were ousted by them in the second round, and that they pierced an ex-Villa custodian’s charge four times on that occasion. With each successive draw the Everton tie has been dubbed “the tit-bit of the round,” and here again, in the last stage but one, the same description must be adopted; the match in which Lancashire centres her hope (for Preston are not likely to defeat the Wednesday on Thursday) is by common consent the more exciting and open of the two.
The following players were selected to represent the English League against the Scottish League. The match will be played in Glasgow next Saturday;- Linacre (Notts Forest), goal; Spencer (Aston Villa) and Burgess (Manchester City), backs; Wolstenholme (Blackburn Rovers), Roberts (Manchester United), and Leake (Aston Villa), half-backs; Stokes (Bolton Wanderers), Bloomer (Derby County), Parkinson (Liverpool), Bache (Aston Villa), and Hardman (Everton), forwards. Veitch (Newcastle United), reserve. Referee, Mr. Risbotham (Irish League).

AS OTHERS VIEW THE SEMI-FINAL
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 08 March 1905
By Bee
It is interesting to note what Everton’s opponents think of their chances in the semi-final tie, due on March 25 at Stoke. Mr. McGregor has written the following;-
 If I had been given the choice of the Villa’s opponents in the semi-final I believe I would have selected Everton. Whenever the sides meet one is assured of a ding-dong game and there is never much to choose between the teams. Both play the same style of game, and both are generally successful when playing at home so that on a neutral enclosure a rattling game may be looked for. If the Villa put the same earnestness and, so once into their play as they have been doing recently, however, I shall expect to see then in the final on the 15th April. As we have such dark designs on the Palace, it may be interesting if I state that the Sydenham venue has been much improved lately. New stands have been erected, one at each side of the pavilion, and the bank near the waterfall has been terraced after the style of the Villa enclosure. Before another year is over we may see the whole ground terraced on the principle. Not only in London, but further South, there is a general hope, now that the Cup cannot go to any of their clubs, that the Villa will appear in the final. We must not overlook Everton’s performance on Saturday. In my mind it ranks before that of the Villa, because Southampton are a stronger side than Fulham, and are a good Cup-fighting team. The Villa must strain every nerve to keep themselves fit, for they will need to be in tip-top condition in order to secure success at Stoke.” Mr. Heath, of the Staffordshire Association in reference to the accommodation of the Stoke F.C  ground, says that since 1897 the ground has been enlarged to the extent of twenty-five yards behind each of the goal-posts, and 50,000 people can be accommodated. This is now doubt true. Nevertheless, the accommodation at Victoria ground does not strike me as at all adequate to hold a crowd such as is likely to appear there on March 25. In answer to inquirers, I may say that the enclosure is quite close to the station.

FOOTBALL ITEMS
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 09 March 1905
Everton have a stiff task before them. They have, before the season ends to rearrange home and away dates with Woolwich Arsenal, away date with Nottingham Forest, and the final tie Lancashire Cup with Southport Central.
Should they go through to the final of the English Cup the Small Heath (home) fixture will have to be put off to another day.  A. Goodall is severing his connection with Glossop.

RANKIN, OUTSIDE LEFT
Liverpool Echo - Thursday 09 March 1905
EVETON FOOTBALL TEAM TO MEET THE WEDNESDAY
By Bee
There is a vast amount of interest centred in the visit of Sheffield Wednesday to Goodison Park on Saturday, for not only are the Wednesday welcomed because of their consistent League record, but because local people are anxious to see if there is to be a repetition of the first meeting between the two clubs. At Owlerton, on November 12, Everton had the extraordinary pleasure of recording no fewer than five goals in the first “45” Everyone recollects what happened in the second portion of the game, when Scott was injured and had to retire from the field of play (this accident had the effect of causing the directors to sign on Roose on the following Friday evening), and the Wednesday actually levelled matters up by recording five goals. This memorable match must surely make the Everton brigade more determined than ever to gain the full number of points possible on Saturday, and generally speaking favouritism will rest with Everton to win. This year has, so far, been a long run of success for them- not at all times merited, perhaps yet one must not blot out from one’s mind the tantalising luck they experienced in the early days of the season.
AN EARLY LEAD
Their results for the year worthy of reproduction;-
Liverpool (local Cup), away 1-4
Sheffield United (league) away 0-2
Preston North End (League) away 1-1
Middlesbrough (League) home 1-0
Liverpool (English Cup) away 1-1
Liverpool (Replayed tie) home 2-1
Bury (League) home 2-0
Stoke (English Cup) away, 4-0
Blackburn Rovers (League) home 1-0
Southampton (English Cup), home 4-0
Goals -For 17, against 9
Even these figures must not allow the Everton players to “pull up.” They will have to play hard and fast for the whole ninety minutes to beat their guests, who have surprised Blackburn (1-0), Bury (4-1), Villa (2-0), and Middlesbrough (3-1) on their own grounds, while the County could do no more than draw with them before the Nottingham crowd. The Wednesday are to-day figuring in Cup warfare, and this may have a detrimental effect on their staying powers. Still, the Blues should strain sternly to get an early lead; no side in the country plays a finer winning game. I have often urged for a showing of “that ounce of dash,” and now I add in my plea, “That early goal”-not a great deal to ask for. A change in the home ranks is necessitated by the inclusion of Hardman in the English League side. Rankin has been called upon to fill the vacancy. He was played at outside right last season several times, and it will be interesting to keep an eye on him against the Blades to see how he shapes in the unaccustomed position.

FRANK BRETTELL
Bournemouth Daily Echo - Friday 10 March 1905
Mr. Frank Brettell has been appointed "consulting expert" to Plymouth Argyle.  The directors of the Devonshire club have inaugurated an office which I think is most desirable.  Argyle are now advertising -for a new secretary-manager.

FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Friday 10 March 1905
At Owlerton on November 12, Everton had the extraordinary pleasure of recording no fewer than five goals in the first “45” Everyone recollects what happened in the second portion of the game, when Scott was injured and had to retire from the field of play (this accident had the effect of causing the directors to sign on Roose on the following Friday evening), and the Wednesday actually levelled matters up by recording five goals. This memorable match must surely make the Everton brigade more determined than ever to gain the full number of points possible tomorrow, and, generally speaking favouritism will rest with Everton to win. This year has, so far been a long run of success for them- not at all times merited, perhaps, yet one must not blot out from one’s mind the tantalising luck they experienced in the early days of the season.

SERIOUS FOOTBALL PROGRAMME FOR THE MORROW
Liverpool Echo - Friday 10 March 1905
By Bee
The English League-Scottish League will deplete the ranks of a number of the clubs. Hardman’s absence may not be seriously felt, and as Sheffield Wednesday, Everton’s opponents have been hard worked this week in the cup-tie, the home team should win without doubt, especially if McDermott brings out his shooting boots. George Molyneux stayed over the week-end in Liverpool, and expressed the opinion that he had never in all his career played against a finer forward than McDermott, Jock Robertson, the Ranger, who was present at the swamping of Southampton last week declared that he could not see how a Scottish selection committee could pass over our inside-right for International caps. This is high praise but well merited by the player-on Saturday’s form; a continuance of such form being assumed of recognition.

EVERTON 5 SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY 2
March 11, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
EVERTON AWARDED THREE PENALTYS KICKS
HARVEST OF GOALS.
The two League meetings of Everton and Sheffield Wednesday this season have been remarkable in at least one respect. They have produced an unusually heavy crop of goals. When Everton visited Owerton-park on the 12 th November an extraordinary game was witnessed. The Blues led at the interval by five goals to one, and so clever was the football exhibited that the easiest possible victory seemed in store for them. An injury to Scott however, changed the scene, and in the last minute or so of play the Blades equalised the scores. Ten goals was thus the product on that occasion. Last Saturday's contest was not quite so prolific, but still seven goals accrued, Everton this time claiming five to Wednesday's two.
AN INTERESTING FIRST HALF
Although Hardman was away at Glasgow assisting the English League, Everton were not so seriously handicapped as the League champions who, owing to injuries, were short of Ruddlesdin and Chapman. Consequently the chances all seemed to be in favour of a win for the League leaders. Everton, however, exhibited no marked superiority during the opening half. They were the cleverer side, it is true, but only goals count, and the record was even when the whistle blew for the breathing interval. Everton ought to have led, but Makepeace, who made for himself a reputation as a safe negotiator of penalty kicks , for once, in a way failed to find the net. (Crawshaw fouling Settle). After this let off Brittleton, the Wednesday's capture from Stockport County managed to get the better of Roose, and singularly enough, the equalising point was the outcome of another Penalty kick , which the referee only allowed after consulting one of the linesmen. Abbott tried to succeed where his comrade had failed, but he was only partially responsible for the goal. He banged the ball against Lyall. Happily Sharp got to it before the custodian could recover himself, and landed it in the net, (Crawshaw fouled Young) to the great delight of the crowd.
SENSATIONAL SCORING.
The opening part of the second half was of a nature, which roused the utmost enthusiasm. Barley had the ball been kicked off from the centre than Makepeace robbed an opponent so trickily that when Young fastened on to it, he had to shoot correctly to give Everton the lead. He did his work gallantly, and only a minute or two later the Everton centre earned further commendation by an even more brilliant effort, which absolutely non-plussed the Shefiield custodian. After this play suffered somewhat owing to a tendency on the part of certain of the visiting players to adopt unfair tactics. Still the Blades did not give in, and with Roose tempted out of his goal Davis seized the opportunity to good effect, thereby making up for some previous mistakes. Yet another penalty kick for deliberate handling McDermott cross, fell to Everton, with the result that Makepeace, having recovered confidence, put on the fourth goal. Not to be outdone, the veteran Taylor added a fifth, and so superior were the home side that with luck they might have still further increased their crop of goals.
IS IT A RECORD?
For a side to give away three penalty kicks in a First League match is, if we mistake not, a record. Certainly the fact is worth mention, especially as it was the boast of Sheffield Wednesday last season that not a single penalty was awarded against them. But, apart from these always more or less unsatisfactory goals, Everton thoroughly deserved their victory. They have played more brilliant games, but there was a felling of confidence about their movements, which never suggested the probability of ultimate defeats. Young's two goals were as fine as one expects to see, and with the forwards all eager to gain distinction, and the half-backs on their best behaviors, no wonder the Blades experienced difficulties. Yet they showed real grit at times, and gave one the impression that sheer merit has taken them into the semi-final of the English Cup. It is likely Everton and Sheffield Wednesday will contest the final at the Crystal Palace. Teams: - Everton: - Roose goal, W.Balmer (captain), and Crelly backs, Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott half-backs Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Rankin forwards. Sheffield Wednesday: - Lyall, goal, Slavin and Burton, backs, Ferrier, Crawshaw (captain), and Barleyy, half-backs Davis, Brittleton, Wilson Stewart, and Simpson forwards. Referee T.S.Heath.

THE ASSOCIATION CUP
Hampshire Independent - Saturday 11 March 1905
EVERTON v  SOUTHAMPTON
Played at Goodison Park, Everton, on Saturday, in fine weather, the teams lining out as under;-
Southampton- Clawley, goal; Benson and Molyneux (captain), backs; Lee, Dainty, and Houlker, half-backs; Webb, Bluff, Harrison, Hedley, and Fraser, forwards.
Everton; Roose, goal; W. Balmer (captain) and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Referee- Mr. A.G. Hines. Linesmen; Mr. J.R. Schumacher and Mr. M. T. Roberts.
Molyneux had to toss with his old partner Balmer, and as they were about to throw the coin an enterprising photographer snap-shotted them. Balmer was successful, and the Saints had to face a bright sun. At the start there was a spirited duel on the Saints' left wing. A position was seized in the home quarter, but offside against Fraser brought Everton relief. However, one of the halves handled, and Southampton were able to gain a place of advantage. Dainty assayed a shot, which went wide, and then Crelly kicked out as Webb was about to centre. Everton worked down, hugging the touch-line, and forced a way into the penalty area, where McDermott shot, Cawley punched away brilliantly. Sharp next did a clever trick, sending the ball over his head. An infringement by a colleague, however, nullified the effort, and then the Saints progressed, the ball eventually going behind. Everton were very nippy, and were more often in possession of the ball than Southampton, but the latter were quirk to tackle. Lee and Molyneux distinguished themselves in this respect. Harrison tried to burst through, but was held, and the home player settled down to aggressive work. Their right wing displayed great activity. Fortunately Molyneux was reliable and equal to emergencies. A brilliant incident followed. Hedley cut an opening for Fraser, who centred accurately. Harrison stood in the goalmouth unattended, but the ball as it bounced broke away, and when Hedley tried to retrieve, his shot was charged down. The Everton forwards retaliated, and were very dangerous, when Houlker tackled Sharp and cleared. A misfire by Webb soon after gave the home left possession. Hardman centred with precision, and Sharp trapped the ball close in. Luckily for the Saints he stepped over the ball, and Molyneux pounced on him before he could recover. However, the slip made little difference, for a few minutes later McDermott ran through, and staving off two attempts to tackle him, SHOT A SPLENDID GOAL after sixteen minutes. Fraser made spirited efforts, but the other men were not at all comfortable, and what was worse, Bluff was lame. Everton pressed severely, and only a magnificent effort by Clawley saved the charge. At length Dainty raised the siege. Then Fraser performed very cleverly, beating Balmer thrice in succession. Moreover he centred well, but the inside men couldn't turn his centres to account. Everton were much more dangerous in front of goal, and for the third time Clawley cleared when a goal appeared certain. Play was in the Southampton half for the greater part of the time, and Molyneux once accidentally diverted a terrific shot. Houlker had some warm duels with Sharp, and kicked into touch in self-defence, while Lee headed out from under the bar. Immediately after Clawley effected another great save, again from McDermott, who was deed on the target. The Saints made a spasmodic rush, Harrison being eventually robbed, and there ensued another onslaught on the Saints' goal, which terminated in a free kick being given against a home player. By dint of hard work, and chiefly through the instrumentality of Hedley, Dainty and Lee the Saints gained a footing at the other end. Bluff took a pot shot and missed. Then Lee yielded a corner. Hardman placed the ball admirably, and Settle seemed to bounce the ball out of Clawley's grasp, and it entered the net, GIVING EVERTON THEIR SECOND GOAL.
On the restart, the Saints made a vigorous burst, which, like their previous attempts, ended in smoke. Away went Everton again, and it was the luckiest thing in the world that the Saints' citadel escaped. The home team were all over the Saints. There was no mistaking the fact, but the Southerners were triers, and it was hard, downright hard plugging on their part that prevented further disaster. After a brief stoppage through injury to Crelly, the home left wing advanced, but were checked by the joint efforts of Lee and Dainty. However, the pressure on the Southampton goal was sustained, and hot play occurred in front of Clawley, whose marvellous defence alone kept down the score. Dainty in the succeeding play gave Roose a handful, which was negotiated, whilst Hedley had a terrific half-volley, which was going into the net as straight as an arrow, accidentally averted. Interval—Everton 2 Saints 0
On opening the second half Houlker dribbled through, and passed to Hadley, who slipped the ball forward for Harrison, but Balmer was first. Still the Saints succeeded in making progress. The leather was taken on the right, and a hold gained in the Everton quarter, but Harrison dallied until he was robbed. Lee beat a couple of opponents and transferred to Webb, whose centre cleared, and then Settle and Hardman manoeuvred effectively, being eventually checked by the former infringing the offside rule. The Saints were doing better than in the first half, being more methodical in their work, but they could not do anything with the home half-backs. Play of a close and determined character took place inside the Southampton half, and Hardman gained a clear course, Benson diverted his centre at the expense of a corner, from which McDermott headed over. A free kick enabled the Southrons to eject the Everton forwards, and the opportunity was used to run into the home quarters, where Roose cleared a centre by Webb. This was just a fleeting glimpse that the Saints obtained, and the next minute Everton were in full cry towards Clawley. Sharp presented his colleagues with the easiest of chances, but both Settle sad Hardman missed. At this stage the First Leaguers resumed their pronounced superiority. Their individual touches were wonderfully clever, end they maintained perfect touch with each other. They failed to score because their shooting had deteriorated to some extent.  When the Saints at a subsequent period trooped over the neutral line Harrison was whistled off-side, and following a free kick that ensued, Hardman forced off Lee a corner that was abortive. Pegging away, the Everton vanguard fairly cornered the opposing defence, and it was a great bit of play on Houlker's part that prevented Settle adding a third goal. We next saw Southampton steal a dozen yards at a time on the left, eventually gaining a corner through Roose inadvertently kicking behind at a nudge from Bluff. This concession brought no tangible result; indeed Everton broke loose from a cordon, and Benson was compelled to kick into his own quarter. The throw in saw Everton make further headway, and finally Settle nipped between the backs and PUT THE ISSUE BEYOND DOUBT with a fast hot shot. Southampton could now only strive to keep the deficit within respectable dimensions, and this they pluckily tried to attain. Dainty made a capital effort to reduce
the margin, but shot over the bar. Everton continued to have by far the larger slice of the play, Sharp being particularly noticeable for clever play. Molyneux was up to most of his tricks though, and kept him at a safe distance. A diversion very welcome to the Saint,' partisans now occurred, but once more Harrison was given offside. Abbott next gave Clawley a ripping shot to negotiate, which the custodian did cleverly. In the last stages the Saints were completely outplayed, and furthermore they could do nothing right. A minute from the end Settle scored the fourth goal from Sharp's centre.
Final, Everton 4 Southampton 0
GATE RECEIPTS
The gate realised £1,612

EVERTON v  SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 11 March 1905
LEAGUE DIVISION 1
By Pigeon Post and Telephone
BRITTLETON SCORES FOR WEDNESDAY
ONE GOAL EACH AT HALF TIME
Every season introduces to us some game or other which in its sensational incidents entitles it to historical importance as far as football annuals are concerned. When Wednesday and Everton met at Owlerton last year on November 12 the Blues gave their hosts a rare lesson in netting the leather, and at the interest a great victory seemed assured to Everton, who led by five good goals to one. But it was not to be, and the almost impossible happened. Scott had to vacate his citadel owing to injuries, and to the amazement and delight of the Sheffielders’ supporters the Blades drew level and shared points at the close. Although it was unfortunate for Everton, it showed the grit of the Wednesday, nevertheless Everton were not likely to-day to forget that most thrilling episode, nor lose the opportunity of paying the Sheffielders off that old scores. The relative position of the clubs in the League tables justified the home supporters in taking a very sanguine view of today’s encounter, as the Wednesday have only scored 27 points against Everton’s 36 and furthermore the Blues have shown such a sequence of brilliant form that they were extremely unlikely to court defeat in their own cockpit. The Sheffield supporters were buoyed up with the knowledge that their men occupy just as prominent a position as the Evertonians in the English Cup competition; in fact to-day’s game might be taken as some criterion of the relative merits of the teams if Fate should ordain that they meet in the final at the Crystal Palace. But many things may happen before April 15. To-day’s struggle promised to be a severe one, as the heavy rains overnight and this morning rendered the ground very holding.
Everton.- Roose, goal; Balmer (captain) and Crelly, back; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Rankin, forwards.
Sheffield Wednesday.- Lyall, goal; Slavin and Burton, backs; Terrier, Crawshaw (captain), and Bartlett, half-backs; Davies, Brittleton, Wilson, Stewart, and Simpson, forwards.
Referee; Mr. T. Heape.
At the start of the game the weather had turned out beautifully fine, although the wind was very high. There were about 15,000 people on the ground when Young kicked-off, facing the wind and sun. the early moves of the game were noticeable for the fine half-back play of Taylor and Makepeace and the persistency of Burton and Bartlett. The first-named Sheffielder at last succeeded in driving the ball forward, and it travelled to Roose who at once returned to midfield. Rankin then had a couple of chances of making progress on his wing, but his methods were faulty. On the other wing Sharp travelled smartly, and finished with a glorious centre, but Lyall punched the ball away. Pretty combination came from Makepeace, Abbott, Sharp, and Settle, but Bartlett did not like the turn of affairs, and kicked out to save further developments. Wednesday  got the best of the throw in, and their left got the better of Makepeace, Stewart putting across to Wilson, Balmer tackled, but kicked on to Wilson near the goalmouth, and as the Sheffield centre forward recovered himself matters looked very ominous, Crelly, however, rapidly summed up the situation and dashing in relieved the tension. After the Blades made a couple of able efforts on either wing. Brittleton winding up a long which sent the leather sailing sky high. Everton then got down on the left, and again on the right where Stavin conceded a corner to Sharp, and a stiff bombardment of the Wednesday goal resulted in Settle heading over the bar. The Sheffielders run the ball out on the right, and when further headway was made Crelly repelled the attack. The ball went to Sharp, who in playing to Makepeace, lost possession. Taylor recovered the position, and then Settle received the leather, but hesitated to shoot, being evidently under the impression that he was offside. When he essayed to pierce the goal his effort was of no use. Abbott followed with a lunge forward, but this likewise went astray; but shortly afterwards Settle was putting in some very fine work, when he was roughly attended to by Crawshaw and Burton, and between them they brought the little Everton man down in a foul manner, the outcome being the usual penalty. This was entrusted to Makepeace. Lyal came out to the full extent and when Makepeace made his effort the Sheffielder suddenly ducked, and whether the ball went out off the goalkeeper or was carried by the wind, is not quite certain, but this was Makepeace’s first miss. The Everton front rank then got fair into their stride, and Rankin presented Young with a most promising opening, but the centre of the Blues responded with an ineffective miskick, and very soon after he was again at fault in heading away a smart return by Makepeace. Then Wednesday dashed away on their left, Simpson and Stewart meeting with little opposition, and Bartlett, chipping in, made matters look worse, until Balmer effected a timely clearance. The next move came from the homesters, but it was very clumsy in conception, and at the finish Lyall cleared at his leisure. At last the smart dashes of the Blades met with success, as a grand combined move all along the line fairly penned the defence up, and Brittleton, lying behind the crowd, took possession, and giving Roose no chance, opened the score after half an hour’s play. Soon afterwards another most incisive attack came from the Sheffield left, and when well down the field the ball went back to Ferrier, who sent in a terrific shot, which rebounded off Roose. Davis followed up, and put the ball over the bar when he had practically nothing to bear, the visitors thus losing a grand opportunity when Everton were well beaten. At the other end Settle gave a fine pass to Young, whose shot was stopped by Lyall. Young appeared to be well placed a minute or two later, when he was fouled by Crawshaw, and another penalty was given against the Owlerton contingent. This was taken by Abbott Lyall stopped the shot, but before he could recover himself Sharp had raced round him and netted the leather, thus bringing his side on an equality, equalisation was very acceptable to the crowd after the miss by Makepeace. Immediately after restarting Sharp nearly added number two with a tricky ground shot which was only inches wide of the mark. Sharp continued to play with wonderful and initiated some fine openings from which Settle and Rankin peppered Wednesday’s defence for some minutes, and as a wind up Sharp made another splendid effort which again very nearly proved successful. The cricketer was undoubtedly in fine form, and all his work was carried out with grand dash and resolution, whilst his shooting was superb. Abbott next took possession and put across to Settle, who supplied Young, but the referee promptly pulled up Everton’s pass for offside. Nothing daunted Wednesday were frequently in the van and their attacks always had an extremely dangerous look about them. Some busting play then took place in Everton quarters owing to a smart bit of play by Simpson and Stewart, the last named getting in a shot which Roose saved. Everton made ground on two occasions along the left wing, but the Sheffield defence prevailed.
Half-time; Everton 1 goal, Sheffield Wednesday 1 goal
EVERTON FORWARDS IN RARE FORM
EXCITING OPENING WORK
THREE PENALTY KICKS
MAKEPEACE MISSES ONE
SHARP MAKES AMENDS
EVERTON’S GRAND SHOOTING
SHARP IRRESISTIBLE
The start of the second half was an eye opener for the Blades. No sooner had the kick off taken place then the ball went across to Sharp who ran along the touch line, and Bartlett was soon beaten, and then came a short pass to Young, who ran through and beat Lyall with a beautiful shot. The excitement had not died away when Sharp was on business bent once more. He worked away, and then McDermott chipped in, Young finally coming on with him, and once more beating Lyall, at which the enthusiasm knew no bounds. Play kept in the visitors half, Rankin and Settle keeping Ferrier and Slavin very busy. A brief breakaway was made by the Sheffield left, but they were  repulsed, and the Everton left-winger again carried hostilities into the enemy’s camp, but could not get in an effective shot. The success of the Blues stimulated them wonderfully, and so rapid did their attack become that Wednesday were nearly run off their feet. A feature of the Everton attack was their wonderfully accurate shooting, and they were seldom far from the mark. A tricky attack on the Sheffield right provided Davies with a clean opening but he shot miserable. Wednesday soon went to work on the other wing, and Roose saved from Wilson, but it was not effective, and the leather smartly crossed to Davies. He made amends by beating Roose and this considerably improved the Sheffield prospects. The visitors made great efforts to equalise and Wilson nearly got through. Roose only managing to clear from a pass back by Abbott. Everton now took up the attack and Bonham, knocking the ball down awarded their third penalty kick which Makepeace this time successfully converted. When Everton had reached their fifth goal they eased up somewhat. Roose had then rather more to do than Lyall. Final result- Everton 5 goals, Sheffield Wednesday 2 goals.
At Goodison Park last season the Everton representative won by 2 goals to nil.

HARDMAN PLAYS IN INTER-LEAGUE MATCH
March 13, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
The game at Hampton-park, Glasgow, between representatives of the English and Scottish Leaguers was a kind of trial for the more import international at Crystal Palace on the 1 st April. Hardman's Everton's nimble outside left, was scarcely as brilliant as when associated with Settle. The English winning by two goals to one.

ARCHIE GOODALL LEAVES GLOSSOP
Athletic News - Monday 13 March 1905
The famous Irish International has bade good-bye to North Derbyshire, an act which was mutal so far as he and the club was concerned.  His brother John left Glossop to manage a Southern League club.  Will Archie fellow his footsteps?  From what I saw of the latter in a match at Glossop this season I fancy he will not seek another playing engagement.  The first time I saw him he was a member of the Liverpool Stanley club, and the intervening period seems an age.  He was assort of nomad in those days for there were not so many professional forms used, but he blossomed into an Aston Villa man, and then to Derby County, with whom he was 13 seasons, and a captain of the club. 

SEMI-FINALISTS AT GOODISON PARK
Athletic News - Monday 13 March 1905
By Junius
Fully 15,000 persons witnessed the return League game between Everton and Sheffield Wednesday, and they were afforded plenty of excitement, for seven goals were scored and a penalty kick missed, in addition to other glorious chances which ought to have been utilized.  The wonder is that more points were not forthcoming, for a strong wind which blew from goal to goal made accurate kicking almost impossible, for the side that had to face it.  In addition, a brilliant sun in the first half troubled Everton, but after the change of ends, it clouded over, and the Wednesday defenders were not handicapped to the same extent.  Owing to injuries received on the previous Thursday Chapman and Ruddlesdin were replaced by Brittleton and Ferrier respectively, whilst on the Everton side Rankin took the outside left position for Hardman.  Everton fully deserved to win.  About fifteen minutes had elapsed when Young and Settle were both brought down together inside the penalty area, and  Makepeace spoiled his unsullied record by failing to convert the ensuing kick.  A determined assault on the Wednesday right wing followed, and after several shots had been repelled Brittleton opened the scoring.  Sheffield pressed, and Roose dropped a swift drive from Ferrier at the feet of Davies, who was scarcely two yards from goal, but he unaccountably shot over the bar.  Another penalty came before the interval, for Young was pushed over, inside the dreaded area, and Abbott was entrusted with the kick.  He shot against Lyall, but the ball came out to Sharp, who equalized.  The second half opened sensationally, for within two minutes, clever passing between Rankin, and McDermott gave Young an opportunity and the latter running close in beat Lyall all to pieces with a fast drive.  Scarcely had we recovered from this when the performance was almost exactly repeated by the same individuals, and Young again did the needful.  Still the Wednesday warriors never despaired, and Wilson whipped the ball out to Simpson, who centred well in front.  Roose seemed to hesitate and came out of his goal, giving Davis a chance which was promptly utilized.  Then came a third penalty.  Lyall was drawn out of his citadel by the Everton right wing, and Sharp beating him for possession, centred to McDermott, who drove into goal.  Burton was standing there, and he repelled the shot with both hands in great style.  Makepeace added number four from the kick.  Ten minutes from time, Sharp centred and Lyall cleared Settle’s effort, but Taylor pounced on the leather, and the fifth goal resulted. 
The game did not provide the same class of football that was witnessed the previous week, but Everton proved the better team.  Plenty of vigour was infused into the proceedings, and the defence of the visitors was sorely harassed at times, whilst they were not particularly scrupulous in their methods of clearance.  As was the case against Southampton the Everton forwards were seen to great advantage.  Young played a capital game, dribbling finely and giving his wings every opportunity of forging ahead.  The two goals he gained were characteristic efforts and were the result of splendid combined work between Sharp and McDermott, which the centre ably finished.  Settle again demonstrated his best form, and just now is in a more effective mood than at any previous part of the present season.  He and McDermott bewildered the Sheffield hat-trick, their tricky footwork and beautifully judged passes being quite a feature of the Everton attack.  Sharp was equally skillful, running and centring in his most sparkling vein, satisfactorily filled Hardman’s usual position.  Taylor was a thorn in the path of the Sheffield forwards, and both Makepeace and Abbott rendered a creditable account of themselves, the combination between them and the forwards being excellent.  Balmer and Crelley had a tremendous task in the first half, and how they managed to get the ball away with a blinding sun to face was remarkable.  The Sheffield defence was not so reliable as that of the home side, and neither Burton not Slavin were as clean in their returns as usual.  Lyall was not at fault, for he had no chance with the shots that beat him, but the half-backs were below their customary aggressive form, and they could not hold the clever Everton vanguard.  Wilson was the best of the forwards, and he gave Simpson and Davis splendid opportunities with his wide swinging passes.  The outside left obliged with some stirring runs, and the rushes of the inside forwards required a stubborn defence to cope with them.  Everton; L.R. Roose; Balmer, Crelley; Makepeace, Taylor, Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle and Rankin.  Sheffield Wednesday; Lyall; Slavin, Burton; Ferrier, Crawshaw, Bartlett; Davis, Brittleton, Wilson, Stewart, and Simpson.  Referee; F. Heath, Birmingham. 

EVERTON WIN EASY
London Daily News - Monday 13 March 1905
Everton beat Sheffield Wednesday at Goodison Park by five goals to two. The play in the first half did not suggest that Everton would gain such an easy victory. Sheffield attacked smartly, and Brittleton scored the first goal for them. Two penalties were awarded to Everton, Sharp scoring from the second, after Abbott had shot against Lyall. At the interval the goals were level. Immediately after the restart Young obtained a fine goal for Everton and two minutes later he added another. Davis then scored for the Wednesday, but further goals were shot for the home side by Makepeace, from a penalty and Taylor.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 13 March 1905
Everton have fairly played havoc with the defence of Sheffield Wednesday this season, and ten goals in the home and away matches denotes either an inordinary amount of skill on the part of the Everton forwards, or a lack of reliability in the Sheffield rear division. The cause of the two debacles must be sought for in the quality of the Everton attack, which was  incisive enough to spread dismay among the spectators at Owlerton earlier in the season, and which, but for a regrettable injury to Scott, would have provided as many points as the return fixtures did on Saturday last. At the present time. Everton are exhibiting their finest form, and it will require a wonderful defence to keep them in check. They had to face a dazzling sun and powerful breeze in the first half of the game against Sheffield, and did extremely well to be able to claim an equality at the interval, for the full backs were unsighted by the glare, which, of course was not so conspicuous later in the day. The figures at the change of ends should have been two each for Makepeace failed to convert a penalty kick, which was awarded for Young and Settle being brought down together when inside the prescribed area. Then, after Brittleton had gained the first goal of the match for the visitors, Ferrier sent in a shot which rebounded off Roose and came straight to Davies, who was almost under the bar. To the consternation of his comrades, however, he shot yards over the bar. When Everton entered upon the second stages of the proceedings Young quicky placed the issue beyond doubt. Within the space of five minutes he had put on a couple of goals in characteristic style. Sharp and McDermott were concerned with beautiful football, and Young receiving a well-judged pass flashed past the backs, and Lyall had not the ghost of a chance of stopping his shots. With the score three to one in their favour, Everton slackened their efforts the result being that Wilson whipped out the ball to Simpson, who centred, and Roose was apparently hesitating whether to go for the cross shot or wait for the drive from the inside players. He came out of his goal, and Davis had the leather in the net before he could regain his place. Everton again buckled to their task, and Sharp got the better of a tussle with Lyall, who had also left his charge, and centreing to McDermott, the latter shot straight at goal. Burton repelled the ball in the correct custodian’s style with both hands, and Makepeace made no mistake with his second penalty kick. Everton had all the remaining play, and, after Settle had nearly headed another goal, Taylor registered the fifth with a left foot drive.
Prominent amongst the Everton forwards was Young, who exhibited fine command of the ball, and kept his wings moving with well-judged swinging passes first to right and then to left. The two goals he secured were splendid efforts and there was more life about his work than has been seen for some considerable time. Settle and McDermott were responsible for some brilliant footwork, their passing being beautifully timed and always placed to the best advantage for the men on either side of them. Sharp, gave another capital display, his dashing runs and centres being a marked feature of the Everton attack. The right winger almost invariably finishes his work judiciously, and given the slightest chance he utilizes it to the utmost as witness his goal from the penalty partially saved by Lyall. Rankin also shaped very credibility as the extreme left, and proved a capable institute for Hardman.  In the intermediate line Taylor was a forceful factor, and he had a troublesome opponent to face in Wilson. The combination between the half backs and forwards was at times resplendent and Makepeace gave his wing every opponents of forging ahead. Some of the movements on the right wing were splendid conceptions which were carried out most accurately, and this sympathetic harmony between the half backs and forwards was responsible for the incisive character of the Everton advance. Abbott showed further improvement and is returning to his pristine form. He made several desperate efforts to record a goal, but failed on each occasion to get in his shot. Considering the conditions under which they had to operate, both Balmer and Crelly performed cleverly for it was most difficult to gauge the flight of the ball. Roose was not seen at his best, and the seconds goal gained by the visitors ought never to have materialised. In the Wednesday ranks, Wilson and Simpson were the most conspicuous forwards the former being difficult to dispossesses when in command of the ball, and he distributed the play most judiciously. Simpson responded with many clever runs, but the remaining forwards were not very effective and their passing frequently went astray. The half-backs could not hold the Everton vanguard and they often resorted to illegal methods to check their opponents. Not one of the line exhibited anything above very ordinary form, but further behind Burton and Slavin defended well, though their returns were not cleanly executed owing to the boisterous breeze. Lyall kept a good goal, and was utterly helpless with the five shots than took effect.

EVERTON v  SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY
Sheffield Independent - Monday 13 March 1905
WEDNESDAY BEATEN
The meeting of these teams at Goodison Park was invested with rather peculiar interest, inasmuch as both are left in for the semi-finals of the English Cup, whilst more peculiar still is the fact that at the first meeting at Owlerton in November last a most remarkable game ended in a draw if five goals each, after Everton had led by five to one at the interval. There had been a lot of rain in Liverpool in the morning, but still the going was not near so bad as might have been expected. Everton were practically at full strength, but Wednesday were without Chapman and Ruddlesdin (injured last Thursday), their places being taken by Brittleton and Ferrier respectively. There would be about 15,000 people present. Crawshaw having won the toss, Young started, Everton having to face the wind, which blew across the ground. Play opened rather tamely, the players at the start being unable to judge the pace of the ball. The visitors were the first to attack, and after smart passing, Davis swung the ball in, but Balmer got it away before Wilson could get up. Then the home team had a turn, but Rankin centred badly, and the danger was easily cleared. A moment later, however, Sharp got in a fine long shot, Lyall coming out and clearing as he was charged down. Then, following determined work by Wilson, the Wednesday men got dangerous but two shots were charged down, and a fine centre from Simpson was well cleared. Aided by the wind the Sheffielders kept play in the home half and from one fair opening Davis shot high over the bar at express speed. Wilson next essayed a shot, but Simpson was given off-side as he dashed up. From the free kick Everton got down, and after Settle had shot wide, Burton conceded a corner. This caused a rather prolonged struggle, but in the end Settle headed over as Lyall rushed out. Slavin stopped one advance, but Everton were very persistent hereabouts, and aided by a free-kick against Wilson, kept play in the visitors’ half a few minutes. At length Wilson set his right wing going, and from Davis’s centre Brittleton dashed up and headed wide. Then Everton, by the aid of the left wing, got dangerous, and in a struggle Settle was brought down inside the penalty line. Everton were granted a penalty, and Makepeace, as usual took the kick, but for once in a way put the ball outside. Then Rankin ran down and centred accurately to Young, but the latter was too slow, and the danger was cleared, Ferrier next set his side going by clever play, and a hot attack was made on the home goal. Roose fisted away from Ferrier, but the visitors persisted Wilson and Stewart both having shots buffeted back luckily, but at length Brittleton beat Roose after half an hour’s play. From the centre kick Wednesday attacked again, but once the ball went a shade too far for Wilson, and Roose cleared. A minute or so later the Everton goal underwent a marvellous escape from downfall. Roose had saved once, when Ferrier immediately shot in at express speed, and the ball struck Roose. Davis appeared to have an open goal, but lifted the rising ball over the bar. Rankin was next prominent on the home left, but he was charged down, and the referee at once blew his whistle. He consulted one of the linesmen, and after a little delay decided on awarding Everton another penalty kick. This was taken by Abbott, who shot straight at Lyall, the latter falling, and before he could recover, Sharp had dashed up and equalised. A persistent attack was shortly afterwards made on the visitors’ goal, but the pressure was relieved by Sharp shooting a shade wide at express speed. Then Wednesday got away in line, and well inside the penalty line Wilson was badly tripped but no notice was taken of this, and Wilson, being unable to get in his shot, the ball went wide. A corner followed, but the danger was cleared at length by Roose, who a little later just rushed out in time to kick the ball away as Brittleton dashed in, and at half-time the score was one goal each.
On resuming Young was immediately set going by McDermott, and the latter running through put in a fast low shot just inside the post, which clean beat Lyall, this within the first minute. Two minutes later the home left wing drew the visitors’ defence, and from a pass by McDermott, Young fastening on the ball put in a fine shot which had Lyall beaten all the way. Thus within five minutes of resuming Everton were leading by three goals to one. Play was then stopped owing to Settle being accidentally kicked. Crawshaw next came in with a very fine clearance, and Wilson passed out a bit too strong for Simpson, who failed to gather the ball. Back came Everton, and Sharp put in a good shot which Lyall saved at the expense of a corner, but this was not improved upon. Then Brittleton gave Davis a good opening, but the latter shot wide. However, Simpson was again set going, and passing to Wilson, the latter drew Roose and put the ball forward for Davis to score an easy goal. Two free kicks to Everton kept play in the visitors’ half and from the first Lyall only just saved, and Burton cleared after a hard struggle. Next Brittleton all but got through the ball cannoning a shade too far for him, and this enabling Roose to kick away. With a little over a quarter of an hour gone Lyall left his goal some distance, and as a shot from McDermott was taking effect Burton fisted out. Makepeace made the scores four goals to two in Everton’s favour from the ensuing penalty. Following a free kick against Wilson the home left took the ball up, and Young had a glorious chance a few yards out, but Lyall just managed to save with one hand. Play was fairly fast, and a long pass out to Davis saw the latter swing the ball in, but Simpson headed just over the crossbar. Another hot attack on the Wednesday goal saw Lyall just clear from Sharp, and Slavin just got in the way of another shot, but Taylor got possession, and with Lyall unsighted the Everton centre-half scored the fifth goal for his side. There was still quarter of an hour left for play, and a fine burst by Wednesday looked very dangerous but with Roose practically beaten Abbott dashed in an cleared as Wilson and Brittleton came up. From another attack by the visitors Wilson failed to gather the ball in front of goal, and then play slackened down considerably. Once towards the close Stewart was tripped inside the penalty line, but gathered himself, though he failed to get in his shot before being overpowered. The home team were doing the most attacking, but an unproductive corner fell to each side. Just before the finish Rankin got in a magnificent centre, which Lyall cleared well, and neither side being able to score again, a somewhat remarkable game ended in a victory for Everton, as follows;-
Everton 5 goals, Sheffield Wednesday 2 goals.
Everton.- Roose, goal; Balmer (captain) and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Rankin, forwards.
Sheffield Wednesday.- Lyall, goal; Slavin and Burton, backs; Ferrier, Crawshaw (captain), and Bartlett, half-backs; Davis, Brittleton, Wilson, Stewart, and Simpson, forwards. Referee, Mr. F. Heath.

NOTES ON SPORTS
Sheffield Independent - Monday 13 March 1905
By Centre Forward
WEDNESDAY’S DEFEAT
There is nothing remarkable in a team being defeated in a League match away from home, especially when the defeated team is below full strength and meeting the prospective champions of the League and semi-finalists for the English Cup on their own ground. But still there is something remarkable about the season’s matches between Everton and Wednesday, inasmuch as though the Wednesday have scored seven goals in the two games they have only earned one point; whilst Everton have scored no fewer than ten goals for their three points. Whilst admitting that Everton were the better side on Saturday (writes our own reporter), I cannot bring myself to think that five-two was a fair reflex of the game. Everton deserved to win on the run of the game, but they were aided by more than their fair share of luck in finishing up three goals in front. Though there were plenty of exciting incidents, it cannot be described as a soul-stirring game- there was a something lacking throughout, which prevented the spectators from being raised to a high pitch of enthusiasm. The play could not be termed slovenly, for at times some very pretty work was witnessed on both sides, but all the same, the game did not realise expectations. It was a fairly interesting struggle- nothing more-in which the referee played a conspicuous part.
REFEREE AND PENALTIES
I am sorry to say I cannot congratulate Mr. Heath on the matter in which he handled the game; for without in the least wishing to hint that he was unfair, he struck me as being weak. Speaking from memory, I don’t remember a single free kick being given against Everton in the first half, which seems to reflect very great credit on the home team. But it was over the second penalty given against Wednesday that Mr. Heath was at fault. He blew his whistle before any appeal could be made, and then went and consulted one of the linesmen. I don’t know whether it is true that the linesman declared against a penalty, but why should Mr. Heath consult the linesman at all when he saw the whole occurrence. Again, when Wilson and Stewart were tripped, he refrained from exacting the full penalty against the offenders, presumably because neither of the men fell prone to the ground, though in each case they were prevented from getting in their shot. Probably Mr. Heath thought he might have been penalising the wrong side had he blown the whistle on these occasions, but it was not y opinion. It is somewhat remarkable for a team to go through a whole season without conceding a single penalty, and then have three given against them in one match.
ABOUT THE TEAMS
For Everton, Roose in goal was clever, and daring as usual, but he twice made mistakes which might have proved fatal. Though kicking strongly, Balmer and Crelly have both been seen to better advantage, and really the best part of the home team was the middle division, the halves being good in defence, and placing well. Young did very well at centre-forward, and found McDermott a very useful partner indeed, whilst Settle put in a lot of good work. Rankin did well in the first half, but is not up to Hardman’s standard, and Sharp at extreme right was usually prominent. For the losers it seemed to be Lyall’s fault for leaving his goal so far that caused Burton to give a penalty, though had the latter been a little cooler be might have breasted the ball away. Neither he nor Slavin were as good as on Thursday, and the same remark applies to the half-backs, though not much fault could be found with any of the five, Forward Wilson worked hard, but there was scarcely that thorough understanding in the front line which marked their play against Preston.

EVERTON v  SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY
Sheffield Daily Telegraph - Monday 13 March 1905
AN ANTICIPATED DEFEAT
EVEBTON V. SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY, AN ANTICIPATED DEFEAT. Last season’? results: Last season’s results;—
At Everton: Everton 2, Wednesday 0. At Owlerton; Wednesday 1, Everton 0
The appearance of Sheffield Wednesday at Goodison Park attracted something like 16,000 people, but the attendance would no doubt have been much larger had the weather in the morning been good. Just before the match rain fell, only for few minutes, however, and the sun shone almost all the time play was in progress. Wednesday took the field without Ruddlesdin and Chapman, who were injured on Thursday, and Ferrier and Brittleton played, while Everton had Rankin in place of Hardman, who was assisting the English League. Wednesday had the choppy wind in their favour during the first half, but they did not make the best use of it, Everton having an equal share of the play. The first really dangerous movement was made by Everton, Lyall having to fist away a centre from Sharp. Wilson was only just baulked as he tried go through, and a bully in front of the Wednesday goal was of no avail. The next incident of note was penalty against Wednesday for an offence against Settle, but Makepeace sent wide. Then Young missed an easy chance, and with Wednesday attacking again, a hard shot from Ferrier was fisted away by Roose, and Brittleton getting hold in the ensuing scrimmage, scored good goal after half an hour. Everton forced Wednesday back, and after Lyall had saved a good shot Young they gained a second penalty for an apparently fair charge on Young. Abbott shot straight Lyall, but Sharp rushed in and equalised. Subsequently Davis missed a good chance, and Sharp put two splendid shots, which travelled just wide. At the interval the score was one goal each.
Everton begun the second half in great style, and before five minutes had elapsed Young scored two lovely goals, as the result excellent work by McDermott and Sharp. Soon after Simpson centred accurately, and Wilson passed the ball on to Davis, who easily obtained his side’s second goal. Everton were the better side this half, and Makepeace once put in a fine shot, clearing which Lyall went a long way out of goal. Sharp sent the ball back, and as McDermott shot Burton fisted away. With the ensuing penalty kick Makepeace made no mistake. More capital work by the home forwards resulted in Taylor getting a fifth goal, after Lyall had once saved. For the last quarter of an hour. Wednesday wore almost, dangerous as their opponents, and once Abbott intervened as Wilson and Brittleton had mastered Roose.
Result : Everton 5 goals. Sheffield Wednesday 2 goals
Everton.—L. R. Roose, goal ; Balmer (captain) and Crelley, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott. half-backs; Sharp McDermott. Young, Settle, and Rankin, forwards. Sheffield Wednesday.—Lyall, goal: Slovin and Burton, backs; Ferrier, Crawshaw (captain), and Bartlett, half-backs; Davis, Brittleton, Wilson, Stewart, and Simpson, forwards. Referee: Mr. F. Heath.

WEDNESDAY AND EVERTON
Sheffield Daily Telegraph - Monday 13 March 1905
It is quite probable that Sheffield Wednesday and Everton have set up record for the present season, as there are other clubs which seem likely to score 17 goals in two matches. That is what has been accomplished by the League Champions and the present leaders the competition, and in the Owlerton draw and a victory to Everton Wednesday have lost ten goals seven by their Cup rivals, On each occasion the brilliant combination of Everton nonplussed the Sheffielders, but on Saturday, writes a colleague, one looked vain for that wonderful recuperative power which the latter showed at Owlerton, when, after being four goals down half-way through they got on level terms in the last minute. In the second game Wednesday were not themselves during’ the latter portion; indeed, it was not expected that they would be when their hard struggles with Preston North End, and the fact that Ruddlesdin and Chapman would be out of the team were recalled, but for half the game they kept their redoubtable opponents at full stretch. They even got the first goal—a capital one by Brittleton—and ought to have crossed over with the lead, Davis missing a very easy chance, after Roose had completely lost an excellent shot by Ferrier. What really gave Everton such a pronounced victory were the three penalty kicks, only one of which seemed to be deserved. The third for a palpable knocking down of the ball by Burton, which would not have been necessary had Lyall fulfilled his duties properly when saving a smashing drive by Makepeace, instead of running to somewhere near the corner flag, but what was the direct cause of the other two the Wednesday players themselves did not know. In the first case Young was about a couple of yards inside the area when Burton came with a rush and kicked the ball away, the Everton centre-forward going down at the same time evidently through a charge by a Wednesday man, and in the second Slavin apparently knocked Young over with fair charge. Mr. Heath himself had some doubt about the second, and showed weakness by consulting a linesman, although he was close enough to see what happened. Other decisions of Mr. Heath, or rather what ought to have been decisions, deserve comment. Twice when Wednesday were extremely dangerous Wilson and Stewart were tripped in the proscribed area, and penalties ought certainly have resulted. Had they been forthcoming it is doubtful whether Wednesday would have won, for on the whole Everton were distinctly the better side. Wednesday were wanting in every division, for although Wilson did his best to open out the game there were not proper responses by his wings, and the forwards were not properly supported, or found the Everton halves and backs difficult of circumvention. After Wilson came Simpson with some effective dashes, but Makepeace was tower strength, and did not give Stewart many opportunities for his clever passes. Brittleton was moderate, and Davis sometimes got the better of Abbott and Crelley, having the completing hand in the taking movement which led up to Wednesday second goal. However, the Wednesday forwards can claim to have accomplished what no other set has been capable of doing since Roose threw in his lot with Everton last November; that is, score two goals, and the team can treat this in the light of a solatium for their heavy defeat. Ferrier, Crawshaw, and Bartlett were often the victims of the splendid short passing of the opposing quintette, and, despite two excellent shots in the first half, Ferrier was not the equal of Ruddlesdin, finding Rankin a speedy, though not a fine outside left, with Settle the maker of capital openings. Crawshaw was sorely troubled by Young, and Bartlett had an excellent wing to face. Sharp and McDermott being both fast and tricky, while Burton and Slavin did not kick at all well.
THE EVERTON TEAM
Young is entitled to praise for his excellent control over his colleagues in the front line, his passes being low, quick, and accurate. He also scored two beautiful goals, and it was these, in the first five minutes of the second half, which made Everton’s victory assured. Better tactics than those employed by Sharp and McDermott in the making of the openings I do not wish to see, the ball being taken along the wing in a fashion bewildering to Bartlett and Burton, and the final passes leaving the centre-forward in the best possible positions. Lyall was he' pless against such shots as Young sent in, and two other splendid efforts by Sharp in the first half would no doubt have mastered him had they been true. The Lancashire cricketer is in capital form just now, and on Saturday he and McDermott made up a wing fit to pierce the stoutest defence, one which it would be difficult to equal for trickiness and speed. Three sound half-backs were headed by Makepeace, who created surprise by missing a penalty kick, and of the backs Crelley was the better, while Roose was, as usual, agile. The football all through was very fast, Wednesday responding to the home team’s pretty combination advances by gallant dashes, especially in the first half, when Balmer and Crelley needed all the support they could get from their halves. It was in that half, also, that the Wednesday defence was called upon to some of its best work, and even if the relieving kicks were not powerful enough to send the opposing forwards well back, the tackling remained strong.

INTER-LEAGUE MATCH AT GLASGOW
Athletic News -Monday, March 13 1905
SCOTS SUCCUMB IN A SPRITED STRUGGLE
ENGLISH HONOURS WELL WON
By Tityrus
The battles between the English and the; Scottish Leagues have assumed an importance scarcely foreshadowed when Mr. J. J. Bentley refereed the first encounter under that title at Bolton thirteen years ago, although there are excellent judges who that that match produced some of the finest football ever seen. Without any break in the sequence in the representatives of these Leagues have fought supremacy every season, and the fourteenth test took place on Saturday at the new home of Queen’s Park—-of happy memory if now their scutcheon be somewhat tarnished—when despite the most adverse conditions a game full of life, colour, and incidents, simmering with excitement until the last side kick was brought to issue. A brisk breeze from the west brought blinding squalls and drove the rain along in drenching fashion. Despite this and the fact that New Hampden Park does not provide shelter for the masses, 36,599 people passed through the turnstiles, and these do not include ticket’ holders and guests. Such a gathering on such a day shows that Glasgow is still the metropolis of football, and that the followers are like unto the legions of Ariovistus, the general who told Julius Caesar that his soldiers had slept in the open air for fourteen years. Some of our Association henchmen would beat that ancient record if they tried. But just as the spectators braved the March winds and the storms so did the players rise superior to all drawbacks and conditions. The ground lying in a hollow was very holding, and some strength was required to pull a studded boot out of the turf. Moreover, the gale, which stiffened the pavilion flags until they were like boards, whirled and swirled the ball about and a greasy ball at that. It was difficult to keep the inflated object of so much attention under anything like decent control- and yet on the whole mind triumphed over the forces of Nature. But think of the great advantage that Scotland had in playing with this wind while they were eager for the fray, while they were fresh, and while rain was pelting into the eyes of the English backs. And yet, with all this help and a lead of two goals at the interval the Scots were unable to win, a victory of 3-2, under all the circumstances, stands to the infinite credit of the Englishmen—and it is well for Scotland to remember that the visiting eleven seemed capable of improvement.
Naturally, with such assistance as I have described, the Scots soon took a commanding lead in the game. The wings were plied, the ball was kept low, and once within any reasonable distance for shooting, or for diagonal centres across the goalmouth there was no dallying with opportunity. Bennett was troublesome, while Walker was full of life, and Quinn distributed his favours with impartiality. He did not make all his passes to Benett. Alec Smith received his share, but Bennett was wide of the target, Speedie hung on to the ball too long, and Smith shot high over the goal. But when the ball was more dangerous Linacre was a host in the breach, his first save from an attempt by Young giving some indication of the mettle in the man. But thirteen minutes had elapsed when the first goal was scored by the Scots. Following a throw-in, Walker gave the ball to Speedie, who dribbled in and transferred to Quinn, whose slow shot just rolled over the line for Linacre, and the backs all seemed foot-fast in the mud. Thus encouraged the Scottish wing men became more aggressive than ever. There was dashing play between Speedie and Alec Smith, the latter crowning the combined movement by a grand drive into the goal, but Linacre was there. Gradually the Englishmen began to have a voice in the argument, and after Wolstenholme had forced the ball outside Stokes tested Rennie with a centre which he pushed away with both hands. But, of course, the Caledonians came rushing back, and when Speedie put the ball to Quinn’s toe the closely-knit, athletic-looking Celtic centre was away like a flash. His lofty cannon-shot into goal was a mighty effort. The pace on the ball was tremendous. But Linacre was there. The corner-kick should have been harmless, but while the ball was travelling i’ th’ air from flag to goal Bloomer, according to the referee, charged or pushed Quinn in the back. Now, according to the referee, this necessitated a penalty-kick, with the result that Thomson netted, and so Scotland were two goals up, as golfers would say, at the end of 25 minutes. The prospect was chilling, but Bloomer and Parkinson tried desperately to change the fortunes of their side, and mayhap would have done had not McLeod intervened. This is a useful habit on the part of a back. Stokes took a turn in the attacking business, and Hardman dashing up caused Rennie to save with his right hand stretched out to its fullest limit. Bache was prominent, and Parkinson compelled Rennie to handle once more—but despite these manoeuvres, the visitors never looked like scoring. But when Bennett, Walker, and Quinn initiated another fine movement they boded much danger. This time Quinn urged the ball along like a swift underhand bowler without any length of pitch. The leather went bounding but Linacre was there. Once again Speedie seemed likely to increase the lead, but Linacre was there—this time some yards out of his goal. The Scots were overwhelming, and Bennett shivered the wooden framework of the goal with a crashing shot which Speedie hurled back into the English citadel. But Linacre was there. Towards the interval the visitors played with some skill and much determination, though they were two goals to the bad when ends were changed. After Bloomer had stretched himself and shot outside, the Scots tried forcing tactics with some success in the teeth of the gale.  But they were quickly brought to realise the fact that England with the wind at their backs were going to have a say in the struggle. Moreover, as soon as Rennie was troubled he seemed in difficulties, for quite erratically he gave a corner to a shot from Stokes, and when Bloomer teased him with a ground-drive the Hibernians’ custodian was slow, and he toyed with the ball until he fell with the leather between his legs. But somehow or other he emerged successfully, and then we saw Quinn threading his way to goal and trying a weak left-footed shot. Of course Linacre was there, but Alec. Smith secured possession and crossed to the right. Bennett rushed in—and missed altogether; a grand chance gone. But the English left wing, chiefly by the help of Bache were very persistent, and Jackson gave a corner. Hardman placed well, but Young headed out. Thereupon Burgess pounced on the ball, and with a very judicious return struck the crossbar. Bloomer, however, is always looking out for little things like that, and taking the rebound without any hesitation he scored with an excellent shot just out of the goalkeeper’s reach at the end of a quarter of an hour. But within two minutes the scores equalised, Stokes led a raid and gave the ball to the left wing, where Bache experienced hard luck, but Roberts saw his chance from a rebound out of a scrimmage, and a long and lovely shot completely deceived Rennie.  
Such a sudden change in the fortunes of war was not appreciated by the Scots, and the struggle became more grim than ever. The home team, chiefly by Quinn and Smith made valiant efforts to retrieve their fortunes, but nothing more than barren corners and feeble shots rewarded their efforts. Yet the Englishmen were not content, and Bache was frequently to the fore. England took several corners, end Bache was unfortunate not to score by a beautiful header. Indeed, Bache and Bloomer were constantly in the thick of the fight. After Quinn had missed a chance in a thousand by turning a centre from Smith just outside the post, Bache, did find the net, only to be ruled offside—a decision which seemed doubtful, as he appeared to take the ball after it had been played by Rennie, who had rushed out. However, Bache was not done with, and after he had given to Bloomer, the Derby crack gave Parkinson a chance, and the Liverpudlian  scored with a shot that was similar in its character to that of Roberts, and quite in the Parkinsonian style. The Scots held that Parkinson was offside, but the referee had a contrary opinion, and he is the only man who counts. I heard a shrewd English judge express the opinion that Parkinson was offside and an equally sound Scot assert that he was in play. As I say, the referee alone counts. The left wings of both teams were to the fore with the difference that Bache drove in a fine ground ball which Rennie saved, while Speedie failed to take an opportunity of equalising. In the closing stages the Scots, who had enjoyed the benefit of a little rest while England were busy, and Rennie was retrieving his reputation, came once again with renewed vigour. This was evidently a grand attack to save the situation. They swooped down on the English in most formidable style, and were conceded corner after corner. There seemed but a sheet of tissue paper between a defeat and a draw. And yet the difference existed, and was maintained in a most exciting finish. Once Walker made as fine a shot as was seen in the match. The ball hurtled high through the air. It was a thunderbolt and seemed certain to travel ‘neath the bar, but Linacre was there. And the ball was over the bar. The game was saved and was won. The finish was dramatic and befitting a match which was played with the utmost keenness and with wonderful pace and skill, when we consider the conditions. The English Leaguers are jealous of their. honourable record in these matches, and they had not been defeated since that terrible 6—2 reverse at Parkhead in 1901. They had a fright on Saturday, but they never lost either their heads or their hearts, and they came out of a tight corner with great distinction. To my thinking the Englishmen richly deserved their victory, for the penalty-kick against Bloomer was an exceedingly doubtful ruling, while the visitors might have benefited by the fact that Robertson once fisted the ball in the forbidden area. There was no doubt whatever about this piece of manual labour, but it was not officially detected. But apert from these controversial matters, England were entitled to the honours as the faster and cleverer team. On a day such as Saturday that extra little turn of pace and the additional ounce of stamina goes a long way. There were Scots who seemed in severe stress in the middle of the second half, but they nursed themselves and joined in the grand final assault on the English citadel. And yet again I hold that the English defence was far the stronger, while the half- backs were more accomplished in the finer arts of their duties. They were better in placing, and that is the difference between a mediocre and a good middleman. Perhaps the Scottish forwards as a set were better than those of England, but I question if the Scots pressed with such persistency in the first half as the visitors in the second period. The Scotch vanguard had a greater share of the game against the wind than England had—a fact which tends to prove the opinion that the Scots had the finer forwards. I must give some impressions of the victors as they appealed to me individually. I cannot conceive that England can look for their goalkeeper against Wales and Scotland than Harry Linacre of Nottingham Forest. For years he has been a great custodian, and the Association recognised his abilities when they played him in the North and South match at Tottenham; but after this they allowed him to remain in the cool shade of neglect. Linacre, equally clever at high and low shots was never in such form as at present, and was never so confident of his own powers and so successful in divining what his opponents would do, Of the backs, Howard Spencer was easily The Master. Brains atone for his want of speed and his weak tackling. He waits and watches for the one false step by the advancing forward, who must keep perfect control to hoodwink so. shrew a judge of possibilities. Spencer has an old head on burly shoulders. Burgess was a little troubled by a weakness in one of his legs, but once he was thoroughly warm when facing the storm he showed himself a little artist, especially by the way he came through with the ball at his toes and helped in the attack of the second half. As already intimated, the half-backs were a trio of workers, and they kept the ball low —a very important factor on such a day. On the whole Charles Roberts, the tall centre-half, of Manchester United, was the most accomplished middleman on the field —especially in the second half. His head and his long legs were ever in play and his goal was a thing of beauty. Leake and Wolstenholme, as ever, never shirked work, but both of them have been seen to greater advantage. The English wing-men were both weak. Hardman had a bad time against such a well-built and resolute half-back as James Young, for he never gave him any scope, and never spared him. Hardman tried is best, but he was far below his club form, and the same may be said of Stokes, who had more chances given him than the Evertonian. Nor was Parkinson such a factor as many had hoped that he would be, for Thomson, a ready and robust half, without much polish, never stood on ceremony with the Anfielder, who, however, had the distinction of notching the winning goal. He did nothing half so well as this. The great forwards were Bache and Bloomer. Each man was a wing in himself, and it is no exaggeration to say that they bore the heat and burden of the attack. In midfield work, and in shooting, too, Bache was always a force, but none on his side could conjure with the ball like Bloomer, who at times could not be dispossessed. Bloomer is still Bloomer, and is playing better than for several years past. The way he led attacks was so bewildering that Jack Robertson was like a man in a maze, for he did not know which way to turn. It is clear to me that Harry Rennie is not the man he was. Generally he got the ball, but his fielding was seldom clean. Rennie never inspired confidence, and I attributed his indecisive handling to a loss of nerve. McLeod was far and away the more dependable back, even when he was playing out of his position, and had a foot that occasionally troubled him. Faith in Jackson is wanting. The Scottish half-backs were useful, as I have already led readers to infer. Young and Thomson are expert stoppers, but they had the ball too much in the air, while Robertson was only in his happiest vein for about a third of the game. He needs a topic. The monumental man in the Scottish attack was James Quinn. By many he is believed to be the greatest footballer now playing, but to see him to perfection I am told that he must be sandwiched between McMenemy and Somers. He lay well forward, and was always ready to take a pass and either endeavour to thrust himself through all opposition of swish the ball to his wings. Always clever he was dangerous with his shots in the first half, and there is steam-power in his drives, as Linacre could testify. But Quinn needs playing to, and he did not strike me as the man who would help his half-backs when they were hard pressed. Nevertheless Quinn is a great centre, and I can conceive him playing a very great game with his comrades on a decent day. Alec Smith is neither superfluous nor a weakling, but he is becoming slower. He wants a good partner, and Speedie is, I fear, becoming selfish and encouraging this habit in his clubmate. While he was fresh Walker was a gem, and he was the next best man to Quinn, but Bennett would, I think, have bene better suited by the top of the ground, for he tired perceptibly. But I keep wondering what would have happened if England had won the toss.
English League.- H. Linacre (Notts Forest), goal; H. Spencer (Aston Villa) and H. Burgess (Manchester City), backs; S. Wolstenholme (Blackburn Rovers), C. Roberts (Manchester United), and A. Leake (Aston Villa), half-backs; D. Stokes (Bolton Wanderers), S. Bloomer (Derby County), W. Parkinson (Liverpool), J.V. Bache (Aston Villa), and H.P. Hardman (Everton), forwards.
Scottish League;- H.G. Rennie (Hibernians), goal; T. A. Jackson (St. Mirren), and R. McLeod (Celtic), backs; J. Young (Celtic), C. Thompson (Heart of Midlothians), and J.T Robertson (Rangers), half-backs; A. Bennett (Celtic), R. Walker (Heart of Midlothian), J. Quinn (Celtic), F. Speedie (Rangers), and Alec Smith (Rangers), forwards.
Referee; Mr. Risbotham, Irish Football League.

INTER LEAGUE MATCH
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 13 March 1905
SCOTLAND v  ENGLAND
The fourteenth match between the selected elevens of the English and Scottish leagues took place at New Hampden Park, Glasgow. The rain was driven along by a south westerly breeze, and the conditions were most unpleasant. There were no changes in the teams. There were 25,000 people present. Teams;-
Scottish League;- H.G. Rennie (Hibernians), goal; T. A. Jackson (St. Mirren), and R. McLeod (Celtic), backs; J. Young (Celtic), C. Thompson (Heart of Midlothians), and J.T Robertson (Rangers), half-backs; A. Bennett (Celtic), R. Walker (Heart of Midlothian), J. Quinn (Celtic), F. Speedie (Rangers), and Alec Smith (Rangers), forwards.
English League.- H. Linacre (Notts Forest), goal; H. Spencer (Aston Villa) and H. Burgess (Manchester City), backs; S. Wolstenholme (Blackburn Rovers), C. Roberts (Manchester United), and A. Leake (Aston Villa), half-backs; D. Stokes (Bolton Wanderers), S. Bloomer (Derby County), W. Parkinson (Liverpool), J.V. Bache (Aston Villa), and H.P. Hardman (Everton), forwards.
The Scots won the toss, and kicked with the wind. England kicked off, and worked hard for openings on the right, but the half-back play was strong on both sides. This was just as well, for the breeze was very strong in favour of the Scots. Some clever close dribbling between  Walker and Speedie ended in Quinns dribbling into goal. The Scots continued to have the best of the struggle, and Burgess was bothered by Bennett. Some fine play between Speedie and Smith ended in Smith giving Linacre a handful. For the first time England advanced by the aid of their left wing. Hardman well but Wolstenholme was a yard wide. Following a corner to Scotland the latter had a penalty, which Thompson concerted. Linacre did his side another grand service when he ran out and robbed Speedie and Bennett had hit the crossbar.
Half-time Scotland 2 goals England nil.
On resuming England at once worked down by the right wing, but Bloomer sent wide. The Scots attacked again, Quinn and Smith prevailed. England tried hard, and after a fine run by Stokes, Rennie gave a corner, from which Leake appealed for a penalty, but it was not given. England pressed and Wolstenholme shot wide. It was with difficulty that Rennie saved a shot from Bloomer. A change next came over the game, the Englishmen playing with great dash. Bloomer scored the first for them, and from a corner kick Roberts added a second with a lovely shot from 30 yards’ range. Parkinson put on a third, and the victory was well earned.
Result English League 3 goals, Scottish League 2

CHARGE AGAINST THE EVERTON CLUB
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 13 March 1905
At a meeting of the Lancashire Football Association at Bolton to-morrow, the Everton club will be reported for illegally approaching a player belonging to Liverpool Marine F.C.

EVERTON’S SCORING PROCLIVITIES CONTINUED
Liverpool Echo - Monday 13 March 1905
By Bee
Everton are singing a merry song just now, and their tune on Saturday was once again of a very loud order. Five times they netted the ball, and with a little more steadiness they might have made the number well above half a dozen. The Wednesday team were a trifle stale through their exertions of Thursday, and this being so the manner in which they kept up speed from first to last was decidedly creditable. They started off by beating Roose, Brittleton, the costly player from Stockport County, drawing the blood. When Settle was bowled over the 15,000 people present were confident that such an able referee as Mr. F. Heath would inflict the severest penalty. Mr. Heath promptly pointed to the penalty spot and, in fact throughout the whole of the game his decisions were smartly given, and most satisfactory. Makepeace of course, was the who took the kick. He missed! It would be grossly unfair and unjustifiable to say one word about Makepeace’s failure, for he has pulled us through so often in other matches. It was a very near thing, and half a foot would have made all the difference between a point and a failure. His miss, I fancy rather upset him, and I believe it was his own wish that he should not take the second penalty, which was awarded when Young was palpably fetched down in the penalty “box.” Abbott usually so strong in the shooting department, did no better than his brother half back, but a goal did come, because Sharp was wide-awake, and netted the ball as it rebounded from Lyall’s chest. Yet another penalty! The Wednesday goalkeeper had been drawn out. Sharp had tricked him and passed to McDermott, who drove in a terrific shot, and, with Lyall out of his charge, was it to be wondered at that Burton brought off a stylish save-with his hands! Burton would make a good goalkeeper, taking that save as a criterion. Now Makepeace was entrusted with the kick, and this time it was a beautiful ground shot, with which he completely beat Lyall. It was an excellent representation of the merits of the teams, the score of 5 to 2, because while Everton deserved five goals for their excellent forward work and rapid shooting one cannot deny the visitors a goal or two for the plucky way they kept up the pressure against odds right to the last moment. They never gave up, and one can easily understand that with such determination they made the scores level in the memorable match at Owlerton. When they once get going the Wednesday line cover a lot of ground in an exceedingly short time; in fact, I have seen no team transfer play from goal to goal in so rapid a manner, and the Foulke of forwards, Wilson, was the cause of this beneficial work on Saturday. He made a capital first, and Brittleton, Simpson, and Davies were able to demonstrate their cleverness, because he kept them well fed, and his passes were well timed. The Wednesday backs were not sure, and Ferrier was the best of the halves. Crawshaw did well, but there was too much pushing in the back about his display. He used his head to great advantage. On the winning side the five forwards played splendidly. As a line they were simply magnificent. There was great merit in Sharp’s centres and general footwork and a little movement of his in the second half, almost on the touch line bordering on the grand stand, I considered to be the loveliest bit of football I have seen for a long time. Burton came towards him, and it seemed impossible to get the ball away; it seemed that it must be kicked into touch. Yet Sharp beat his opponent by drawing him to him-sort of “cannon off the left.” He kicked the ball against his left foot, and then wheeled round the back and sent in a centre. McDermott’s passes were the feature of the game. He it was who enabled Young to get the two startling goals so quickly after the second half had been opened; and at all times McDermott was unselfish, accurate, and his exhibition most creditable. Early on Young would not shoot, but as time went on he improved better. He has scored once since December 3, and now he has found his scoring line I hope he will give Aston Villa demonstration of how to net the ball. He did not try to dribble right on to the goal line before shooting when he got his couple of goals. McDermott opened the way for him, and he let fly without hesitation and received a just reward. The left wing was good the half backs very reliable-Jock Taylor’s goal was a real beauty and the backs, when the sun shone in their eyes, were strong. Balmer was erratic, and Crelley in comparison shone out brightly. Balmer is not a dribbler, and full backs should not attempt to dribble almost in front of their own goal mouth. Roose slipped when Davis fell. He saved some hot shots, one from Ferrier being a masterly save. Roose has become a great favourite with the crowd, who seemed pleased to see him race up to Wilson, who had laid Crelley low, and tell him various and sundry words of warning. Trainer Elliott told him to get to his goal and leave the administrative of cautions to the referee.
Sunderland away next week and the Cup semi-final the following week. Business is most important this month.

VARIOUS NEWS ABOUT PLAYERS- PAST AND PRESENT
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 14 March 1905
By Bee
The ball was swung from Rankin’s toe to McDermott, who gave Young the opportunity to shoot. He did so, and netted the ball. The incident happened at Goodison on Saturday and the time it has taken for the compositor to set these few lines into type was about the time taken by the Everton men from the kick-off to the final shot. It is rare indeed that one comes across a goal scored with not one opponent touching the ball, though Saturday’s incident does not constitute a record. Years back, when Everton met Preston North End and Jimmy Ross and Jack Gordon were in their prime the proud Prestonians perpetrated this singular style of goal-scoring against the Blues. Latta, Brady, Fred Geary, Chadwick, Milward, quintet of internationals, were then engaged and Doyle and A. Hannah were also members of the team. I believe. At that time Everton headed the League. Goals scored in the manner mentioned and the taking of three penalty kicks within ninety minutes to say nothing of witnessing a back fist the ball out in orthodox custodian clearance style- these are a few of the strange incidents which occur so unexpectedly in football  encounters, and tend to make the game so enticing and so attractive to watch. Like Micawber, the football public are always “waiting for something to turn up.” But, unlike Dicken’s character, the public yearning is generally satisfied. Let us hope Saturday’s week will turn up -a win for Everton.
Where football followers gather there is argument. Anticipating many other correspondents like “A,G” and “L.H.,” I give a few of the likely disputable points concerning the meeting of the boys in Blue and Villa in ’97. Lord Rosebery said, after witnessing the game, that it had been an “Olympian struggle.” All the goals were scored in thirty-five minutes. Wheldon got two. First the Brums led, then Everton, and then Villa again. The “gate” was 65,891- slightly bigger than last year’s multitude. This may be ancient history, but there are and have been so many inquiries about points of this particularly fine games that it is necessary to go over old ground.
Everton have had a magnificent season from the “paltry” money point of view. I question whether the great rivals of Aston could beat their record, and Woolwich and Small heath to receive before the season ends. The club have already taken more money this season than they did during the whole of last season. During last week they paid off the last mortgage on their ground, which was purchased thirteen years ago for £8,000.
Roose, Hardman and Ashworth were engaged in George Robey’s charity match yesterday. Roose has promised to keep goal for Reading against Southampton to-day. A referee told Mr. Bentley that if he could get McCombie and Carr between Roose and the Everton half-backs and forwards, he would wager that the team would not only beat Scotland, but any possible combination.
  “Old Evertonian” sends a postcard- Your football notes are very interesting, but you would do a good service if you advocated an improvement in the Everton jersey. At present it is a miserable article. I suggest a bordering of yellow or old gold, say on the sleeves and collar; or have the word “Everton” on the front of the jersey. Something ought to be done to improve the present one.
Concerning the Cup-tie, in which Stoke figures prominently, a reader asked if the railway companies might be prevailed upon to return later in the day than on the previous visit. Mr. W.M. Turnbull, London and North-Western Railway, writes that a late train has been arranged for on his line. The Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway representatives says;- “With regard to specials run in connection with matches, it is our practice to obtain suggestions as to times for going and returning from the managers of clubs, and my experience is that the vast majority of the followers are anxious to return with the team.” Bullock and Co state that their private dining-car leaves Stoke at seven o’clock, which the company think a reasonable hour. The extraordinary interest aroused in the encounter can be gauged by the fact that within a week Mr. Bullock had to order another saloon car.

EVERTON F.C. AND A WATERLOO PLAYER.
Liverpool Evening Express - Wednesday 15 March 1905
Unfounded Charge.
At a meeting of the Lancashire Association, held at Bolton last night, the Everton Club was reported for inducing a Waterloo Marine player to join the former club. The Waterloo club were unable to prove, that such was the case, and the complaint was dismissed.
WEST DERBY GUARDIANS.
Last evening, at a meeting of Conservatives of South Walton Ward (36 Polling District), Mr. W. C. Cuff, solicitor, the secretary of the Everton Football Club, was unanimously adopted as a candidate for election to the West Derby Board of Guardians.

EVERTON’S TRAINING
Liverpool Echo - Thursday 16 March 1905
By Bee
Everton have Hardman back in place of Rankin against Sunderland on Saturday; and the men will travel to Roker to-morrow midday, arriving at seven o’clock. I was pleased to hear that Mr. Cuff was coming out in a new light. A football enthusiast of his shrewd charcater would be of great value to a board of guardians.
The Everton directors, at their meeting this week, decided that the usual home training, which has proved so successful since its inception will be relied upon to get the players fit and well for the Villa match. The men have been to Northwich brine baths, and the local authorities there are waking up to the need of improvements for the football clubs visiting their fine brine baths. The Aston Villa players are training quietly at home this week. Country walks, sprinting, &c., are varied by an occasional visit to Droitwich for a salt bath. After the match next Saturday the eleven who defeated Fulham will probably go to Rhyl again, remaining there until the following Friday.
The demand for special saloons by the Everton supporters is a record one, and there has been a phenomenal demand for the 5s reserved tickets for the semi-final. The supply in the hands of the Villa officials is nearly exhausted. So far no arrangements have been made with regard to the postponed League matches between Villa and Manchester City and Villa and Newcastle United, and it is not likely that anything will be done in the matter until after the semi-finals. The same applies to the Everton matches.
R.E.O. (Birkenhead) runs into “rhythm” over the semi-final as follows;-
Oh Everton! Oh Everton” whatever you do,
Do not let Aston Villa be masters of you.
Rub it fu’ like sam buk, for we know you can
Play well, my hearties, each and every man,
You have a Hardman to Settle all your debts
And a man who is Sharp at rattling the nets
If “Sandy” is the dandy, like the days of yore,
The Villa can look out for a pretty big score
And of “Mac” will mak’ sure of shooting at goal,
The Blues will be in the final, upon my soul.

FOOTBALL ITEMS
Liverpool Daily Post - Friday 17 March 1905
Everton have Hardman back in place of Rankin against Sunderland, on Saturday; and the men will travel to Roker to-day, arriving at seven o’clock. The Everton directors at their meeting this week, decided that the usual home training which has proved so successful since its inception, will be replied to get the players fit and well for the Villa match. The men have been to Northwich Brine baths. The Aston Villa players are training quietly at home this week. Country walks, sprinting, &c., are varied by an occasional visit to Droitwich for a salt bath.

WILL EVERTON “COME UNDONE” TO-MORROW?
Liverpool Echo - Friday 17 March 1905
By Bee
Everton’s visit to Sunderland will probably decide whether they are likely to fulfil the first portion of their attempts to gain double-event honours this season. Sunderland, Stoke, Woolwich, Nottingham Forest, and Manchester City have to be met “away” and the greatest of these is Sunderland. Few teams, indeed go to Roker with hopes of a draw, unless it by such as Small Heath, Villa, Woolwich Arsenal, and Middlesbrough, who, it is pretty safe to say had no idea that they were going to make blotches on the Wearsiders’ record when they started on their journey North. With their usual team, and with Rankin on the reserve, Everton made the journey to-day. They will have to fight extremely hard to maintain their position at the top of the ladder, and although hoping it will not happen, I fear that their downfall will be recorded. On November 19 when Sunderland came to Everton, they showed us sterling play, even though Common had an extra duty in coaching a new-youth at outside right. Sunderland have an excellent side, but as they have recently been off-colour they are likely to make a bold bid to beat the leaders of the band. They have chosen the rear division men as in previous matches, but last week’s right wing players Brown and Watkins, are dropped in favour of Thompson and Holley. The left wing remains unaltered, and Hogg again figures in the centre. Thompson is the West End player whom Sunderland engaged only on Tuesday night so he has not had to wait long for a trial in first-class football. No side has yet drawn four points from the “Blues” and Sunderland may be the first to accomplish this feat.

EVERTON
Birmingham Daily Gazette - Saturday 18 March 1905
WHO MEET THE VILLA IN THE CUP SEMI-FINAL NEXT SATURDAY
Aston Villa and Everton, two of the most famous teams in the country, will cross swords at the Victoria Grounds, Stoke, a week to-day for a high prize- the right to appear in the final fight for the “blue ribbon” of the football world, the Football Association Cup. It will be an exacting memorable contest. The Everton officials have little to say about the contest, but Mr. William Cuff, the shrewd secretary, informed our representative that they would meet the Villa with less fear than they did Southampton. If Mr. Cuff’s opinion goes for anything, the Villa will not go to the Palace, for Everton’s 4 to 0 victory over Southampton in the third round was a pronounced success, gained by superior all-round tactics. It was no flash in the pan. The Everton forward line, the smallest set in the country, and probably the most brillaint when playing a winning game, have been scoring heavily. The following figures furnish proof;-
Leigh Richmond Roose is daring to a fault, but withal he is described as “the world’s goalkeeper.” He has some strange action, never fearing, for instance, to run thirty yards out of goal. He is a rare enthusiast, and though qualifying for medical honours in London, he is extremely keen on playing each week. Strangely enough he never sees a ball from one Saturday to another. He will be remembered as the Stoke custodian. He is a marvellous artist, and it is due to his abilities that Everton’s “goals against” total is so small. High, low, long, and short shots come alike to him, if his backs keep a reasonable distance from him.
William Balmer, captain of the team, has a style of his own, and though his health has recently had a deterrent effect on his reliability, he still boots the ball fiercely. He is not a really great tackler, but when he does nip in against his adversaries one can rely on the leather being sent well up the field. He has any amount of confidence, and had gained much popularity, and with his own club’s supporters is a prime favourite, the fact he is a local lad tending to increase good feeling towards him. He received his first International honour this year when England met Ireland.
Crelly is an artistic player of local training. As a school boy at Arnot-street School, he received tuition under Messrs Booth and Smith, and made rapid strides. He is of stiff build, yet can cover the ground smartly. He is equal to Walter Abbott in the art of tackling. He can be placed among the “classiest” of defenders, and may be he will be allotted an International reward before the season ends. He is a certain kick, and his judgement tells him to pass accurately to half-back or forward rather than give a might kick and send the ball into the air. He uses his brains.
Taylor, the centre half, is likely to find Hampson a lively customer. And the latter is more likely to find Taylor too much for him. Taylor puts every ounce of dash and energy into his play. The fact that he formerly partnered Sharp leads him to roam among the front line, and the more arduous the task the more it is relished by him. At fifteen years of age he commenced his football with the Newton Thistle, twelve months later going to Dumbarton, who then had one of the finest teams in the country. He was fortunate enough to receive coaching alongside such stalwarts as Jack Bell and Dick Boyle. In 1892 the Scottish League chose him against England, and in the four following years he was awarded a like distinction. He secured a cap in 1893, in which year he was transferred to Paisley St. Mirren, who afterwards let him go to Liverpool. For four successive seasons he missed but one match, and this inclusive of friendly, League and Cup-tie games. His only absence was the last match in the season. Taylor has played in every position in the field, save goal, for Everton. “Honest Jock” is his nickname. He once laid low an opposing goalkeeper, whom he thought had “sold” the match.
The right half-back, Harry Makepeace, was born at Middlesbrough in 1881 and spent the early part of his life at Darlington. Twelve years ago he went to Liverpool and was educated at Queen’s-road Board School. He began his football career with the club attached to this elementary school, and after leaving became attached to the Queen’s-road Mission, a local Junior League team. In 1901 he was “noticed” by the Everton directors, and has since been associated with the Goodison Park club. His first position was as inside left, but he was transferred to left half-back, where he operated for two seasons in the reserve team. Occasionally he figured in the League eleven last season, and this year, when Abbott was incapacitated, he was requisitioned to fill the vacancy at left half-back. He has improved beyond all knowledge since his acquaintance with First League football. he possesses a rare turn of speed, and uses his head judiciously.
Walter Abbott will be recognised by all the Birmingham enthusiasts. Born in Birmingham in 1878, he started amongst the Juniors with a club called St. Mathias, and then figured at inside left, and from this team he went to Rosewood Victoria, and so notable did he become that the attention of the Small Heath directors turned in his direction in 1895. He had to be content with a reserve position during his first year. as Fred Wheldon operated at inside left. Wheldon left, and Abbott walked in and did surprisingly well. He scored 36 goals in one season, and rapidly attained the reputation of being one of the finest shots in the country. Of the 36 goals scored 6 were from penalties. Everton wanted a good man, and they got one in Abbott in the season at 1898-9. He never, singularly enough, seemed to succeed in his early matches with the Goodison brigade, but this dark period of non-success was the prelude of a dazzling commencement to a sequence of triumphs.  One afternoon he filled a gap at left half, and since then has remained in that position. He was "capped " against Wiles, and has figured in inter- League matches. He has been absent four or five times this season owing to a knee twist sustained in the Sheffield United match, and this seems to have had the effect of increasing his bulk. He seems to tire about three-quarter time. His most memorable effort was when he scored five goals of the right by which Small Heath beat Manchester City in the test matches in 1896.
John Sharp, whose name is peculiarly applicable to him, is still the finest outside right in the country, providing he is in a strenuous mood. He is a great cricketer and a great footballer, and since leaving Aston Villa has come on very rapidly. From his earliest days he has been an enthusiasts. He was in that excellent combination which represented Hereford Thistle in 1896- when Tom Forrester, the Warwickshire and Derbyshire cricketer, and Harper ex-Wolverhampton and Grimsby, were in the zenith of their fame- and carried off the Birmingham League Championship. He is still one of the speediest men in England, and his runs and centres betoken danger. In Cup matches this season he had been above par.
McDermott is one of the finest made right forwards that ever stepped on a field, and is a clever dribbler. When 17 years of age he joined the Cambuslang Hibernians. For three years he assisted the “Hibs” and then he threw in his lot with Dundee, for whom he played a couple of seasons. His next migration was to his native city, where he became connected with the famous Celts. His abilities were quickly recognised, and he was chosen to represent Glasgow in the inter-city fixture with Edinburgh, and in March, 1902, he received his first international cap, playing for Scotland against Ireland. Next season he was noted by Everton scouts and against Blackburn Rovers on September 1 he made his first appearance.
Young, the centre forward, is a variable sort, who plays one good game in three matches on an average. He takes the bumps a centre forward must inevitably expect and determination makes up for the lack of skill at times.
Settle is of the class of footballer without a commanding stature, but possessing a head almost an equal in utility of old Caesar Jenkins. He was born in Millom, in Cumberland, twenty-six years ago. In 1894 he went to Bolton Wanderers and in 1896-7 was signed by Bury, and threw in his lot with Everton in 1899. He filled every position in the forward rank, with the exception of outside right. A capital shot, and one of the most troublesome forwards to keep in check, he is a terror for his size.
Hardman is a young player, unassuming, and there is no more popular player. He is studying for law at Blackpool, and is quite out of the run of the average footballer. He is quite a diminutive lad, but is one of the pluckiest footballers that ever stepped on a football field. At seventeen years of age he was a member of the Blackpool High School team, and shaped so well in a medal competition that the Blackpool Club signed him up. Towards the close of 1902-3 he assisted Everton, and had a great desire to become a regular member of the League eleven, founded partly upon ambition, and also upon the fact that having a knowledge of some of the players he would feel more at home with them. He has missed one League match only, this being the Villa fixture last September.

TEAM ARRNAGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 18 March 1905
EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
League match at Roker; kick-off at 3.30;
Everton.- Roose, goal; R. Balmer and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Everton Reserve v Darwen
Lancashire Combination match, at Goodison; 3.30
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Wildman and Kerr, backs; Hanlin, Chadwick, and Littleton, half-backs; Roberts, Mcloughlin, Johnston, Thorburn, and Dilly, forwards.

EVERTON v  SUNDERLAND
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 18 March 1905
LEAGUE DIVISION 1
SUNDERLAND LEAD AT THE INTERVAL
In view of the great claims for championship honours the Everton team had one of the stiffest encounters of the season this afternoon when they were due to meet Sunderland at Roker Park. The meeting of the old-time rivals is always interesting, but on this occasion the attractiveness was redoubted by reason of Everton’s position not only in the League competition, but in the English Cup tournament. The long journey to the banks of the Wear was undertaken yesterday, the men reaching Sunderland at seven o’clock. A quiet evening at theatre was succeeded this morning by a gentle stroll to the famous Roker. The weather was agreeably mild and springlike and the men greatly enjoyed the invigorating breeze that blew in from the North Sea. The visitors hoped to be at full strength, but at the last moment W. Balmer, who was injured last week was unable to play, and his place was filled by his brother. The only other change was the return of Hardman in the home ranks there were one or two alterations, Fullerton reappeared and the right wing pair were Thompson and Holley, the first named being altogether new to League football. Locally the game attracted enormous interest, and there was a fine crowd present when the teams lined up as follows;-
Everton.- Roose, goal; R. Balmer and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor (captain), and Abbott, halves; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Sunderland; Webb, goal; Rhodes and Watson, backs; Farquhar, Fullerton, and Jackson, halves; Thompson, Holley, Hogg, Gemmell, and Bridgett, forwards.
Referee S. Kirkham. Sunderland lost the toss, and there were fully sixteen thousand spectators present when Hogg started in the face of a brilliant sun. the home left at once attempted to get away, but first Makepeace and then Balmer checked the leather, which went over to the right wing, and Crelly was in difficulties when the ball went outside. This the way to a brilliant advance on the part of the Everton left, Hardman and Settle working down with rare cleverness, and the amateurs’ centre looked extremely dangerous when Watson nipped in and cleared, the Evertonians now got into their proper stride and they treated the crowd to some wonderfully fine footwork. The movement ended in McDermott being given a splendid opening, but he shot badly, and a golden opportunity was lost. Following upon this there was end to end play and Hogg put in a long shot, but it was charged down. The visitors immediately got going on the right, Sharp put in a very effective centre. This was partially cleared by Watson, and Young rushing in made a gallant attempt to lower Webb’s charge, but the screw on the ball carried it outside. A temporary break by the Wearsiders was well beaten back by the Everton defenders, and once again the visitors took up the running. This time there was some splendid combined work, and McDermott passing forward to Young, the latter netted the ball. He was distinctly offside, and the point was promptly disallowed. The home forwards then got going strongly on the right, and Holly put in a fine shot which Roose fisted out. Before he had time to recover himself Hogg dashed in and headed the ball into the net.
This success came after ten minutes’ play, and was received with terrific cheering. Having thus early gained a lead, the home team played up with great spirit, and for some moments it looked as though they would completely overwhelm the Everton defence. A long bombardment was eventually cleared by Taylor, and the Evertonians made an incursion into the home territory, the three inside men being all concerned in a bully in front of Webb, but the danger was cleared by Rhodes, and the Sunderland left ran down in refreshing fashion. Balmer checked them for a moment, but the home centre-half got possession, and put in a long, which Roose cleared cleverly. A few seconds later he kicked clear from Gemmill. The home team were now having distinctly the best of the argument, and for a time it seemed as though the visitors were demoralised. A promising movement on the right ended in Taylor fouling when close in. Farquhar took the free kick, and the ball rebounded to Hogg, who netted it right out of Roose’s reach. This second success gave Sunderland renewed confidence, and they continued to press strongly. The visitors, however, gradually pulled themselves together and advanced on the right. A foul against Watson gave them the advantage of a free kick, and Sharp who took it, just shaved the wrong side of the upright. Play now settled down somewhat, but the excitement continued unabated and some really fine football was shown by both teams. A combined movement by the Everton forwards ended in Sharp putting in a glorious dropping shot, but it went outside. A moment later the Lancashire cricketer was again on the job, and he forced a corner. This was well placed and the bully in front of Webb ended in another corner being granted. This was again taken by Hardman but it proved fruitless, and after some midfield work the home forwards again began to pay attention to Roose. A free kick from the centre half was luckily intercepted, and then Gemmell shot outside. The pace was now rather slower than before, though the Everton defence found all their work cut out for them, and on two occasions Taylor was invaluable in coming to the assistance of the two backs. A long spell of midfield play was followed by a clever forward movement on the part of the Evertonians, the whole line being concerned. Young was about to shoot when he was dispossessed, and Sharp, nipping in, struck the outside of the net. A breakaway by hardman and Settle looked very promising, but Rhodes robbed the latter and cleared well. Then Sharp got down on his own once more, and showing a clean pair of heels to Watson, he swung the ball right across the goalmouth. Hardman ran in, and had nobody beat when he shot tamely outside. This failure on the part of the clever little amateur was very disappointing to the Everton supporters, and was hailed with proportionate delight by the Wearsiders. Nevertheless the visitors played up with rare pluck, and Young, after picking his way through, shot over the bar. Towards the interval the Evertonians put forth strenuous efforts to make up the adverse leeway, and Taylor put in a vigorous shot, but it was cleared. Further exciting play in front of the home goal ensued, but the Sunderland defence was thoroughly sound, and time after time the Blues were beaten back, and half-time arrived with the score;- Sunderland 2 goals, Everton nil.
Final Result; Everton 3 goals, Sunderland 2 goals.
Everton returned from Sunderland last season with 2 goals to nil against them.

EVERTON v  DARWEN
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 18 March 1905
LANCASHIRE COMBINATION-DIV A
At Goodison Park this afternoon. The visitors immediately forced matters on the left, Chadwick running the ball over the goal line. Everton took up the running, and Roberts shot outside. After the visitors had failed to pierce the Everton defence, the home forwards moved off in promising fashion, Johnston and Thorburn being conspicuously prominent. Hindley clearing the threatened danger by leaving his charge. At the other end Kitchen brought off a good save from a well-placed free kick, while from a dashing run by Dilly and a clever centre by McLoughlin Hindley threw clear. Both sides infused any amount of dash into their play, and Greaves, getting between the home defenders with the ball at his toe, easily defeated Kitchen after ten minutes’ play. Roberts sent the ball right across the Darwen goal when the mildest touch must have recorded a score. Johnston and Dilly both failed from a similar opening a moment later, much to the disgust of the home supporters. So far there was little to choose between the teams. The Everton forwards had shown a lamentable weakness in front of goal, and missed many openings, while the visitors’ forwards were never slow to test the abilities of Kitchen. In all other departments they were fairly evenly matched. McLoughlin received near the centre, and Hollis slipped in attempting to dispossess him. The Evertonians, taking advantage of the accident, continued on his course, and finished by beating Hindle with a really good attempt. The Blues now bombarded the visitors’ citadel, but erratic shooting brought timely relief to the visitors. Midfield play followed to the interval, which arrived with the score; Darwen 1 goal, Everton 1 goal. Final.- Darwen 2, Everton Res 1.

EVERTON RESERVES V. DARWEN
March 18, 1905. The Lancashire Evening Post
At Goodison Park, in beautiful weather. Play was well contested at the outset, both goals being visited in rapid succession. Kitchen and Hindle both had to handle, but nothing resulted. McLoughlin made a fairly good attempt, but Hindle saved and Darwen pressed again. After about ten minutes' play the visitors attacked hard, and Greaves beat Kitchen. Everton exerted themselves after this, and had much the best of matters, but fine defence by Darwen, coupled with poor shooting, lost several easy opportunities. Subsequently McLoughlin equalized for Everton after heavy pressure. Fast play followed, the home lot trying hard to obtained the lead, but Hindle and his backs were safe. Half-time –Everton Reserves 1, Darwen 1. Resuming after the interval, play was very evenly contested, the visitors fully testing the Everton defence. Booth, Kitchen and Hindle were responsible for good clearances. The Blues tried repeatedly to force the lead but Darwen's defence behaved well. Eventually Chadwick scored for Darwen, who maintained their lead to the end. Result; Everton reserves 1, Darwen 2.

EVERTON’S FINE PERFORMANCE
Athletic News - Monday 20 March 1905
By Junius
Everton’s success at Sunderland created the liveliest feelings of satisfaction in the city.  They have only once before gained two points on the Sunderland ground, though they have twice drawn there, and in view of their chance of securing the League championship the visit to Wearside was looked upon as the most difficult engagement.  In several matches this season they have effectually demolished the idea that they could only play a winning game.  Since Roose joined the team they have enjoyed almost phenomenal success, and only two defeats have been sustained in the period.  On November 19 Sunderland beat them at Goodison Park, and on January 7 they were vanquished at Bramell-lane.  In the meantime they have won eleven League games drawn three and three Cup-ties have been decided in their favour.  This is championship form, and on their present showing they will require beating by the best teams in the country.  Everton are quickly preparing for the great game at Stoke next Saturday, and the policy of home training is proving a magnificent success.  Brine baths at Northwich seems to be quite the fashion and the Everton players themselves speak highly of the advantage which they have deprived from their visit to the Cheshire town.
EVERTON RESERVES BEATEN
For the third time this season, the Everton second string were beaten on their own ground.  Darwen accomplishing this by two goals to one.  The visitors played capital football, and fully deserved their success, their forwards especially displaying fine combination and keeping the home defence fully extended.  Greaves scored their first goal but McLaughlin equalized before the interval.  In the second half Chadwick placed his side ahead, and Darwen gained a very creditable victory.  Greaves at centre forward was seen to great advantage, and the men on either side of him.  Bow and Crook were responsible for much prominent, whilst Derbyshire was a very disappointing display, the forward being weak and the best football came from the right wing.  Roberts and McLaughlin combing nicely at times.  In defence, Wildman was the outstanding figure and Chadwick was a long way the pick of the half-backs. 

WONDERFUL WIN ON WEARSIDER
Athletic News - Monday 20 March 1905
By Tom Tiddler
Sunderland had a visit from Everton, their most frequent opponents, on Saturday, and a spirited contest ended in favour of the visitors by 3-2.  This is their second victory at Roker, and still further strengthens their position at the head of affairs.  Sunderland made further changes in their front rank from the previous week, introducing Thompson, the local lad, who was only signed on the Tuesday might, and placing him alongside of Holley.  Brown and Watkins were the thus dropped, Hogg remaining as pivot.  On the visiting side only one alteration was noted, Hardman coming in again for Rankin.  Glorious weather favoured the fixture, though the ground was a bit greasy, the result of recent rains.  Everton was always a popular team with Wearside folk, and they received a rousing reception from a crowd that numbered at least 20,000 people.  Sunderland had a glaring sun to face at the outset, and were early put on their defence.  Within five minutes Young was presented with a grand opening but kicked wide.  He was more fortunate shortly afterwards, but the referee had no doubt as to his being offside.  Some nine minutes from the start Roose fisted out, and Barrie pouncing upon the ball transferred to Holley, who headed into the net to the accompaniment of tumultuous cheering.  Everton made a great effort to draw level, and some lively bouts ensued.  Sunderland came again, however, and with the contest 20 minutes old Hogg, with a terrific drive along the ground, scored Sunderland’s second goal.  There were now visions of a glorious victory in store, and there were radiant smiles all-round the enclosures.  Roused by this second reverse the visitors put more energy into their play, and up to the interval they certainly did more attacking than the Wearsiders.  The home defenders preserved a clean sheet to the interval, Sunderland thus crossing over with a useful lead.  The second half opened quietly, but Everton were not long in finding their feet.  Seven minutes after crossing over McDermott took advantage of an opening at short range and reduced the lead.  A quarter of an hour later Young came away and putting out nicely to Sharp, the latter carried along the line, and working the ball across, equalized with a splendid low drive.  Just after this Gemmell had a grand chance of scoring, and a howl of disappointment went up when he shot wide.  The famous Lancashire cricketer was again in evidence, and with a repetition of his previous movement gave his side the lead with a brilliant shot.  The crowd cheered Sharp to the echo, and right well did he deserve it.  Sunderland were not yet done with, but struggle as they might they were not clever enough to get on terms, and so had to retire beaten.  Everton were the cleverer team and undoubtedly deserved to win.  They made fewer mistakes than the home lot, and this was perhaps the most striking difference between the teams.  Everton were cooler and more methodical in their work than Sunderland, but what the latter lacked in that respect they made up for in dash.  Taken all round the contest was a fine one, and to winners and losers alike praise must be accorded.  For the winners Roose was very smart and clean in all he did.  Balmer and Crelley gave a masterful display of back play, Crelley in the second half volleyed the ball in all sorts of positions with precision.  Taylor was great at centre half and the best of the line.  Abbott had the measure of his opposing wing pretty nearly all through.  Among the attacking brigade Sharp was brilliant, his display being equal to anything seen at Roker this season.  Young was very reliable in the centre, and finding his right wing the smartest plied them for all he was worth.  Settle at times put in some dainty touches, but Hardman appeared to be off colour and was the least prominent of the line.  Turning to Sunderland, Hogg led his forwards in dashing style, and the best men with him were Bridgett and Holley.  As a wing, however, Gemmill and Bridgett were the more effective.  Perhaps it was asking too much of the local lad, Thompson, to play in such an important fixture.  He was very speedy, accurate in his centring, and has the makings of a good winger.  Barrie was fine at centre-half, but neither Jackson nor Farquhar were up to concert pitch.  Jackson allowed Sharp to much scope in the second half and ought to have stuck to him closer than a brother.  Watson was the better back.  Webb  did well.  Sunderland;- Webb; Rhodes, Watson; Farquhar; Barrie, Jackson; Thompson, Holley, Hogg, Gemmill, and Bridgett.  Everton; L.R. Roose; Balmer; Crelley; Makepeace, Taylor, Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P. Hardman.  Referee; T. Kirkham, Burslem. 

SUNDERLAND 2 EVERTON 3
March 20, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
EVERTON'S MAGNIFICENT VICTORY.
A DIFFICULT HURDLE.
Everton encountered a very difficult hurdle in the League course in the shape of Sunderland, but they negotiated it with complete success. True, it required all their resourcefulness to accomplish the Wearsiders downfall by three goals to two, for they were meeting a combination which hitherto had preformed with considerable success against them, and who in the earlier part of the season registered a victory at Goodison. Thanks to brilliant play in the return encounter Everton wiped that account off the slate. Having thus got rid of those formidable rivals, the path to championship honours should now be comparatively easy, if the locals will continue that irresistible form they are now showing, and which spells winning matches. The result of Saturday's contest ought to lend encouragement for their great task at Stoke next Saturday. The only absentee from the accustomed ranks was W.Balmer, whose injury in the Sheffield Wednesday prevented his playing, and his brother filled the vacancy. The Wearsiders, who seem to have been experimenting of late, gave a trial to a local youth named Thompson, whom they have just signed on, and again brought in Holley, another Sunderland youth, who was dropped in the Derby County match.
A HARD FOUGHT GAME.
To have two goals chalked up against them at half-time, and then to responded with three goals in the second half, especially against a strong side such as Sunderland, says much for the conquering mood in which the Evertonians appear to be at the present time. To most teams this substantial lead would have been demoralising, and taken all the heart out of them. Not so, Everton however. They recognised that there was a great deal at stake. It was a hard and keenly fought game, and with a few exceptions of the fast order, the 18,000 spectators being treated to a fine exposition of the game. They had the satisfaction of seeing Everton displaying the sparkle and brilliancy which latterly has characterised their play. Determination was apparent on both sides from the very beginning. The Wearsiders were worrying in the first few minutes, this having its termination in a successful “header” from Hogg, the centre ten minutes after the kick off. The visitors them gave the home defence a lot to do, but it stood the test well. Sunderland could not be kept in check, the forwards were as fresh as paint, and they again bothered their opponents, with the result that Roose had no chance with a lighting shot from Hogg. It anything the game was keener after this, and the spectators were treated to some fine runs and centres by Sharp, whilst others of the forward line were putting forth their hardest efforts, which deserved better success. It looked as if this had come before half-time, Sharp swung the ball across the goal mouth, but Hardman could only managed to put it just outside. Although Sunderland had played a dashing sort of game, they were not two goals better than Everton, who oftentimes had been within an ace of scoring. It was left to McDermott to open Everton's score, the clever inside right beating Webb with a fast shot, Sunderland strove bravely to strengthen their position, and some of their moves were exceptionally brilliant. But nothing seemed to baulk Sharp, who was frequently out on his own. Once he placed the ball nicely to Settle, who, however, put outside. The equaliser at length came from the cricketor, who also succeeded in notching the decending goal five minutes later.
SHARP AGAIN BRILLIANT.
If Everton were a little time getting into their stride, they afterwards came out in their true colours. The forwards sped along with characterstic dash, the short passing game being adopted with successful results. As already indicated, Sharp was the hero of the vanguard. He put in many pretty touches, and the way he outwitted Gemmill and Bridgett and got past Jackson was a treat to see. His centres were very well timed, and one in particular might have been better taken advantage of by one of his colleagues. He had useful assistance from McDermott, whose dribbling was often very noticeable. On the other wing Settle did capital work, and his colleagues, H.P.Hardman, although rather weak in shooting, got through any amount of work in neat style. The qualities of the halves were thoroughly tested, and the examination showed by Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott to be very reliable and effective, while R.Balmer and Crelly were frequently responsible for getting their side out of a tight corner. Roose was kept fairly busy, and did exceedingly well with some of the shots with which he was plied.
SUNDERLAND'S DISPLAY.
The footwork of the Sunderland forwards was of a high order, and compared very favourably with that of Everton. Hogg was a dangerous centre, who made good use of the passes. Bridgetts the outside left, was a glutton for work; he frequently went through a bunch of opponents with the ball at his toes. He is a tricky player. The new man, Thompson, was often conspicuous on the outside right, and both he and Holley made good use of their opportunities. The halves played a steady and safe game. Jackson and Farquhar coming in for most notice. Rhodes and Watson, the two backs, had a busy time in clearing, and they often cleared well under difficulties, Watson's tackling was a feature.

EVERTON RESERVES 1 DARWEN RESERVES 2
March 20, 1904.
The Liverpool CourierLancashire Combination “A” Division (Game 27)
Everton are this season making but a poor show in the competition, and cannot hope to figure even amongst the first half-dozen. They gave anything but a good display against Darwen on Saturday, and the Peaceful Valley team well deserved their victory. Everton, it must be said, were poorly represented, but they should have given a better exhibition than they did. All through Darwen played fine football, and result of brilliant effort by Greaves, and although McLoughlin equalised before the interval. Chadwick afterwards gave the visitors a lead, which they easily held to the close. Everton were best represented by Kitchen, Wildman, McLoughlin, and Dilly, Johnston, a new centre, tried hard, but with indifferent success while Thornburn did nothing. Darwen proved themselves one of the strongest teams seen at Goodison-park this season, so far as Lancashire Combination matches are concerned, and if they retain the same players next season should make a bold bid for championship honours. Everton: - Kitchen, goal, Wildman, and Kerr, backs, Hanlin, Chadwick, and F.Littlejohn, half-backs, Roberts, McLoughlin, Johnston, Thornburn and Dilly, forwards.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 20 March 1905
Sunderland has not been a happy hunting ground for Everton. Inclusive of Saturday’s game the clubs have met on no fewer than 38 occasions; the Wearsiders’ record being 23 victories, 10 defeats, and 5 drawn games. Several of Everton’s victories, however, have been of the most pronounced type, and there is still on record Sunderland’s heaviest league defeat at the hands of the local club. Only a solitary goal has separated the sides on 19 occasions, and Saturday’s contest served to demonstrate the keenness with which the players enter into the spirit of their work. Everything was favourable for a capital exposition of the code, though possibly the ground was a little on the soft side, and it was not surprising that quite 20,000 spectators were present. There were several changes in the home ranks from the side that did duty on the previous week, and local interest was naturally directed to the right wing, where Thompson a youth who had been signed on during the week, was given his first trial in League football. Balmer was unable to take his place on the Everton side, owing to an injury received last week, and his brother was drafted into the team. From the outset it was quite evident that the spectators were to have a capital afternoon’s sport. There was a keenness infused into the game, and a cleverness that pervaded the movements of the players that kept the huge crowd fully interested. Everton opened out the play in fine style, and the inside forwards supplemented clever footwork by affording the wing men every opportunity of displaying their sprinting and centring powers. Quite early on Young only just failed to convert from Sharp and though he did place into the net immediately afterwards he was pal[ably off-side. From this point the Sunderland players became most aggressive and the combined play of the forwards and half backs was for a lengthy period well nigh perfect. The ball was kept low, and passed from one to the other with an accuracy that astonished the home supporters of the club, and it was not surprising that early on a couple of goals should have occurred to the side. Both points were cleverly obtained by Hogg, the home centre. After some pretty triangular passing the ball was centred from the outside right, and though Roose was ready to deal with a strong drive by Holley, Hogg got in the way and cleverly headed the ball out of the custodian’s reach. This success came after ten minutes’ play, and ere a similar period had expired the second goal was recorded at the result of a free kick against Taylor. There was no disputing the fact that, for a long period, the Sunderland side was by far the cleverer; but still, Everton had chances that were not utilised. On one occasion Sharp ran clean through the home defence, and put the ball to Hardman who had an open goal, but there was evidently a great amount of screw on the leather as the left winger, who appeared to make a huge drive for the net, put the ball back to Sharp, and the chance was gone. Again Sharp only just missed from a free  kick against Watson for fouling McDermott and just on the interval Young failed to take advantage of an easy opening. Still, there could be no denying the fact that the Wearsiders played the better football during the initial half. Their movements were delightfully crisp; they were keen on the ball, and the defence, with very few exceptions, was always ready for emergencies. They had the disadvantage of playing with the sun in their faces, and, having such a substantial lead at half-time, matters did not appear at all promising for the visitors. Immediately upon resuming, quite a change came over the game. The Everton forwards at once bounded into promising stride and their persistency was at length rewarded by a goal from the foot of McDermott after the ball had been bobbing about in front of the home goal for quite a minute. At intervals the Wearsiders got off in strong rushes, but they were not able to sustain them as in the early portion of play. For the most part the Evertonians were the more aggressive and it befitted the occasion that Sharp who and all along been a thorn in the side of the home defence, should have obtained the equalising point, and then give his side the lead as the outcome of a brilliant effort. Everton more than made amends for their shortcomings during the first portion, and there could be no question that the result of the game was mainly due to the fitness of the men. They stayed better than their opponents who had evidently run themselves out in the first portion; and on the general run of the game Everton quite deserved full points. The Everton team are to be complimented upon their fine performance, especially in view of the fact that at the interval they were two goals to arrear. The display of Sharp, apart from the two goals with which he credited his side, was one of the principal features of the match. Time and again he put in beautiful centres, and on his Saturday’s form the English Selection Committee need look no further than Everton’s dashing outside right to represent England in that position in the great encounter with Scotland. There was no weakness apparent among the remainder of the forwards, and the accurate passes out to the wings by Young had not a little to do with success. During the first portion the Everton halves were several times in difficulties but after once getting the measure of the Sunderland forwards they played with their customary confidence, and allowed practically no quarter. The younger Balmer and Crelly were a capable pair of backs, and when it is stated that Roose had no chance with the shots from Hogg, the quality of his work can readily be imagined. For Sunderland Hogg was in great shooting trim; Bridgett was most aggressive on the wing; while the two inside men. Gemmill and Holley were always a dangerous pair to keep in check. The defence was clever in the first half but was often overrun in the second; and Webb on the whole, kept a good goal.

INTERNATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 20 March 1905
SCOTLAND v  IRELAND
Beaten badly by Wales at Wrexham, Scotland played the second of their matches in the International Championship at Parkhead, on Saturday, when Ireland who had shared honours with England at Middlesbrough, were entertained before an attendance which failed to come up to expectations, there being  only some 25,000 people present when Murphy kicked off for the Hibernians. Ireland had doubts about their backs, but McCartney was able to turn out, along with McCracken, and the sides controlled by Mr. Fred Kirkham, of Preston were;-
Scotland.- Howden (Patrick Thistle) goal; McLeod (Celtic) and McIntosh (3rd Lanark), backs; Gibson (Patrick Thistle), Thomson (Heart of Midlothian), and Hay (Celtic), half-backs; Walker (Glasgow Rangers), McMenemy (Celtic), Quinn (Celtic), Somers (Celtic), and Wilson (Hearts of Midlothian), forwards.
Ireland- Scott (Everton), goal; McCracken (Newcastle United), and McCartney (Everton), backs; Darling (Linfield), Connor (Glentoran), and McConnell (Glentoran), half backs; Mercer (Derby County), Maxwell (Glentoran), Murphy (Queen’s Park Rangers), O’Hagan (Tottenham Hotspur), and Kirwan (Tottenham), forwards.
Play was early interesting for Ireland on the right wing pressed till on the left McConnell fouled Gibson, and Quinn shot past from McLeod’s kick. McCracken badly fouled Quinn six yards from the penalty line, but nothing came from the kick. Then the Hibernians had a turn, and Howden gave a corner in saving a volley from Murphy. The kick was cleared. Scotland were clever enough, and for ten minutes did everything but get goals, for which the sound defence by McCracken and Scott was mainly responsible. However, the point came, luckily maybe, for McCartney fisted out a ball from McMenemy, and from the penalty Thomson scored. For a long time the visiting forwards could not make headway. They were nippy and clever, but could not beat the home half backs, of whom Thomson was in great form. Rain fell in the last quarter of the period, but did not spoil the play. However, a slippery ball upset the calculations of Scott, and have a second goal to the Caledonians. McMenemy gave a pass to Walker, who went down the right wing at top gallop, he beat McConnell and Connor, and shot a long low ball, and Scott muffed the field, and the ball went a foot over the line. With the exception of an occasional breakaway. Scotland pressed to the interval. Half-time; Scotland 2, Ireland nil.
The second half began in keen style, for Ireland had a fine chance in front of Howden, but Murphy was slow, and the opportunity was lost. The Scots at the other end, however, were different, and after a fine bit of wide passing Wilson centred to Quinn, who beat Scott. Scotland had the better of the succeeding play, some of the combination of the half-backs and forwards being exceptionally clever. But the Irishmen gave away the fourth point. McCracken fisting down a soft shot from McMenemy, and paying the penalty of his folly. Thomson kicked the fourth goal. Ireland’s a misfortunes continued, for Mercer got hurt, and was carried off. McCracken got crocked, but stuck on till the close of the game, in the finishing minutes of which Wilson got injured.
Result; Scotland 4 goals, Ireland nil.

PROSPECTIVE HONOURS
Liverpool Echo - Monday 20 March 1905
EVERTON F.C PLAYERS’ ASTOUNDING WIN AT ROKER
By Bee
Everton -Played 28, Won 18, Lost 6, Draw 4, For 55, Against 30, Points 40
Liverpool -Played 27, Won 22, Lost 2, Drawn 3, For 74, Against 21, Points 47
Liverpool Reserves- Played 27, Won 16, Lost 6, Draw 5, For 79, Against 40, Points 37
These three records are generating excitement altogether above the ordinary average. Everton are prime favourites this season, and their sensational victory over Sunderland at Roker has raised hopes that even though the men must feel the strain of the season’s heavy engagements, they will equal the record held by Aston Villa and Preston, and win both League and Cup trophies. Before the encounter it was generally conceded that Everton appeared certain to break down at the awkward fence. After the final score was learnt there were such a number of local wiseacres, “know-alls,” ready to say, “I said they would win!” The win was a sterling one, and again provides us with the demonstration of Everton’s extra ordinary grit this season. The Blues went to Sunderland on November 16th 1901, and swept the home lot away with a 4-2 victory. This was their only previous victory. Saturday’s attainment, however, was streets ahead of this performance. At the home team had pierced Roose’s charge twice successfully, and the game was to most people present as good as over. They had not reckoned with the men whose courage is wonderful and whose tenacity is remarkable-men, in short, who lately refuse to be beaten, and have not tasted the “bitters” since January 7. The ruddy-faced Sharp gave a display of a life-time and three times the ball was whipped past Webb!  Such a display made even the Northern enthusiasts cheer the visitors heartily, and Sharp and Young came in for especial praise. After the cricketer footballer’s sparkling exhibition I am open to say that he will displace Bond in the international match against Scotland. As the game went on Sunderland became aggressive immediately after Young had failed to convert from Sharp, and the well-nigh perfect passing and shooting of both sides was excellent to behold. Hogg hopped in and scored a couple after Roose had dealt with a strong drive by Holley. Hogg’s head put the ball far out of Roose’s reach and ten minutes later, after Sunderland’s superiority had been noticeable a free kick was ordered against Taylor, and the Wearsiders were 2 up. The fact that the visitors missed open goals showed that they got away smartly. Hardman had an open goal even, but the screw of the ball deceived him. After a welcome “lemon time” the Everton men bounded into their stride, just as in the latter half of the game against Sheffield Wednesday. McDermott put an end to the bobbing of the ball in front of Webb, and insides a minute the lee-way was lessened. Sharp put in many touches of brilliance, and as is generally the case with him, his centres were lifted well, and always so judiciously timed that more tangible use should have been made of them. This is how Sharp got his goals. Young, on each occasion, drove out to the cricketer, who careered along the line and worked the ball in towards the penalty area as each opponents came to tackle him. He would up with brilliant shots, and low drives which would have beaten any goalkeeper. Each of the divisional men played in his best style in the second half. All dallying a treason, and McDermott appears to realise the truth of this statement now. He and Young plied Sharpe because they could readily see what a lively mood the extreme right man was in. settle and Hardman were always on the go, and were also the half backs. W. Balmer will be ready for next Saturday’s encounter. His brother and Crelly played a solid defence along with Roose. The home defence very powerful in the first half, but like all other defences they found to their cost when Everton get into their stride there is always absolutely no holding them.
On Saturday, the Villa secured their eighth successive victory. In those matches they have scored 26 goals to 6, so it is evident that the shooting of the forwards so weak in the earlier part of the season, has wonderfully improved. The players left on Saturday night for their Rhyl training quarters and will stay there until the morning of the tie. They are in excellent spirits, but it is not likely that their comparatively easy win on Saturday will render them over-confident. They recognise that there is all the difference between meeting a disorganised Sheffield United at Villa Park and an all-conquering Everton  at Stoke. There was a singular coincidence in regard to the matches played by them on Saturday. They put three teams into the field. The first beat Sheffield United by 3 goals to nil, the second team beat Stourbridge, at Stourbridge by 3 goals to nil, and the third team met the picked strength of the local junior League and won by the same 3 goals to nil.
The English International Selection Committee has chosen the following team to represent England against Wales, at Liverpool, on March 27-
Linacre (Nottingham Forest), H. Spencer (Aston Villa captain), H. Smith (Reading), Wolstenholme (Blackburn Rovers), Roberts (Manchester United), Leake (Aston Villa), Bond (Preston North End), Bloomer (Derby County), V.J. Woodward (Tottenham Hotspur), S.S. Harris (Corinthians) and H.P. Hardman (Everton).

THE CUP TIES
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 21 March 1905
Yesterday Everton commenced their training for the great English Cup semi-final at Stoke on Saturday against Aston Villa with another course of Northwich brine baths. The full team, three reserves, the trainer, and a director were present. Everton express their lively appreciation of the Northwich brine, which is the strongest in the world, and has proved so popular amongst League footballers as to necessitate special arrangements by the municipal authorities.

A ”BRUM” OPINION
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 21 March 1905
COMPARING THE SEMI-FINAL FOOTBALL TEAMS
TWO BEST HALF BACK LINES
“One of Your Old Football Chums,” a gentleman who worthily kept goal, writes “Bee” as follows;-
“I am of ‘Brum, therefore hope to see the Villa come out on top next Saturday at Stoke; and, mark you, we have expect they will -of course you don’t. I have been comparing the strength of the teams, both individually and by the various lines. In goal Everton have the advantage; but if your team will only try to smash the crossbar, and not cut up the grass between the post when they shoot- well, they will not get many past George. George is all right on his feet, but he hasn’t had much exercise.
Miles and Spencer
Are a splendid combination of youth and age, nimbleness and caution, vigour and experience, and if your forwards are to get past them they will have to remember which is youth and which is the veteran and play accordingly. Clever individual play will not pay against our international veteran. Speed can beat him, tricky play and passing will not. At half back probably Everton have slightly the better of us- not much, though. In my opinion the two best half backs lines in the kingdom will be on the Stoke ground. Forward, I quite confidently look to see brilliancy on both sides; but even you, I think, must admit of present form the Villa hold the palm, for have they not scored 26 goals in the last eight matches- a record I don’t think Everton can produce.
  “Be content, dear “Bee,” for it’s Everton for the League Cup, Villa for the Old Tin Pot.
   “Still, I tremble for our Bum favourites if Everton play the fine game they did against Small heath-the finest played this season on the Small Heath ground. Of victory for the Villa I should be absolutely certain if they were only a weaker team, for it is well known that the weakest team can always do against Everton what the strongest cannot. Now, friend, Brum is ready to welcome the Old Tin Pot again, and welcome it they will.”
A Birmingham football paper has the following about the match;-
  “Mr. Rinder, the Villa chairman, some time ago expressed the opinion that his boys were going to carry off the League championship and that they would not lose another match. The first part of the prophecy remains to be fulfilled, but the second is being justified by events in a most remarkable manner. At the time of writing Villa seem absolutely unconquerable. Like Achilles, they may have a vulnerable part, but the enemy bath not found it yet. Here we are in the Ides of March, and since the 21st of January the Villa have not once failed to win a match, either at home or away.  How is this for a record;-
Jan 28- Sunderland League away 3-2
Feb 4 -Leicester Fosse (Association Cup) home 5-1
Feb 11- Derby County (League) away 2-0
Feb 18 -Bury (Association Cup) home 3-2
Feb 25- Small Heath (League) away 3-0
Mar 4- Fulham (Association Cup), home 5-0
Mar 11-Notts County (League) away 2-1
Mar 18-Sheffield United (League) home 3-0
Total 26-6
“In eight consecutive matches, therefore which included four away League games, Villa have been triumphant. But for the lamentable weakness in the Sheffield Wednesday match the proud record could have been carried much further back, for the Villa either won or drew their previous eight matches. Still, if a sequence of sixteen matches with only one defeat isn’t one to feel elated about, it would be difficult to know what the Villa supporters would like for their money. No other club in the League can show such an “out” record as the Villa this season. Of their last nine games on foreign pastures they have won seven, drawing the other two, and scoring 28 goals to the 8 mustered by their opponents. Now sits expectation in the air, as Willy Shakespeare put it. The Stoke officials are making mighty preparations for a big battle next Saturday, and though the Victoria grounds isn’t the most swagger enclosure in footballdom it will hold a greater crowd than most people imagine. Both sides know that the struggle will be a grim and tenacious one. Neither will have anything to give away, and if ‘form’ goes for anything the Villa seventh semi-final ought to be one of the greatest in the club’s history.”

EVERTON F.C.
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 21 March 1905
TRAINING ARRANGEMENTS IN VIEW OF THE SEMI-FINAL
By Bee
The match of the season seems to be everyone’s designation of the fixture due at Stoke next Saturday, when Everton and Aston Villa cross swords in the last but one stage of the Cup competition. Pursuing the course of training which has proved so beneficial in former instances this season, the men went to the famous Northwich brine baths. There were the whole of the regular members of the first eleven, as well as the younger Balmer, Tom Booth, and Rankin, in charge of a director and Trainer Elliott, and they returned fresh and much benefited. This morning the governor’s orders were to go a walk out Sefton way, and also this afternoon. Sprints were gone through. Walks, ball punching, sprinting, and shot in are included in the preparatory list, and these are all very lightly dealt with after the strenuous work of Saturday against Sunderland. By the way, the team stayed over Saturday night at Harrogate, and arrived in Liverpool on Sunday afternoon. Against the Wearsiders the only player to be damaged was the hustler, Hardman. He was charged heavily, and is suffering from soreness. There is no anticipation that he will be unable to turn out against Aston Villa. Roose, ever enthusiastic, has made arrangements for an unusual thing. He is actually going to visit Brighton to get himself in fit condition, through really one always looks upon bis clearances as demonstrating that fit or unfit he is a marvellous man between the sticks. The officials and players are very reticent about talking of the match. “We are going to do out level best.” This is as far as they will go, and more they could not be expected to say.
The particulars of the most probable eleven are as follow;-

As for our opponents well, glance on page three and read what a former clubmate has been good enough to send me.
You see the value of a correspondent’s letter. He opens out a most interesting argument, and I will add the Villa comparison. On that memorable occasion in 1897, the Villa eleven was the best they ever had to represent them. Let us go in orthodox order, taking “goalie” first. In George better than Whitehouse? He has been, but at present the ex-soldier is almost as bulky as Hillman, and this putting on flesh has rather detracted from his former brilliance. Whitehouse could get to all shots smartly. Just tempt George with a grass shot of any strength and he is in a hole. Spencer and Evans are about the equal of the present backs. Miles I have watched since he was nineteen years old, and I predict international honours for him if he can keep up his present form. At half-back the present line cannot be compared with the trio of brilliants-John Reynolds, James Cowan, and James Crabtree. There has never been an intermediate line to equal these three. Pearson, Leake, and Windmill-the names fall very short. Leake has not the ability any one of them had, though his terrier tactics make up for a lack of the very finer points of play. Pearson and Windmill, the Saltney College youths are comparatively juniors and experience must be needy. Everton caught Reynolds, Cowan and Crabtree in the topmost point of their career; on Saturday they will come across two wing half-backs who should be mastered. On the right wing give me Brawn for Athersmith by all means. At inside the Villa are not now so excellent represented. Garratty is a rough diamond, the warhorse of the team. He goes for goal, and adds that dash which is needed to make up a line mainly composed of men of tricky play at small build. Devey was a master, and he played with his head. There was no rash movement. He took in the situation at one glance, relied on his co-players being in their proper positions, and drew the opposition towards him. Next he would send high across to the outside left- and, heigho! He worked all his ideas out in practice by himself. With imaginary opponents he spent many a pleasant half hour at practice. Garratty plies his wing man persistently-half back, please note. Hampton has come on apace. An old head like Campbell is to be preferred. You known Aston badly wanted a centre forward for a month and more, and once Hampton got in a few goals he was made a hero. The club had found a badly wanted gem, and how he was “cracked up” by the local Press! Hampton is good; Taylor will hold him quite readily in my opinion. Wheldon in his prime had as great a command over the ball as Bache, and in one essential matter he can be favourably compared with Bache; he shot like a demon, whereas if Bache has a weakness it is that he cannot trouble custodians unless he is under the bar. Generally speaking, I don’t know of a player whose marksmanship, I don’t know liable-save my own. Hall will be the outside left. He is a really clever footballer, and his strength is about on a par with the John Cowan of 1897. When one comes to quarter the team and compare divisions of the past with those of the present it brings forth the argument. “Are footballers improving their play?”-a big subject which we will talk about later on. However, I am firmly convinced -yes, surprisingly convinced, Aston Villa members for 1905 cannot hold the candle to these of 1897.

“Evertonians” writes;- “It is worth-while comparing the present Everton team to do battle against the Villa, with the Everton team which played in the final against them. The present team comes out very favourably-I don’t know the Villa of that day- I know they had a great player, Crabtree, so I fancy Everton’s chances very good. Roose as a goalkeeper is to be preferred to Menham. Storrier and Meehan as backs were of the heavy-weight order, but I think Balmer and Crelley more likely to come off against the Villa, as they have more speed and understand each other so well. I would pick Taylor before Holt as a centre half, good as Johnny was. Makepeace and Abbott are quite as good as Boyler and Stewart. Abbott plays more of a forward game than Stewart did and I never heard of Stewart getting a goal. Young before Hartley as a centre forward. Hartley did not like being bustled about, and it was often against his success, whereas Young fears no foe. There is not much difference in the wing men. It is a moot point whether Taylor and Bell were better than Sharp and McDermott. I know Bell was not a dribbler and was sooner knocked off the ball than McDermott, and often the latter’s tenacity leads to a goal. I might be surprising but I would pick Settle before Chadwick at inside left. Chadwick would never have got three goals like Settle did against Southampton as he is not so nippy. Hardman will bear comparison to Milward. He has one great advantage-he does not show the white feather like Milward often did. I would like your opinion of the team and also the team that did battle for the Villa in their final against Everton. I have shown that Everton have no need to fear the Villa. What say you?”

TOM BOOTH BEGINS TO FEEL SOUND AGAIN
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 22 March 1905
By Bee
A visit to Goodison yesterday brought forth the information that Tom Booth may possibly be seen out on the field of play before the season ends. This season has been a great disappointment to him and to all Everton supporters. Tom went a nice trot round the throw in line in most satisfactory manager, and it appears that the injury to his ankle which has been so stubborn is now healed, and he has stood various tests without its cracking again. While giving Balmer every credit for his captaincy, I always hold that a player in that capacity should be a half or forward. A back cannot on the field of play give him like a member of the intermediate or attacking division. So one welcomes the probable return of Booth, and his aid will be especially benefiting should one of the halves desire a rest during the heavy work of the next month. Settle was early on the scene, and he went his paces in characteristic style. He and the other three players who received benefits this season have received £327 6s, and the accounts have been closed. Lucky fellows, did you say? Never forget that a footballer must make hay while the sun shines and that his occupation is an extremely precarious one. I make bold to say that in a general way a steady footballer can keep up his form with the best till he is thirty-four. Yet how many do manage to last till that age?
Will Balmer was out and locking well. He is certain to line up against the Aston brigade. Hanlin came next in order. There is no player in the team can cover the ground so smartly as this member, though officials declare that S.B. Ashworth is the artiste of the whole lot in getting round the ground in double quick time. One would not have though so. John Sharp looked in perfect trim, and so did Taylor; and, in fact all the members were in excellent spirits, thanks to the endeavours of the trainer.
So great has been the rush for tickets that within six days of the match the whole of them had been snapped up. Yesterday an Everton official required one, and ‘phoned Mr. Austerberry, the Stoke secretary. “All gone,” was the reply. All classes of persons have purchased tickets form the bricklayer to the clerical enthusiast, and a party of Liverpool barristers have engaged a private dining saloon.

EVERTON’S OPPONENTS
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 22 March 1905
CHAT ON THE COMPOSITION OF ASTON VILLA
In view of the football tit-bit of Saturday next, I give feature and facts of Villa players. The team is likely to be constituted as last week, when the following men beat Sheffield United;-
INSERT JAMES

That George is a downright good goalkeeper will not be seriously disputed. At his best he is really brilliant; but like the great majority of players who scar above the crowd by sheer force of merit, he has a bad hour or so occasionally. His splendid height and reach, and his superb athletic frame, are advantage not possessed by every goalkeeper of repute. Most “keepers” shine to best of advantage when there is plenty of work to do, and in this respect George may be placed amongst the best of his contemporaries. One or two characteristics are especially his own. As a very capable cricketer, and more than ordinary smart in the field, he is a splendid judge of a catch, and it is quite exhilarating at times to note the ease with which he takes the half a few feet from the crossbar. Bringing it down with an easy swing of the arms, and feinting a clearance to the left, as the oncoming forwards dash in he makes a sudden turn, and sends the ball clear on his right. The rules of course, have put a stop to the goalkeeper running from goal with the ball in his possession. Another favourite resource of George’s is to spring like a flash out of harm’s way, and, once clear, to bound the ball on the turf until he has made for himself sufficient elbow-room to punch, throw; or punt the ball out of danger. He gave a marvellous exhibition of his skill upon the occasion of his first appearance in a Villa jersey at West Bromwich. The Albion shot for goal with the velocity of pompoms. From start to finish the balance of play was in favour of the Albion, but they met more than their match in George. The Villa had to go on the carpet over signing on their soldier-goalkeeper on a Sunday; but they won the game, gained two points, and introduced one of the most reliable goalkeepers and one of the best sportsmen in the country. George has an excellent hobby. He is an accomplished fretsaw worker, and has his house full of quaint articles of his own fashioning. As an exponent of the gentle art few men have won more general commendation than Howard Spencer. His first real step on to the ladder of fame came when he was selected to play against the Scottish Junior Internationals from which moment his progress has been a series of triumphs. Coming straight from a junior team into Aston Villa’s premier eleven, he justified all the confident predictions of those who had watched his youthful career, and of what service he has been to the club every connoisseur of the game knows. The old Albert-road boy belonged to the “good old gang,” who made the name and fame of Aston Villa household words. They won the League championship and the English Cup in one and the same year, and as long as the eleven were held together they were easily at the top of the tree. In 1897- the year of the Diamond Jubilee-the Villa repeated their 1887 performance by carrying off the English Cup. In 1897 Spencer won international honours against Scotland and Wales, and three seasons later a second Welsh cap was bestowed upon him. Spencer has even been famed for the cleanness of his methods, and his lovable manliness on and off the field alike.
Miles is quite a youngster. He played with St. Mary’s. a local team, helped the club to top the Birmingham Old Boys’ Association League, a league which I had the honour to practically inaugurate, and which now governs eleven leagues and some 6,000 players. Miles was watched by the Villa and for them he has ever been improving. He is fast, obtaining the finer touches which his partner is renowned for.
Pearson is a local man, is still at colleague, and is always a trier. Not an over-brilliant exponent of the game.
Leake is a humorous fellow, and happy when gaming. He actually made Steve Bloomer laugh at Glasgow! A feat to be proud of. For many years he captained Small Heath. He quickly fell into the style of Villa play. Like Abbott, his old clubmate, he is a capital tackler, and puts in an occasional pot shot which troubles the goalkeeper considerably. He has been chosen for international honours despite his thirty-four years. A general utility man, he can play in almost any position. Windmill is also at college. He has a fine turn of speed, and improves every season. His only League appearance in 1903 was against Newcastle.
Brawn is a tall winger, who earned a regular place in the League forces in January, 1903 after having served Sheffield United three years. His centres are reliable, and he has a great idea of the best manner to “middle.”
Garraty is not a “star” in the generally accepted sense of the word. Garraty is more of a go-ahead worker (or “grafter”) and when he goes on the field it is to do his level best in a legitimate, whole-souled manner- to win if possible to accept defeat gracefully if beaten. A Birmingham “boy” (he was born at Saltney), he was only eighteen when he first donned the claret and blue of the Aston combination. Strangely enough, Garraty first came into prominence in local football while playing on the very piece of ground now occupied by the Villa, but when Lozells leased the turf there was little in the way of stand accommodation, and the place had not been transformed into the splendid amphitheatre known to all and sundry of the football world. From the Lozells team he went straight into the Villa and it can safely be said that the directors have never once regretted their choice. By common consent he is one of the most genuine triers the Villa have ever possessed, and, though he has had “off” days like the rest, these are few and far between.
Hampton has dropped from the clouds. He was transferred by Wellingborough, and this is his first season. Villa could get no one for many weeks to take up Johnson’s place. They came across Hampton and, within a month, he had been christened “the friend of goalkeepers.” He bundies into them right sturdily, and has proved he was a missing link of the Villa’s front chair.

FOOTBALL ITEMS
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 23 March 1905
Tom Booth may possibly be seen out on the field of play before the season ends. So great has been the rush for tickets that within six days of the match at Stoke the whole of them had been snapped up. On Tuesday an Everton official required one, and ‘phoned Mr. Austerberry, the Stoke secretary. “All gone,” was the reply. All classes of persons have purchased tickets from the bricklayer to the clerical enthusiast, and a party of Liverpool barristers have engaged a private dinning saloon. The training operations of the Villa team at Rhyl are progressing quietly but very satisfactorily. The men are in splendid condition.

ENGLISH CUP SEMI-FINALS
Liverpool Evening Express - Thursday 23 March 1905
EVERTON’S HOME TRAINING
PLAYERS CONFIDENT.
In football circles in Liverpool intense interest is being taken in the semi-final tie between Everton and Aston Villa, which will be fought on the ground of the Stoke Club next Saturday. In the whole history of the National competition, memorable as it is, there has probably been no such marvellous final from the point of view of scientific football ‘as that in which Everton and Aston Villa participated at the Crystal Palace some years ago. On that occasion Everton were beaten by three goals to two. This season the fortune of the draw has rendered it absolutely impossible for these two great rivals to meet in the final encounter. Thus one of the semi-finals, so far as followers of the game in and around Liverpool and in the Midlands ale concerned, is invested with exceptional interest. To put the matter plainly, all who have any knowledge of the game recognise that the winner of the tie mentioned will doubtless figure triumphantly at the Crystal Palace next month. In reviewing generally the two semi-finals, it is recognised that no FOUR CLUBS OF SUCH GREAT IMPORTANCE as those which will be participants in Saturday’s games have ever before been brought together. It is often stated that the association code is declining in popular approval. We make bold to state that the attendances registered at Stoke and Hyde-road will create a record, even though the accommodation may not be of the best.  Stoke itself, although central, is not quite so accessible as one could wish. That is to say, the resources of the North Staffordshire line are distinctly limited. On Saturday it will be the converging point of thousands of enthusiasts from both Liverpool and Birmingham. At least thirty trains will run into the Pottery capital, and without derogating from local enterprise, it is reasonably questionable whether the vast army of invaders will find sufficient food to satisfy even the most modest demands of the football enthusiast. We are assured that the railway companies concerned are making the best arrangements possible, and the congestion is likely to be dealt with in a businesslike way. For the first time in the history of the Everton Club special training at a seaside resort has been discarded. During the season Everton have gone in for what is known as HOME TRAINING. That is to say, they have had the ordinary course of training at the ground, combined with visits to the Northwich brine baths and excursions into the country. The effects have not been at all bad so far as playing results are concerned, and with the men all happy and contented it is not at all surprising that the directors have not sent the men away to the seaside. Aston Villa, as is generally known, have been indulging in the breezes of Rhyl—that is, their players have been staying at the popular Welsh resort, and be it hoped, with benefit to themselves. The Everton men, on the other hand, have stayed at home. Apart from the brine baths already mentioned, they have followed a course of home training, which, in the words of Mr. Secretary Cuff, has been “very satisfactory up to date.” Let us briefly mention what the daily programme comprises. Take, for instance, last Tuesday. Then they had a short walk in the morning, followed by sprinting on the ground and punch ball in the gymnasium in the afternoon. Yesterday they walked from Aintree to Sefton, where they spent a pleasant afternoon, having lunch and tea at the famous Punch Bowl. Jack Elliott, the trainer, knows what is what in the matter of training, and if all the players are not fit next Saturday it will not be his fault. A visit to the players yesterday found them all in the best possible condition. W. Balmer has quite recovered from his muscular ‘strain, and the plucky amateur, H. P. Hardman, is himself again. In case of accidents, R. Balmer, McLoughlin, Rankin, and Tom Booth are all immersed in the training process, but it is very questionable, although the FINAL SELECTION OF THE TEAM will not be made until Friday afternoon, whether any change will be made from the ordinary team. However, much will depend upon what may happen between now and Saturday morning. To-day the players will indulge in their usual training at home; tomorrow they will have a walk in the direction of Hoylake, spending the evening at the Empire Theatre, and on Saturday morning they will travel to Stoke by the noon express from Lime-street Station, having lunch in the train en route. Naturally the players themselves have very little to say about the forthcoming semi-final except this, that they mean to do their very best to win. They have hopes, of course, but it is a habit of football players not to express themselves with any fervour. At the same time they mean to do all in their power to win, and thus obviate the necessity of a re-play on Nottingham Forest’s ground next Wednesday. Admittedly the Everton team of to-day in two or three respects is stronger than that which fell at the Crystal Palace in 1897 by three goals to two, after really the finest final which the English Cup competition has ever produced. Menham was never a Roose in goal, and moreover the backs of that day—Meecham and Storrier—can hardly be compared with W. Balmer and Crelly. Mr. W. C. Cuff, the Everton secretary, may be allowed to say a word for himself. To our representative yesterday he did not disguise the importance of the struggle with Aston Villa. “We recognise,” he said, “that we have A VERY HARD STRUGGLE, but we are not without great hopes of appearing in the final. The Villa play a similar game to ourselves, and you may take it from me that the game will be one of the most scientific and interesting, supposing weather permits, in the history of the game.” Asked as to whether the present Everton team was superior to that which fought out the most famous of all finals with the Villa, My. Cuff unreservedly replied in the affirmative. “Yes,” he said; “our men are all fit. They mean to establish, if possible, a record for the Everton Football Club. By that I mean their ambition is to win not only the League championship, but the English Cup and the Lancashire Cup.”  “Do you think that is possible?” queried our representative. To this Mr. Cuff quietly responded by saying, “Everything is possible with our splendid lot of players. Their heart is in the game, and they mean to do great things.” We will all subscribe to the Everton secretary’s wish. After all, the first hurdle to be got over is that of Aston Villa at Stoke, A little extra luck may turn the issue one way or the other, but if Everton lose the day it will be through no want of trying. They are going all the way, and that means a lot, even in a cup semi-final.

ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
Staffordshire Sentinel - Thursday 23 March 1905
Preparations for the semi-final
HOW TO SEE THE MATCH.
The extensive arrangements which have been made in readiness for the important semi-final at Stoke on Saturday are well-nigh complete, and by to-morrow -everything will have been prepared for the accommodation of the large crowd which is expected. The ground this morning was in excellent condition, having been thoroughly well rolled during the early part of the week, and will how require no more attention. The slight breezes which are prevalent will do much to render the state of the turf even more favourable for play of the first order. If rain does not fall heavily before Saturday the playing pitch will be almost perfect and like a carpet.  
During the week several small improvements have been made in the spectatorial portion of the enclosure. For instance, at one end of the big stand the upper portion of the end wall has been removed and thrown open so as to provide a clear view of details of the play near the Stoke end of the field. At the other extremity of the stand some boarding has been removed, with the result that holders of tickets for seats near the directors' pavilion will be able to see practically the whole of the play on the goal line nearest this point. A number of new crush barriers have been placed on the embankment provided for sixpenny patrons, and the track seats in front of the big stand remain as they have done since the Stoke v. Everton Cup-tie. For the convenience of those using the Boothen end of the ground four new turnstiles have been placed, making eight in all. The paddock fronting the Butler-street stand will be reached by means of turnstiles, where the admission fee charged will be 1s. 6d. Those desiring to witness the game from the new stand itself will proceed thither on payment of a further fee of 1s., and turnstiles will be fixed at the foot of the gangway leading to the stand. Spectators who wish to view the game from the paddock which fronts the Boothen-road stand will obtain their tickets from pay boxes on the way to the stand, and will enter by door "B." Holders of 5s. tickets will gain admittance only by the doors mentioned on their tickets. It is unnecessary, perhaps, to mention how greatly the improvement in the widening of the corner of Glebe street and Church-street will facilitate the progress of the crowd to and from the ground. This alteration is one which is sure to be greatly appreciated. Spectators of the Villa v. Everton match will be able to know at any moment how affairs stand between the other semi-finalists at Manchester, for the Victoria grounds will be in constant telephonic communication with City-road, and almost immediately after a goal is scored by either Newcastle or Sheffield Wednesday it will be announced on the telegraph board.

RANGERS PLAYER AS CLUB MANAGER. APPOINTMENT TO J. T. ROBERTSON.
Dundee Courier - Friday 24 March 1905
We understand (says the Daily Chronicle) that the famous Scottish International half-back- Jack Robertson, who was born Dumbarton in 1877, has been appointed manager of the new club at Stamford Bridge, now described Chelsea F.C. Robertson gained his first cap when member of 'he Everton team. Subsequently he joined Southampton, and for the Southerners often turned out at out/side left forward. Robertson then returned to Scotland, and has almost regularly appeared in Rangers and in International football, often as captain. He played against England in 1808, 1899, 1900 1901 1903, and 1904. '

CUP CONTESTANTS
Liverpool Daily Post - Friday 24 March 1905
ASTON VILLA
The Aston Villa team have been preparing for their cup tie with Everton at Rhyl Hydro, their favourite out-training quarters. They journeyed there after defeating Sheffield United on Saturday, and will not return to Birmingham till Saturday night. The players are reported to be in fine condition. No severe regime has been imposed. Walking exercise, sprinting and swimming have been the order, strenuous gymnastics being avoided. The eleven will not be finally chosen till Saturday, but the probability is that the players who vanquished Bury and Fulham will take the field. Spencer, the captain was seen to be limping after last Saturday’s match, and there were misgivings as to the return of the trouble which kept him out of team through the middle of the season. He is apparently all right, however, though the directors have taken the precautions of sending Brown, his understudy to Phyl. Wilkes, the old international half, is also training as reserve. The probable team is;- George, goal; Spencer, Miles, backs; Pearson, Leake, and Windmill, half-backs; Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards. The men are full of buoyancy and confidence. They will travel to Stoke on Saturday morning.
FOOTBALL ITEMS
Yesterday’s training of the Everton footballers in view of the stern cup-tie tomorrow was gone through on the Goodison ground, and to-morrow the players go to Hoylake and in the evening visit one of the theatres. “All well” is the latest report concerning them.
Settle has been chosen first reserve for the International match at Anfield, on Monday between England and Wales so there is a possibility, though not a probability of the Everton left wing pair appearing in the forward line of the English team.

CUP TIE SEMI-FINAL
Liverpool Echo - Friday 24 March 1905
THE ROOSE RUMOURS TERMED “ALL NONSENSE.”
TEAMS AND THEIR DOINGS
By Bee
Tomorrow the semi-final round of the English Cup competition will be got through, and Aston Villa and Everton, at Stoke, and Newcastle United and Sheffield Wednesday, at Manchester, will meet to decide which two clubs shall at Crystal Palace, on April 15, fight the final battle for possession of the Cup for another twelve months. To-morrow’s encounters are exciting the utmost interest among the partisans of the four clubs, who recognise that, as the matches are to be played on neutral grounds, the antagonists are very evenly matched; and it may be taken for granted that, given weather, the holding capacity of the Stoke and Manchester City grounds will be thoroughly tested. Quite unusual interest is being taken in Liverpool in the tie between Everton and Villa and the feeling is that Everton have a great chance of winning the Cup, the players being just now at the top of their form. The Everton directors have selected the following team;
L.R. Roose, goal; W. Balmer and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
A rumour has been circulated concerning Roose which, until it is squelched, will cause much uneasiness among the supporters of the Blue jersey. It is Roose, the amateur goalkeeper, was unwell, and was totally unable to play. Then the alarmist added a spicy note, that McDermott, too, would be unable to take his place in the team. Apparently, as the tale was told to various persons its veracity was lessened. An Everton official replies to a query about the matter that it is “all nonsense.”
We rest contented now,
The players went to the Empire Theatre last night. They leave Lime-street by twelve o’clock train, dine en route, arriving at the Potteries at two o’clock. The return journey is made by the 6.50 train, reaching Lime street at 8.30. should Everton win they can be assured of an outburst of enthusiasm far in excess of the last occasion when they went to Stoke in the Cup tie. Personally, I rather lean to both the games being drawn at the first time of asking. Of course, I give Everton to win, and found my selection on form and fancy. There is no stopping them their year, and I hope to see them contesting with and beating Sheffield Wednesday in the final. On page 3 will be found sketches of the Everton players.
Aston Villa have been preparing at a Rhyl hydro, their favourite out training quarters. They went there after defeating Sheffield United on Saturday, and will not return to Birmingham until tomorrow night. The players who will travel to Stoke are reported to be in fine condition, and full of confidence. Walking exercise, sprinting and swimming have been the order, strenuous gymnastics being avoided. The eleven will not be finally chosen till tomorrow, but the probability is that the players who vanquished Bury and Fulham will take the field. Spencer was seen to be limping after last Saturday’s League match, and there were misgivings as to a return of the trouble which kept out of the team about the middle of the season. He is apparently all right, however, though the directors have taken the precautions of sending Brown, his understudy, to Rhyl. Wilkes is also training as reserve.
Probably team is;-
George, goal; Spencer and Miles, backs; Pearson, Leake, and Windmill, half-backs; Brawn, Garraty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards.
A FEW HINTS
The bulk of the 5s tickets were sold to Evertonians, and it seems a probability that the Goodison Park brigade will outnumber the Villa followers. To those people visiting Stoke the following hints will be useful;-
Th Great Central trains leave Central at 12.20 Garston 12.30, Stockport 1.15.
The gentlemen who are to fill the five dining cars arranged by Bullock and Co, should be at Central at 12.5. these passengers arrive at 2.25, and return at 7 o’clock.
The London and North-Western line run a day trip (Lime street 10.5, Edge-hill 1010), and half-day trips at 11.30, 12.10, 12.45, arriving at Stoke at 1.25, 1.45. 2.20 respectively.
Passengers return same day by 5.55, 6.20, or 6.50 trains from goods yard or 10.50 from the passenger station. The walk to Victoria ground taken four minutes. What is the direction? Why, follow the crowd. If you are meeting a friend from another town arrange to meet him at the monument just outside the station. Don’t take your watch; you will thus avoid “lost time.” Stoke has not an abundance of good refreshment houses. Be warned in time that a parcel made up in Liverpool will be very acceptable towards half-past five. Make your way straight to the ground. There is a possibility of gates being closed early on. Don’t forget to cheer the Villa and Don’t forget the Everton “whisper” when the Blues turn out.

NELSON 1 EVERTON RESERVES 0
March 25, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire Combination “A” Division (Game 28)
Everton continue to do badly, and further points were dropped at Nelson. The team was not at full strength, but at the same time better results should be forthcoming than has been the case of late. Nelson although holding an advantage nearly all through could only score once, and that in the second half, a fact which was the to the good defence of the visitors. Everton: - Kitchen goal, Wildman, and Kerr, backs, Hanlin, Chadwick, and Hutchinson, half-backs, Roberts, Caldwell, Thornburn, Dilly, and Evans, forwards.

ENGLISH CUP TIES
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 25 March 1905
VIEWS OF SOME CONQUERED CAPTAINS
In answer to two questions- “Who do you think will win the Cup tie at “Stoke?” “Why?” -|Raisbeck, the Liverpool captain, telegraphs;-
  “Fancy Villa to win, as they are the better cup team.”
 Holford captain of the Stoke Club (defeated in the second round by Everton by 4-0) wires;-
“Villa are the better team. Their defence is steadier, and the forwards combine better. The Villa should win.”
Ross captain of Bury, whom Villa beat by 3-0 says he is undecided as to who will win. “The teams are almost equal,” his telegram reads; “but I have a slight leaning for Everton.”
The Everton directors have selected the following team;- L.R. Roose, goal; W. Balmer, and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
A rumour has been circulated concerning Roose which, until it is squelched , will cause much uneasiness among the supporters of the Blue jersey. It is Roose the amateur goalkeeper, was unwell, and was totally unable to play. Then the alarmist added a spicy note, that McDermott, too, would be unable to take his place in the team.  Apparently as the tale was told to various persons its veracity was lessened. An Everton official replies to a query about the matter that it is “all nonsense,”
Referee at Stoke. Referee Mr. Kingscott (Derby), Linesmen Messrs H.E Walker (Reading) and F.H Dennis (Middlesbrough).
Nelson v Everton Reserve
Exchange Station 12.45; kick-off 3.30
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Wildman and Kerr, backs; Hanlin, Chadwick and Hutchinson, half-backs; Roberts, Caldwell, Thorburn, Dilly, and Evans, forwards.

ENGLISH CUP
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 25 March 1905
SEMI-FINAL TIE
EVERTON v  ASTON VILLA
A BIG “GATE”
BEFORE THE START
Keen anticipation gave way this morning to realisation when the date fixed for the meeting of Everton and Aston Villa in the semi-final of the English Cup duly arrived. Statistics, partisanships, and analytical comparisons have in the past proved so many times to be delusive and unreliable when applied to Cup ties that the issue of the present momentous contest could not fail to be in the highest degree speculative and uncertain, and for this reason particularly brimful of interest. Such reasoning, however, did not prevent the supporters of the teams, even at the last moment, summing up the chances of either side. The Villa’s partisans proudly proclaimed this their seventh semi-final; but Evertonians were not ashamed of their fourth. Eight successive victories constitute the Villa’s latest record, and they brought 26 goals against 6. But Evertonians did not overlook the fact that 10 of those goals were scored against Leicester Fosse and Fulham. Including the Bury match the Villians scored in their cup ties 13 goals to 3. Everton against Liverpool, Stoke, and Southampton -much more doughty opponents-scored 10 goals to 1, so that Everton’s record was distinctly a more meritorious one. Still the Villians have done all that was asked of them, and they have a truly brilliant sequence of sixteen matches played with only one defeat, and that by “Wicked Wednesday,” who have this season eased the Villans of four points. Another point in Everton’s favour was that a scrutiny of previous records of games played at Stoke by them and the Villa disclosed an average distinctly favourable to the Blues. Few of the spectators probably recollected that of the two elevens who fought out the final in ’97 only Taylor represents Everton and Spencer the Villa. Rhyl was selected by Aston Villa for training purposes, but the Toffees of late have found local atmospheres sufficient to maintain their splendid condition, and have not gone far afield in search of invigorating influences. Some of the very highest authorities have publicity expressed the opinion that the circumstances under which Everton and the Villa meet ball-mark the match as the finest semi-final we have had for many years. The splendid record of both clubs, and the fact that they both play the game in its most scientific form, coupled with the potential charcater of the issue, clothes the encounter with such all-absorbing interest as could hardly be exceeded. The railway companies recognised fully the demands of the public, and no less than sixty six excursions were arranged, which would enable something like 30,000 outsiders to swell the ranks of the potmakers at Victoria ground.
THE PLAYERS
The following short biographical sketch of the players may interest our readers;-
EVERTON
Roose.- One of the finest goalkeepers ever seen on a football field. Cool and determined, he is the only goalkeeper for Wales. A fearless custodian, and as active as a cat.
Balmer (W.)- A cool, determined right back. He kicks well, and is a rare tackler. Players a good game recently for the English League against the Scottish League.
Crelly.- A Liverpool lad, and a vastly improved back. Not very showy, but always reliable and at his best brilliant.
Makepeace.- An energetic half, who only got his chance this season. One of the surprises of the season for Everton, and one of the best half backs in the country. The penalty kick artiste of the team, he has only missed one penalty this season.
Taylor.- The old warhorse of the team. A rare, hard worker and a great favourite. He is playing at present in the centre half back position as well as he ever played in his life.
Abbott.- Always a worker, he has all along been one of the mainstays of the Everton defence. Can worry the forwards beautifully, and always shoots for goal with some purpose.
Sharp.- On his day Jack Sharp is the finest outside right in England. He plays not only with his feet, but with his head, and has a happy knack of rising to great occasions. Plucky and tricky, he is a most useful member of the side.
McDermott.- One of the trickiest forwards playing football, and can do almost anything with the ball. He is a trifle slow, but what is lacking here is made up with actual cleverness.
Young.- Occasionally disappointing in his centre work, but when he is in the humour he makes one of the best pivots.
Settle.- The old international is playing as well as ever he did, and the Everton front line would be just without him.
Hardman.- This player is about as plucky a little forward as ever stepped off to a football field. Very speedy, but owes a not to his partner, Settle.
ASTON VILLA
George.- A sturdy custodian who show in his fine physique his Army training. Stands well over most forwards and is famous for mighty punches and tremendous goal kicks. Always cool and good tempered, and as popular off the field as on.
Spencer.- One of the sweetest-tempered and most polished backs of the day. Not quite so fast as he was a year or two back, but still well worth his place. A superb tackler. The Villa team would sadly miss him.
Miles.- A dashing back, lacking experience as yet, but shaping as though he would make a first-class man. His style is something like that of his predecessor, Evans. The vigour of both men contrasts strongly with these quiet methods of Spencer.
Pearson.-A school-master engaged at Saltney College and comparatively new to League football. Has plenty of dash, and does not hesitate to use his weight, is a fairly good shot.
Leake.- The former Small Heath skipper has made many friends at the Lower Grounds, and is playing sterling football just now. He can capably fill any position in the intermediate line, and is a third back and a sixth forward. His unbounded enthusiasm is very popular with the other members of the team, and prays on to the end, whatever the state of the score.
Windmill.- A Saltney College man, who has shown remarkable improvement this season. One of the brick, bustling sort, whom forwards find it difficult to get past. Has not quite the style of a Crabtree, but is coming on by leaps and bounds.
Brawn.- This speedy outside right came from Sheffield United, and has done the Villa good service. He has a tremendous stride, and after beating the back can centre squarely across the goalmouth with a facility which few outside men can equal.
Garratty.- One of the most experienced of the front rank, and though not so fast as he once was, is still a valuable member of the team. Is always cool in front of goal, and often succeeds with a shot where a fussy man would fail.
Hampton.- A dashing centre who revealed his merit in Birmingham League matches. His introduction to the team has made a wonderful difference to the attack. Never hesitation to go for goal, and is not much beloved by goalkeepers whom he is apt to treat with scant courtesy.
Bache.- Regarded as one of the cleverest inside lefts playing football to-day. Is fast and tricky, and can shoot with remarkable accuracy. Went unaccountably off form last season, but never played better than at present and on recent form his many friends deemed him a certainly for international honours.
Hall. A recruit from Stourbridge, tried on the left wing as an experiment, and making such an excellent partner for Bache that he has never been displaced. He is fast and clever, and knows where the goal lies.
THE GAME
DEFENCE BEATS ATTACK
THE NET NOT FOUND UP TO HALF-TIME
The scene at Lime-Street Station was one to be remembered, and almost every carriage carried an extra complement. The Liverpudlians made Stoke ring with the Everton “war cry.” At Stoke Everton were good favourites, the local betting being 6 to 4 on. The Stoke ground is supposed to hold 65,000. The prices charged for admission were 5s, 2s 6d, 1s 6d, and 6d. Mr. A Kingscott officiated as referee. At three o’clock there were 35,000 present. There was neither wind nor rain when Hampson led off, the ground apparently being in good condition and the crowd perhaps over 40,000. Hampton passed back to Leake, and he kicked out. McDermott was next in position, and Everton pressed on the right for a bit, and then crossed to the other wing, where pretty work came from Settle and Hardman, but the Villa half-back tactics soon put the ball out again. Brawn looked like getting away smartly, when he was cleverly intercepted by Crelley, but Balmer had to respond immediately to a very close attack to the Villa left. Sharp slipped Windmill very cleverly, and Pearson had to dash across and kick out to check the cricketer. The Villa soon dashed off again, and Crelly had to concede a corner, which was negotiated, but good work by the Villa forwards provided an opportunity for Hall to sky the leather well over Roose’s citadel. Hampton came away with great dash Brown in recovering was distinctly offside. So far the Villa had the best of matters, and there was more sting in the attack. After Roose had handled from Hampton, Balmer was also rather pressed, but cleared at close quarters from Bache. Roose next made a long rush out of goal to save, and soon after Taylor conceded a second corner to the Villa, which was dealt with skilfully, so far the Blues had not got the measure of the Villians. Bad misses by both Taylor and Abbott let the Brums in again, and a pass across from Hall to Brawn nearly brought disaster until Crelly chipped in cleverly. Good work by Young enabled the Blues to attack, but Sharp was offside at the finish. Crelly next provided Settle with a good opening, but Miles stepped in smartly, and McDermott was disappointed. The Villa front line was again at work, and a capital pass by Brawn to Bache resulted in that worthy attempting the downfall of Roose, but he shot too high. Good work in the Everton centre led up to possession by Hardman, but when Abbott attempted to improve matters for his side he put the ball too far forward. Exchanges in midfield were hotly contested, and Young, in attempting to trip Garratty, was penalised, Taylor and Settle attempted to make a move, but Leake opened out for the Villa and Crelly had once more to stave off an incursion by Brawn. Balmer put Settle in possession with a well-timed pass, and he parted to Hardman, who was, however, very cleverly robbed by Leake and by his efforts hot attacks came from Bache and Hampton, Roose saving grandly from a splendid shot by the latter. The Everton centre and right now came away in their best form, and had the opposing half-backs well beaten when most unfortunately Sharp got offside. Everton stuck to their guns, and a really beautiful shot from Sharp forced the first corner for the Blues. From this Makepeace headed in, and the pressure on George’s charge was tremendous. But eventually Leake got the leather away, much to the relief of the Villa supporters. This was the best bit of work which had yet come from the Evertonians. Immediately after the Villans missed their opportunity, as Balmer quite failed to stay the advance of Hampton, and the Villa centre had only Roose to beat, and a score seemed imminent, but in the most unaccountable fashion Hampton struck the upright and the ball rebounded, Everton being saved once more. Roose had to respond to a great shot from Hampton, who went head and heels over into the net with the impetus. Everton now made a promising rush, and the ball was planted in front of George by Hardman. The custodian kicked out, Taylor recovered and returned the leather by a grand straight drive, George only saving on his knees. The Blues were now getting to work in fine style, and Sharp forced a couple of corners, during the negotiation of which George had a most anxious time. Sharp next beat Windmill cleverly, but the followed it up with a faulty pass to Leake, who was in turn successfully tackled by Taylor, and the ball was carried over the goal line by Everton’s right. McDermott next initiated a capital opening, and Settle put Young in possession, but the Everton centre refused to finesse, and attempted to find the net with a very feeble effort. Hardman was next away, and had a grand try, but Young in taking his pass kicked on to George, next followed a grand combined movement between Sharp, McDermott, and Hardman, but it wound up by the left winger heading over. Everton had so far been most unfortunate in not turning their opening to account, though by that time they seemed to have the measure of the Villans. At this point Hardman racked his shoulder, and a foul against Leake brought the Blues in once more, and they continued a fruitless attack, which had lasted fully ten minutes. Grand footwork by Hardman brought about a capital opening for Settle, who tested George with a beauty but he saved in splendid style. Just before the interval there was a cessation of hostilities owing to Leake getting in Taylor’s and being knocked out. When they once more set to work Young got in a particularly clever shot, which once more George saved on his knees. Immediately afterwards Young was deliberately bowled over in the penalty area, but Mr. Kingscott ignored this most palpable breach altogether.
Half-Time Score;- Everton nil, Aston Villa nil
HALL GIVES THE VILLA THE LEAD
A GRAND GAME
BOTH SIDES FIGHT HARD
SHARP EQUALISES
In the opening stages the Villans were seen to most advantage, but during the last twenty minutes preceding the interval the Blues pulled themselves together famously, and George was lucky to escape defeat, though it must be admitted that Roose had a wonderful escape from Hall.
SECOND HALF.
Re-starting, the Villa sailed away on their right, and a grand cross from Brawn to Hall led to Balmer conceding a corner, which brought severe pressure on Roose; but luckily for the Blues Brawn finally headed over. The encounter was continued in Everton territory and pretty work by Hampton, Bache, and Hall, led to Roose rushing out and clearing from the Villa centre. An advance by the Everton left was checked by Spencer, and then a foul against Settle brought a finely judged shot from Myles, which Roose disposed of. Brown sent in, and Roose made a run out and saved from Hampton. This was followed by some fine sharp shooting from the Villans, and Everton defence was severely tested. Sharp was the first to enable his side to emerge, but he was checked on the line by Miles. Brown got away pretty well by himself, but he contented himself with a long shot, which was wide and high. A bad miss by Taylor let the Villa front line in force, and Roose saved splendidly from a glorious shot by Brown. Roose conceded a corner, and Brown planting the leather accurately the Evertonians had the mortification of seeing the ball headed past Roose after ten minutes replay. The reserve stimulated the Blues, and their front worked well up to George, who was tested by Settle, and Hardman getting the return just missed the equaliser by inches. Excellent work came from Settle, McDermott, and Young, and they completely outplayed the Villa halves, “Sandy” winding up this move with a perfect shot, which George judged to a nicety. Young next missed a nice pass from Makepeace and Taylor was also at fault. Sharp and Young made gallant efforts, but the Villa warden never made a mistake with dealing with Young’s curling shot. A miskick by Balmer and Crelly gave the Villans another rare chance, but they crossed and recrossed too much, and lost ground. Makepeace fell several times, and Abbott made several feeble efforts, so that any chance of the Blues retiring victorious seemed gradually fading away a quarter of an hour from the finish Sharp had an open goal but after he had mis-kicked, Young made a very much worse effort to equalise, the Blues continued to make strenuous efforts, but they had vile luck with some well-judged shots. Five minutes later the Villa forced a couple of corners.
Final Result; Everton 1 goal, Aston Villa 1 goal.
POINTS OF THE PLAY
By F.E.H
This morning, Stoke awoke to find itself famous. It was the converging point of thousands Liverpool and Birmingham vied with each other in despatching their big battalions to the Pottery centre. The spirit of mimic warfare was in the air, and “abrums and excursions” were contributed by the railway companies. At two o’clock the sleepy streets of stolid, stodgy Stoke seethed with humanity. Never was seen such a surging, struggling spectacle. And yet I think old Omar must have had the English Cup in his mind’s eye when he, nearly, wrote’-
  And, strange to tell, among the Football lot
Some could articulate, while others not;
And suddenly one more impatient cried,
Who is the Potter, pray, and what’s the Pot?
The congestion in the vicinity of the ground was quite appalling, but all sections of the great crowd were in the best of temper, and they jostled each other with elephantine playfulness. Both the Liverpolitans and the boys from “Brum” were confident of success, and the Midlanders were slightly the favourites. At three o’clock the ground was completely filled, and the time of waiting was agreeably passed by many occupants of the popular enclosure throwing oranges at each other- a form of practical joking more honoured in the breach than in the observance.
At 3.20 the Villa captain led his men into the arena and mighty fit and well they looked. The cheer that greeted them had scarcely died away ere Balmer and his comrades, resplendent in new jerseys with nice white collars, made their appearance. Mr. Kingscott followed, and after Balmer and Howard Spencer had shaken hands, the fateful coin was spun. The Everton captain won the toss, and we all looked to this as a happy augury. The first exchanges fully bore this out for the Evertonians at once attacked , and both the full backs were called upon to clear. Then the Midlanders got going, and Brown forced a corner; tremendous excitement in consequence; but Balmer eventually cleared. The Villa persisted and from a fine centre by Brown, Hall shot high over the ball. The claret and blue jerseys were now pressing in grand style, and twice Roose rushed out to save his lines. McDermott and Settle tried to force the pace, but the Villa half-back line was wholly admirable. Leake allowed nothing to escape him and soon the Villans were again operating in front of Roose. Brown’s centre commanded the applause even of the Everton supporters and from one of these Bache ought to have scored, but sent over the bar. Play was confined to midfield for some time, but the Villa gradually made ground, and Bache headed in neatly, but Roose was on the alert, and threw away. The next item of interest was a swift ground shot from Hall, but it passed wide of the mark, and Everton took up the running in fine style. Sharp flashed down the wing and finished with a lovely shot, which George fisted clear. A corner resulted, and from this Makepeace headed in, but the watchful George just put the leather over. A second corner was easily cleared, and Hampton working through his field beat Balmer and shot with terrific force,  but to the delight of the Evertonians he struck the post, a very lucky escape. There was now no mistaking the Villans determination and once the referee had to speak to Balmer for the way in which he checked the left wing. At length Everton got a look in, and Taylor put in a shot which brought George to his knees. This was followed with a couple of corners from the second of which Abbott headed over. Wonderfully pretty footwork on the part of the Evertonians promised well, but Young’s final shot was very tame, and caused anxiety. Hardman thereupon tried to get through, but Spencer hampered him and the ball going to Young he put in a clinking shot which George only cleared at full length. As the interval drew nigh Everton exerted tremendous pressure and Hardman, Young, and Settle all had shots which failed to find the net. Returning to the attack, Settle put in a magnificent effort, but George was all there, and then Sharp spoiled the movement by sending the leather on to the roof of the stand. More spirited work in midfield, and then the game was stopped for a time by Leake being hurt. He and Taylor came into collision and the Midlander was injured on the head. Play being resumed, Everton pressed and Windmill ought to have been positioned within the area but Mr. Kingscott was looking another way at the moment. A few seconds later half time arrived, and the teams left the battlefield without either side having scored. On the whole the forty-five minutes had been admirably contested. That great crowd had full value for its money, the play being so fast that it was really difficult to say which was the better side. During the interval rain began to fall, but this is no way daunted the spirits of the mighty gathering. They cheered with renewed enthusiasm when the players reappeared. Villa at once went at it hammer and tongs and the Everton defence was quite “held up” Taylor, however, relieved the pressure momentarily, and the Blues were prominent for a little while. But the Villians were not to be denied. They swooped down on the Everton goal and Roose saved from Brawn at the expense of a corner. This led to the downfall of the Goodison Park brigade, for from a judiciously placed kick Hall headed into the net, right out of the custodian’s reach. Great jubilation in the ranks of the Birmingham supporters, hats in the air rattles going, whistles blowing and general pandemonium. Corresponding depression in the bosom of the Evertonians. Nevertheless they played up manfully and put in shots which caused George to exert himself. The fortunes of war however seemed to be against the men from the banks of the Mersey, for try as they would they could not pierce the Everton defence. Sharp and Young both put in great shots, but the gigantic George was ubiquitous and the way he saved from the Everton centre was marvellous. As the game progressed the excitement intensified and several players on both sides appeared to lose their heads, because there was much loose kicking and many errors of judgment. Fifteen minutes from the finish Everton made a terrific spurt. Sharp raced right through and after being knocked off the ball by George the leather went to Young, who had an open goal before him, but he shot skywards. All this time rain was falling steadily, but the semi-drenched spectators took no notice. Nothing short of an earthquake or an avalanche would have distracted their attention. The game had still six minutes to run when Sharp got through and scored the equaliser for Everton.
THE GATE
There were about 40,000 spectators present, and it is estimated the receipts will reach £1,700.

A DRAW AT STOKE
Sports Argus - Saturday 25 March 1905
The Villa lead Until Six Minutes from Time, when Sharp, the old Aston man, Equalised for Everton.
The teams Will Meet Again on the Nottingham Forest Ground on Wednesday
VILLA v  EVERTON
SHARP EQUALISES JUST ON TIME
A GREAT GAME
By “Argus Junior.”
For the seventh time Aston Villa have reached the semi-final stage of the Association Cup competition, end it was hoped that the psychological number would carry with it even further success—nothing less than the acquisition of the Cup for the fourth time in the history of the club. The progress, of the Villa in the present season’s Cup-ties has been nothing less than triumphal. it is true that they have been favoured with extraordinary luck, both in regard to choice of ground and the calibre of their opponents; but the supporters of the team have sufficient confidence in its ability to teel assured that even under less happy conditions the Villa would have fought their way into the penultimate stage. To qualify for the great event at Stoke to-day they have had to dispose in turn Leicester Fosse (5-1), Bury (3-2), and Fulham (5-0). If the tasks set them so far had not been supremely difficult, it was recognised that they could not have been given a harder test of merit than to meet Everton to decide the right of entering the final. The Liverpudlians do not possess such a glorious record as the Villa, for they have never yet carried off the great prize of the football world, though they have twice appeared in final (in 1893m and in 1897, when the Villa beat them after a struggle that Lord Rosebery described as Olympian), and only once have they been League champions (1891), while the Villa have five times achieved that distinction. But on present form so little divides the clubs that only the most speculative would hazard an opinion as to the chances of either of the rivals. While the Villa had only suffered one defeat in their seventeen matches, Evertor had not bees worsted since the 7th of January. An even more curious parallel is found in the match at Roker Park last Saturday, where Everton, after being two goals behind at the interval, won by 3 goals to 2, exactly the same score as that by which the Villa defeated Sunderland on the same enclosure in February, and the Villa on that day also were behind when the second half started. While the Villa pinned their faith to Rhyl their favourite training quarters, where they have been indulging in not over strenuous preparation, Everton carried out their preliminary programme at home, with occasional visits to the brine bathe at Northwich. Special preparations had been made by the Stoke officials to accommodate a huge crowd at the Victoria Grounds, and from the fact that so large a demand had been made for the high-priced tickets, it was evident that the resources of the enclosure would be severely taxed. Both the L. and N.W. and Midland companies ran a number of "specials" from Birmingham and from all parts of Lancashire—Everton being the last hope of the County Palatine -excursion brought big freights of enthusiast to the proud Potteries—proud because so important an event had been allotted to its capital. The Stoke enclosure is supposed to comfortably hold 45,000, and long before the hour of the start it was evident that it would be taxed to its utmost limit. The town was full of football enthusiasts, and merry -go-rounds in the open spaces indicated that showmen were bent on earning an honest penny out of the occasion. The ground under the shadow of the corporation gasometers was opened at one o'clock, and even then there were about 5,000 persons waiting outside the gates. Though dull the Potteries atmosphere was comparatively clear. Those who know the arena of old, after an anxious glance at the surrounding chimneys, were able to congratulate themselves that the wind was carrying the smoke the other way. The crowd, which by three o'clock had swollen to 40,000, was entertained during the period waiting by a military band. Everton came on from Liverpool this morning, and the teams arrived at Stoke within a few minutes of each other. Fortunately, both sides were able to play their full strength, and the men lined out as follows;-
Aston Villa.- George; Spencer (captain) and Miles; Pearson, Leake, Windmill; Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, Hall.
Everton.- Roose; Balmer (captain), Crelly; Abbott, Taylor, Makepeace; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, Hardman.
Referee Mr. A. Kingscott (Derby)
The Villa appeared first, and were accorded a hearty reception, as were their opponents, who closely followed. Balmer won the toss for Everton, and, electing to
defend the southern end of the ground, took advantage of a very slight wind. Hampton kicked off for the Villa two minutes before the advertised time.  Everton were first to attack, but Settle and Hardman were nicely checked by Spencer, whose return enabled Bache and Hall to get away. After a pretty run Bache centred, but neither Hampton nor Garratty were up, and the opportunity was lost. A notable piece of work by Leake, who took the ball from McDermott's toe, opened out the game, and Brawn showed up with a sparkling run along the touchline, which Abbott checked before the Villa man could get in his centre.  A neat centre frown Brawn cannoned off Crelly over the line, but the corner brought no advantage to the Villa. The latter, however, were plainly the more dangerous side so far, and were having nearly all the play. Hardman  and Settle broke away, but Spenser cleared with a delightful punt which dropped the ball at Hampton’s feet! The Villa centre made the most of the opportunity, but Crelly spirited down to meet him and dispensed him. Hall flung in a long shot which sailed over the bar, and altogether the star of the Villa was in the ascendant. Leaks was one of the most prominent men on the side. The Villa forwards ware combining beautifully, and a centre from Brawn, which was missed by Hampton, was snapped up by Bache. The latter shot in, but Brawn was a too late to late to apply the finishing touch.  The 'Villa forwards raided Everton quarters again, and a lovely cross from Brawn, who secured from Leake, was mulled by Bache, who shot over. The Everton supporters did not relish the manifest superiority of the Villa, and urged their favourites to play up. The Everton van seldom crossed the centre line, and when they did Spencer and Miles were equal to every emergency; Leaks caused cheers by the way in which he eluded three opponents in turn and fed Bache.  The latter headed to Hampton, who in turn headed into goal, but too short to do damage. Then Everton had a belated turn at attacking, and the next few moments spelt real danger to the Villa goal. To save a lightning centre by Sharp George had to give a corner, and again when Makepeace shot in at close quarters the Villa custodian had to tip the ball over the bar. A scrimmage full of incident succeeded, and every moment it seemed as if George would have been beaten, but eventually, through the agency of Pearson, the siege was raised, and Roose was again the centre of attention. Hampton had the Everton keeper well beaten, but hit the post with a terrific bang, to the cruel disappointment of the Villa crowd. The culprit himself was not disconcerted, and in the very next minute was charging Roose, who had the better of the argument, for while the Everton goalkeeper was coolly kicking away Hampton was disentangling himself from the meshes of the net, much to the amusement of the spectator. About this time the Liverpudlians woke up, and persistently attacked the lower end. Their forwards, who had shown little understanding got into their swing, and the Villa goal narrowly escaped disaster when Hardman swung in a centre. Young pounced on the ball and drove hard and true at goal. George seemed beaten, but luckily the ball cannoned off his back as he fell prone on the ground. Everton were just as persistent now as the Villa were in the first quarter of an hour, and Settle shot through when he was obviously off-side. The game was suspended owing to Hardman, who hurt his shoulder last week, injuring the same part of his anatomy again, while Leake was also limping. Hardman was able to get into harness again and the Everton light brigade were soon active at George's end. Young fired in a raking shot, which the crowd were already acclaiming as a goal, when George punched out magnificently. Leake was badly laid out through colliding with Taylor's outstretched foot, but though evidently in great pain he resumed after a rest.  The Villa were attacking with every prospect of success when a temporary truce arrived. Half-time;- Villa 0 Everton.0
In the second halt the cripples of the first half, Leake, and Hardman, both appeared, looking fit and well. The Villa were aggressive in the first minute, but a long dropping centre from Brawn went astray through Hall delaying his shot too long, Balmer being able to dispossess him. The pressure, however, was kept up hotly, and Roose had to save in quick succession from Garretty and Brawn, while Hampton levelled a shot which Roose got away under the crossbar. Even Miles tried his luck, and his shot was one of the best of the day. Everton got away fora brief spell, but Windmill returned only to see Brawn, with an excellent chance, shoot wildly over. He made amends, however, a second later by a crashing shot, which Roose got away cleverly at the cast of corner. Another corner followed, and from this came the long - desired goal. Brawn placing the kick nicely, and the ball was touched out to Hall, who made no mistake with his shot, screwing the ball well out of the reach at Roose.  The hero's hands were nearly shaken off by his delighted comrades, while the Villa section of the crowd cheered themselves hoarse. The success occurred when the second half was exactly ten minutes old, and had a wonderfully inspiring effect on both teams, though the game could scarcely wax much harden and faster than it had been previously. While Everton were active enough, George having to parry shots from Sharp and Young, the Villa's attacks were always more insistent and well sustained, and for fully fifteen minutes they kept the bulk of the game at Roose's end. Though Balmer and Crelly seldom allowed them to get on terms with Roose, they were always menacing. At the other end George brought off a fine save from his old tormentor. Young, but Everton were quickly driven back.  After Roose had yielded a corner to save from Garratty, McDermott raced half the length of the field with Miles in close pursuit, but George ran out and repulsed. It was close shave. Rain was falling now, and the ground grow greasy.  For the last fifteen minutes Everton had the better of the game and great credit is due to Spencer, Miles, and Leake for their splendid defensive work. Up to six minutes from the finish it seemed likely that the Villa would win by a goal. Such good fortune, however, was not to be, for Sharp, who appeared to be offside when he received a centre from Hardman, beat George and made the scores level. It must be said, however, that Mr. Kingscott had no hesitation in awarding a goal. The subsequent exchanges were exciting but no further scoring took place.
COMMENTS ON THE GAME
Geographically, a better venue than Stoke could hardly have been found, and certainly Birmingham had no right to complain. The Claret and Blues are prime favourites in the Potteries, where they are claimed as a Staffordshire team on the ground that the club was founded at Handsworth. Everton also were well suited. It was at Stoke that Everton won their way to the final in 1897, the year in which the Villa conquered them at the Palace. To-day is the fifth occasion on which the Stoke ground has served for a semi-final. It is a trifle on the small side, but apprehensions of encroachments by the crowd were unnecessary. The vast concourse was well disposed, and the lines were well guarded by stalwart policemen.
The Liverpool contingent made themselves conspicuous by waving blue flags, but the Villa supporters had the advantage in lung power. Wonderfully fit the men looked, and they had a magnificent reception.
For the first few moments both sides appeared oppressed by a sense of responsibility. The opening efforts were choppy and nervous, relieved only by stalwart kicking by the backs. Spencer and Balmer, the rival captain’s curiously enough, controlling their forces from the same strategic position, alone looked perfectly cool.
The Villa found their feet first, Leake and Bache showing up with accurate touches, which enabled pressure to be brought upon Balmer and Crelly. After several unavailable attempts Brawn swung in a centre, and Bache’s shot saved the bar. It encouraged the Villa to try again, and for some minutes Everton ere hotly taxed.
Leake was doing splendid work both of the stopping sort and in finding openings. Once he pulled up Young in midfield in brilliant fashion. Pearson and Windmill were very little behind and, thanks to their efforts things began to look very promising. A little more precision and the Villa must have drawn first blood.
In front of the posts, however, force was lacking, and Roose was only once tested. The lanky Evertonian has an enormous reach, and his agility also inspires respect. He had an anxious moment a little later, Hampton striking the post with a shot which must easily have beaten him.
The escape awoke the Everton forwards from their lethargic mood, and with Sharp going strongly the other goal became the centre of the struggle. Two corners kept the Villa supporters on tiptoe with anxiety. Once Pearson saved when the goal seemed bound to fall. George was not at his best, and twice fumbled awkwardly.
Whenever they were near goal the Everton forwards shot with knife-like keenness, and with several very near shaves the balance of the play was veering the Liverpool team’s way.
Sharp was dangerous whenever he had the ball, and Young was also well on the target. Spencer gave him a glorious chance by declining a charge, and the Everton centre’s shot stuck George’s body when the latter was in the act of falling to save. On the rebound it was cleared- a stroke of luck indeed for the Villa.
Hall and Brawn tried hard to transfer, but they were met by a bustling defence, and most of the opportunities as half-time approached were going to Everton. The Villa indeed, had to thank George for keeping their sheet clean, three of his saves being a good deal above the ordinary.
During the last quarter of an hour of the half Everton were going great guns. Their forwards waited with perfect understanding, and they were well supported by the halves, though Taylor and comrades were perhaps hardly such a clever line as Pearson, Leake, and Windmill. It was hoped that the Villa would do better with the wind in their favour, and the opening of the second half as favourable to the theory. The Villa forwards appeared to have taken a new lease of life. Thrice they bore down on Roose, and twice the latter played the ball through a crowd of opponents. Afterwards he saved a hard, low free from Leake beautifully in the far corner. It was Everton’s turn to look anxious, and for ten minutes they were penned in their own half. At this point Hall was favourably placed in a scrimmage following a corner, and he found the net obliquely at twenty yards range. Everton by no means exhibited traces of depression. Young and Sharp levelled in very good shots, and in the case of the former George had to make a mighty spring to clear the ball.
MR. McGREGOR’S SNAPSHOT
It was a very fast and exciting game- perhaps not up to expectations considering the great teams engaged, but nevertheless very interesting.
On the whole the Villa had most of the play, but on the play a draw was a fitting result. Villa started well, but towards the interval the Everton forwards showed rare dash, and George may be said to have saved his side by making two brilliant clearances. In the second half, as in the first, the Villa were the better side for the first portion, and Everton for the latter. The closing stages were most exciting. There was a suspicious of off-side about Sharp’s goal, but it must be said that Mr. Kingscott was in a capital position to judge. At all events, on the play leading up to it the point was deserved. Spencer and Miles played a great game for their side, and Leake was the best half back on the field. On the Everton side, the backs, Balmer and Crelly were not very clean in their kicking, but they did fairly well. Taylor, the veteran, was the best of the halves. The best forwards were Hall and Bache for the Villa, and Sharp and Settle for Everton.

HARDMAN
By Perseus
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 25 March 1905
H.P Hardman, another of the Evertonians, and also an amateur, is filling a prominent place in public notice at present, and to football enthusiasts in North Lancashire he is especially interesting personality, for it was at Blackpool that he first made a reputation. Joining Everton last season, he quickly proved his prowess in first-class company. Fortunate in his partner-the nippy little artiste, James Settle, who can pass with perfect precision- Hardman had advanced step after step. In the Everton team he has been a great success his speed, pluck, footwork, and centring having been excellent. In the third round tie against Southampton he reached his highest standard. Fortunately his brilliant display was observed by some who have a share in the distribution of honours, and he was picked to play against the Scottish League a fortnight ago. The weather and the ground were wretched, and he never had a fair chance, but on Monday he will have an opportunity of playing for his country against Wales. Evertonians, however, will have been more concerned with his exhibition in to-day’s semi-final.
Jack Sharp, the Everton outside right, has probably never performed so finely as of late. He has long been recognised as among the swiftest and cleverest of our outside right wingers. Years ago, in the Villa days, he was at one time preferred by the Aston Committee to the oft-capped Athersmith, who was waning a little when Sharp was coming on; and since joining Everton he has frequently shown himself a superb player. Only one thing has been against him- a tendency on occasion to avoid the more vigorous passages, in which respect he resembles a famous right winger of old, William Gunn, like himself a cricketer. Recently he has appeared to eradicate the fault, and to play with any amount of pluck.

ENGLISH CUP SEMI-FINAL STAGE
Staffordshire Sentinel - Saturday 25 March 1905
GREAT MATCH AT STOKE
ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
A DESPERATE GAME
EVERTON EQUALISE CLOSE ON TIME
STRUGGLE TO EB RENEWED
ASTON VILLA 1 EVERTON 1
All reads in North Staffordshire led to Stoke to-day, where two crack teams were pitted one against the other in the struggle to make good a claim to play in the last game of all in the absorbing cup competition at the Crystal Palace. The clubs engaged, Aston Villa and Everton, were at the game time two of the best known and two of the greatest football playing organisations at prevent in existence, and their premises at Stoke was a circumstance to which the lovers of the game within a radius of many miles of the Potteries had looked forward with almost unprecedented concern and interest.
The game of to-day was regarded as by far the most attractive of all the five semi-finals which have been played upon the Victoria Athletic Grounds, and it was confidently expected that with favourable conditions of weather the record attendance for the ground, established in the semi-final of 1897, would be considerably exceeded.
The Villa reached to-day's stage of the competition by beating in the first round Leicester Fosse (5-1). Bury (3-2) to the second, and Fulham (5-0) in the third; while Everton’s, appearance in the semi-final was the result of their having beaten Liverpool at the second time of asking by 2-1 in the fleet round, Stoke (4-0). at Stoke, in the second round, and Southampton at Goodison Park (4-0) in the third. Of the two clubs the Villa had unquestionably, ably the greater reputation. They have held the Cup three times. Their first victory for the trophy was in 1887 when, after it had been held for three years in succession by Blackburn Rovers, the Villa and West Bromwich Albion fought determinedly for possession. The Villa were victorious on that occasion by 2-0. Five years later they again appeared in the final, and again against the Albion, who this time wiped off old scores and trounced the Villa by 3-0. In 1892 Aston Villa again met their old rivals and neighbours, and turned the tables by a goal to nil.  In 1897 Everton were their opponents, and the game was admittedly the finest Cup final that has yet been seen. Everton had to confess the superiority of the Villa by three goals to two.
Everton have not yet held the Cup, although they have twice had it within reach, so to speak. Their first appearance in a final was in 1893, when the Wolves secured the trophy by a goal to nil, and their second was on the occasion already mentioned in 1897, when they were defeated by the Villa. On current' form them was indeed little ground for expressing a preference for either of the clubs struggling at Stoke. Both had men of experience and judgment to steady the younger members of the team, and the issue was remarkably open. In the Cup-ties the Villa bad scored 13 goals to 3, and the netters of the ball were: Bache (4), Hampton (4), Hall (2), and Pearson, Garratty, and Leake (One each). Including both matches with Liverpool in the first round Everton have registered 11 goals against and the scorers were: Settle (4), McDermott (3), Makepeace and Hardman (two each). Both Makepeaca's goals from penalty kicks, one against Liverpool and the other against Stoke.

THE PLAYERS.
EVERTON
L.R.ROOSE .- One of the finest goalkeepers ever seen on a football field. The only custodian for Wales. A fearless goalkeeper.
BALMER (W.).- A cool, determined right back. He kicks well and is a rare tackler. Played recently for the English League against the Scottish League.
CRELLY.- A Liverpool lad. A vastly improved back. Not very showy, but reliable and, at his best, brilliant.
MAKEPEACE.- Another local lad, who only got his chance this season. One of the surprises of the season for Everton. The penalty-kick artiste of the team. He has only missed one penalty kick during the season.
TAYLOR.- The old warhorse of the team. A rare worker. He is playing in the centre half-back position as well as ever he played in his life.
ABBOTT.- Always a worker, he has all along been one of the mainstays of the Everton defence. Can worry the forwards beautifully and shoot for goal with some purpose. SHARP.—On his day Jack Sharp is the finest outside right in England. He plays not only with his feet, but with his head, and has a happy knack of rising to great occasions. A most useful member of a side.
McDERMOTT.—One of the trickiest forwards playing football. A trifle slow, but clever. YOUNG.—Disappointing centre occasionally, but one of the best when in the humour. SETTLE.—The old International is playing as well as ever. The Everton front line is lost without him.
HARDMAN.—About as plucky a little forward as ever stepped on to a field. Very speedy, but owes a lot to his partner, Settle.
ASTON VILLA.
The heights and weights of the players are:—

 
GEORGE.-A sturdy custodian who allows in his fine physique his Army training. Stands well over most forwards. and is famous for mighty punches and tremendous goal-kicks. Always cool and good-tempered, and as popular off the field as on.
SPENCER—One of the sweetest-tempered and most polished backs of the day. Not quite so fast as he was a year or two back, but still well worth his place. A superb tackler. The Villa team would sadly miss him.
MILES.—A dashing back, lacking experience as yet, but shaping as though he would make a first-class man. His style is somewhat like that of his predecessor. Evans. The vigour of both men contrasts strongly with the quiet methods of Spencer.
PEARSON.—A schoolmaster engaged at Saltley Collage. and comparatively new to League football.  Has plenty of dash, and does not hesitate to use his weight. Is a fairly good shot.
LEAKE.—The former Small Heath skipper has made many friends at the Lower Grounds, and is playing sterling football just now. He can capably all any position in the intermediate line, and is a third back and a sixth forward. Has unbounded enthusiasm, is very popular with the other members of the team, and plays on to the end, whatever the state of the score.
WINDMILL—A Saltley College man, who has shown remarkable improvement this season. One of the brisk, bustling sort, whom forwards find it difficult to get past. Has not quite the style of a Crabtree, but is coming on by leaps and bounds.
BRAWN.—This speedy outside right came from Sheffield United, and has done the Villa good service. He has a tremendous stride, and after beating the back can centre squarely across the goal-mouth with a facility which few outside men can equal. GARRATTY.—One of the most experienced of the front rank, and though not fast as he once was, is still a valuable member of the team. Is always cool in front of goal, and often succeeds with a shot where a fussy man would fail. Critics are fond of describing him as a " plodder."
HAMPTON.-A dashing centre who revealed his merit in Birmingham League matches. His introduction to the team has made a wonderful difference to the attack. Never hesitates to go for goal, and is not much beloved by goalkeepers, whom he is apt to treat with scant courtesy.
BACHE.—Regarded as one of the cleverest inside lefts playing football to-day. It fast and tricky, and can shoot with remarkable accuracy. Went unaccountably off form last season, but never played better than at present, and on recent form his many friends deemed him a certainty for International honours.
HALL.—A. recruit from Stourbridge, tried on the left wing at an experiment, and making such an excellent partner for Bache that he has never been displaced. He is fast and clever, and knows where the goal lies.
IN THE CROWD.
(By An Idle Spectator.)
Stoke station undeniably busy. The trains puffed in and the trains puffed out, but the crowds came on for ever. Wakes Saturday was a mere fleabite to it. To find anything like it you had to go to Hampstead Heath on an August Bank Holiday. It was all push, hurry, scramble, and rush, and if you lost your feet it did not matter—you would find them again safely outside. "What', it all about?” gasped an immaculately dressed young man in top hat and frock coat, who had got caught in the crush while trying in fight his way to the refreshment room to fortify himself on a northward journey. A sturdy Liverpudlian with an enormous blue rosette in his button-hole, cast a pitying glance at the inquirer. "What d'you s’pose it is?” he inquired.
"Think it's the retreat of the Russians from Mukden? —: "
“Seems to me," gasped the young man, "that you're all retreating to Bedlam.”
"Oh, no, my friend—it's merely a football match," volunteered the Liverpudlian.
“Merely a friendly game, you know."
"What match is it!" asked the young man. But just then he was caught up off his feet and whirled away. The Liverpudlian followed him with a pitying glance.
  "Some of theme toffs don't know they're born yet," he observed to himself, as he went on his way rejoicing.
The journey from the station down to the football ground was like the march past of an army on a review day. First a squad of the Villa men with claret and blue favour, on: then a company of Toffeemen with blue favours in their coats. Itinerant vendors of unconsidered trifles were here, there, and everywhere. Piemen, sandwichmen, sellers of matches, programmes, picture postcards, and photographs, confronted one at every turn, net to mention blind beggars, dumb beggars, lame beggars, one-armed beggars, one-legged beggars, and beggars with no arms and legs at all. At half-past two, an hour before the kick-off, sixteen thousand people had passed down from the station to the football ground and still they came in unabated streams. The scene in the enclosure was good to look upon. Every second hundreds poured in through a score or so of gates. Sixty moneyless spectators swarmed up the advertisement hoarding at the town end, and, perched like monkeys on the top, grinning with joy to think that they were going to get an extra fine view for nothing. Vain hope! Enter Peter Dempsey, the genial groundsman, with a hose pipe, and accompanied by a sturdy policeman. The grins vanished right quickly, and the venturesome sixty evinced extraordinary celerity in swarming down again, before the hose pipe was turned upon them. The big gasometer was also attacked as usual. The attacker was a hay individual who brought a chair with him, deposited it on one of the platforms encircling the gasometer, and laid himself out for a real good time. But before he had been on the spot five minutes he came down again more quickly than be went up, at the urgent request of an officer of the law. It is better after all to pay your sixpence and look on in peace. The devices and decorations of some of the enthusiasts were ingenious in the extreme. Several of the " Toffy" supporters made their appearance in blue stove-pipe hats, which proved so offensive to the eyesight of boys from Brum, that they became a target for any missile which happened to be to hand. Their wearers soon found discretion to be the better part of valour, and discreetly put away their tiles—which were of the crush opera hat variety—and resumed a less conspicuous form of headgear. At a quarter past three the sixpenny end was closed, and disappointed would-be sightseers clambered on top of the covered shelter in scores, and sat comfortably on the roof. A battle royal ensued between those on top and those below, the missiles used being oranges. Hundreds of the juicy fruit were hurled up at those on the roof, but they refused to be dislodged by this means, and, catching the oranges, filled their pockets with them, returning grateful thanks for same to the enemy below.
Hurrah ! Bravo ! A great cheer goes up at ,3 20 as the Villa men, in their claret and blue jerseys dash on to the field. Hurrah ! again, and even a mightier cheer ascends when Everton show themselves. There is Roose strolling quietly along last of all, smiling cordially as be acknowledges a special welcome given to him by his old Stoke friends. The captains approach the centre of the field, and the crowd of 40.000 look on expectantly while the coins is spun.  Everton win, and their supporters set up jubilantly  their curious penetrating war cry—
Hay-oh, Hay-oh!
Hay-oh, Hay-oh!
Now they’re off, and although Everton, who defend the Boothen end, make a couple of incursions into their opponents' territory, they are soon sent back, and within ten minutes of the start it is plain that the Villa mean to " win or bust." The crowd hold their breath as a sharp one is popped in at Roose, but the old Stoke custodian is safe and clears finely. A couple of minutes later he is called upon again.  The ball is passed over to the left wing and Hall is after it at full speed. So is long-legged Roose. Who will win? Roose just manages to do the trick and sends the ball spinning into the crowd, almost decapitating half a dozen lookers-on. Hereabouts the Everton contingent are less demonstrative than they were as the beginning. The Birmingham men are, up to now, far and away the most aggressive team. With head and feet they are equally nimble. The ball runs along the whole of their forward line as though by clockwork, and the defence twice narrowly avert a downfall of their citadel. But Everton are sly customers. They play with their brains as well their feet, and although swept back at that they have a great deal in reserve. Suddenly their forwards get going, and Sharp, from the corner flag, sends in a shy which is sailing grandly into the net, when George leaps up and fists it out. A second later the leather is in again, and this time the score seems certain. "It's through, it's through," yell Everton joyfully but George is there again and tips it calmly over the top of the bar. Vociferous cheers from the Liverpudlians. Then the Villa throw away the chance of the match. The ball is within two yards of goal and on Hampton's toe. Roose is beaten to the world. It is a million to one on a goal. The Birmingham people are cheering life mad and then—Hampton bangs it into the goal-post and it bounces out. That there's many a slip twixt "the cup" and the foot is a proverb which ought to find its way into every football.  Half-time.
The enclosure is now absolutely packed. There is not an available inch to spare, and it is marvellous that some of the spectators with a precarious footing on the roof of the covered stand do not step off in their excitement. The gasometer platform now supports quite a number of privileged watchers of the game. It is far and away a record gate for Stoke. The first half has been fought magnificently, and everyone agrees that the contest has been a Titanic one. The Villa were clever, pretty, and effective, but Everton stayed splendidly, and in the later stages quite recovered what ground they lost at first. Nevertheless the Villa ought to have crossed over in front by at least a goal if not indeed a couple. The interval gave an opportunity for an interchange of opinion as to the respective merits of the play shown by the rivals. It was unquestionably the finest football seen on the Victoria ground this year, but the Villa's all-round play came in for most approbation. Nevertheless there were not wanting those who inclined to the view that Everton would come out on top in the end-and certainly there was no thought of them losing in the mind of one enthusiast who attempted to invade the field of play with a blue flag bearing the device "Play up. Everton." A policeman turned him back, and the flag-bearer retired to bury his disappointment in a glass of nut-brown fluid at the refreshment bar.
The Villa supporter, were not afraid that their team would lack staying power, and were confident of ultimate victory. The opening of the second half seemed to fully justify that confidence, for the Villa went off with just the same grand dash that they evinced in the first half. Their shooting was deadly, and for ten minutes Everton were penned in. Roose made some grand saves, but at length was compelled to concede a corner in saving a stinger from Garratty. Brawn took the place kick, and the ball went back to him. He returned it neatly on to the foot of Hall, and the latter banged it into the net amid deafening cheers. It was a magnificent goal, and in every way a fitting ending to a superb attack. Then the death cards came round. They bore the inscription: "In loving memory of Everton F.C., who died Saturday, March 25th, 1905 (on the Stoke Victoria Grounds), fighting for the English Cup.
Sweet little Toffee-men, the cup has fled,
And you are numbered with the dead;
The Palace gates are far away.
But try again another day.
“Blessed are the Toffee-men which die in the field, for they rest from their labours."
But the jubilation of the Villa partisans proved to be premature, for before the cards had been selling more than a few minutes Everton scored finely through Settle, and the decision became quite another question again. It was fitting that it should be so. for the match throughout was grandly fought.
THE GAME.
The teams had spent the week in quiet preparation. After their match with Sheffield United the Villa went to their favourite resort —Rhyl—where they remained until this morning. For the that time in their history the Everton team had discarded special training at the seaside, and had spent their time mainly on their own ground at Goodison Put, with occasional visits to the brine baths at Northwich and daily walks into the country. Both teams had brought their injured men back to playing condition. Spencer was limping after the villa's last League match, but he was reported fit. Hardman got a severe knocking about in the Sunderland match last week, but be too was able to take his place at outside left in the Everton team. The teams arrived shortly after 2 30. Everton occupied the Stoke dressing-room in accordance with the result of a toss-up a week ago, and the Villa were accommodated in the room usually assigned to visiting clubs. Two hours before the match the attendance numbered close upon 5,000 : and within half an hour the number was double. The track seats were quickly snapped and the Butler-street stand had few vacant places by 2 30. By three o'clock the attendance was not far short of 25,000 persons on the ground. The following is a plan of the field showing the position of the players:—
PLAN OF THE FIELD

It will be seen that the teams took the field in the manner originally selected. The ground was in capital condition, and favoured football of a high character, being like a carpet.
A huge roar greeted the appearance of the Villa on the field, the men being attired in jerseys with claret bodies and blue sleeves, with white knickers. Everton followed after a minutes interval.  At this point the crowd numbered not far short of 40,000. Three minutes before the advertised time for the kick-off came Mr. Kingscott and his linesmen—Messrs. Dennis (Middlesbrough) and H. B. Walker (Reading).
Everton won the toss and chose to play from the Boothen end of the field. From the start there was some midfield play, but eventually Taylor sent out to Sharp, but Leake brought off a clearance, when the Everton right winger centred. Leake was prominent in pulling up Settle, Hardman and McDermott. A couple of throws-in by the big stand resulted in Pearson, who was limping getting the ball out to Hall, who sent along to Bache, but the inside left was offside. The ball was cleared however. Following a run by Sharp (who was spoiled in his attempt to get the ball by Miller putting it into touch) the Villa got going, and Brawn ran on smartly and forced Abbott to concede the first corner of the match. This was put in wide, however, and Crelly placed the ball down the field to his forwards, but Leake again frustrated their efforts. The Villa were smart on the ball, and made good progress, Brawn and Garratty forcing the pace strongly. Hampton was off-side on one occasion, and Taylor was forced to concede another corner which was well cleared by the Everton halves. Garratty got a nasty bump with Taylor, Makepeace was responsible for a very pretty bit of play in trying to beat the Villa forwards, and he was eventually successful. But the Everton attack had to retire before Spencer, and before long Brawn seized the ball, and beating Abbott went on for goal. He put in a lovely centre which Bathe headed over. From the goal kick Balmer sent down the field, and Young made a sparkling attempt to break through the Villa defence, but Leaks and Howard Spencer outwitted him beautifully. Leake was seen to have been in collision with something or someone, for his face was bleeding. Miles met a pass forward by young with a long kick which fell just outside the goal. The Villa were doing the whole of the pressing so far, and Hampton and Bache both had shots. Hampton's was a weak affair but Bache's was a hard drive which whizzed outside the goal.  Settle was responsible for a fine bit of bustling work, and when he received the ball on the return he had hard lines to be blown offside. A moment later Sharp got possession and fired in a grand shot which George tipped over the bar. The corner was put in closely, but was rushed away by Pearson. When the Everton front rank got away McDermott was improperly given offside. A similar fate betel Sharp shortly afterwards. Then came
The Villa’s Best Chance.
Their forwards went away on the run, and Hampton received front the left, when favoured with an almost open goal. The Villa centre had a great opportunity, for with Roose beaten he struck the far upright. The Toffeemen made brisk play down the centre, and Taylor sent in a spinning shot which George was lucky to catch. Maintaining the pressure, the Everton forwards played smartly. Sharp sent in a beautiful centre for Young, and Pearson only diverted the centre's shot by giving a corner. This was followed by a second flag kick, caused by George putting the bell behind. Sharp and McDermott played cleverly down the wing, but Sharp's centres were a little too square. Settle and Young also came down, and on receiving from his left partner Young shot weakly, and George saved with ease, a moment later Young came along with Settle again, and the Everton centre sailed in on his own and shot. George brought off a fine save, and in order to allow the ball free outlet from the custodian Pearson smartly jumped over it and Spencer finally cleared. A foul in favour of the Villa afforded only a temporary respite to the Birmingham brigade, for after another combined run by the Everton quintette Hardman shot over. In the continued pressure by the Liverpudlians Hardman was hurt in the shoulder, but he soon resumed, although the injury appeared to trouble him somewhat. A foul against Leake near the centre line was taken by Balmer, and Settle ran in to materialise, but was grandly spoiled by Spencer. George was called upon to save a smart shot by Settle, and, then McDermott shot over.
An Unfortunate Incident occurred when Taylor, in trying to prevent Leake receiving the ball from Pearson, put his foot heavily into Leake's stomach. It was probably accidental; at any rate Mr. Kingscott threw up the ball after Leake had resumed. Spencer was rather fortunate to rid himself of a long pass by Taylor, but the shouts for a penalty against the Villa back were totally unjustified. Half-time:— VILLA, 0; EVERTON, 0.
The first half had produced football worthy of the nature of the game. Though at first the Villa were the smarter and the more dangerous, the Toffeemen retaliated with groat dash, and were only kept out by the Villa halves and Spencer. If Young had the chance which fell to Hampton it is very probable he would have made more effective use of it. The Everton forwards looked likely to wear down the opposition in the later stages of the game. George had kept a fine goal. but Roose had much less work to do. From the restart Bache went away finely, and with a swinging pass placed the ball a few yards in front of Brawn. The latter returned the ball out to Hall, who shot Balmer gave a corner, from which Brawn all but headed through. The Villa kept pegging away, despite a brilliant effort by Settle, and Roose had to save from Hampton. The ex-Stoke custodian saved grandly, and a moment later he saved a  splendidly-taken free kick by Miles. The Villa played grandly, and the frequent fouling of the Evertonians enabled the Birmingham team to keep up the pressure. Garratty called upon Roose to bring off another magnificent save, with which he had to play into touch. After a momentary break away by Sharp, who was pulled up by Windmill, Brawn tried a shot at long range which went behind. Then Hardman returned to the attack, and he, too, shot wide. Again Brawn was given the ball by Garratty, and the inside right received it, and Brawn again called upon Roose to save, which he did only at the expense of a comer.
VILLA SCORE
After all this pressure by the Villa team it was not surprising they should score, which thou did after eleven minutes of the second half. From the corner kick just mentioned, which was taken by Brawn, the ball travelled to Balmer, who put it to Hall instead of to  McDermott. Hall had a clear opening, and with a lovely shot, which Roose saw was hopeless from the Start, scored. Then the Everton front rank went to the attack Iike demons. Spencer had to head away twice, Makepeace being particularly dangerous. But the Villa defence hung together well, and the custodian was scarcely troubled. A foul was given against Young for kicking Leake on the chest. But the Everton defence withstood the pressure ensuing from the free kick, and rushing away Sharp forced a corner, which was of no value. The half-back play of the Everton team seemed to falter about this point, and Abbott was especially uncertain. Young made a grand dash all on his own, after Sharp had prettily outwitted Spencer. The centre shot well, but George saved with ease. But the Toffeemen pressed warmly, and forced a comer, and a shot from Abbott was headed away by Miles, who thus compensated for a serious miskick a moment previously. Leaks was the author of a fine opening for Brawn, which resulted in Hall having an ineffective shot. A splendid piece of work followed a breakaway by Sharp. The outside right went at a great pace, and before Miles bad charged him he had shot. George kicked away very cleverly, and Young met the bell on the rebound, and shot yards over. Miles and Leake did a lot of bustling, and kept the forwards well at bay. Settle and Young made A Very Determined Rush, and George saved from an overhead kick by Settle. From George's kick the Villa want away gamely and forced a couple of corners. Brawn placed both nicely, and from the second Hall shot behind.
The Game Level.
Quits unexpectedly Everton draw level. Taylor bad found an opening from the midway line and gave to Sharp. The latter went away at a fine rate and flung the ball out to Hardman. Sharp ran in towards the goal, and received a lovely centre from the outside left. In a twinkling the ball was in the net. This occurred within six minutes of the finish.  After a couple of free kicks the whistle went, and the game will be probably replayed at Nottingham on Thursday.
NOTES AND COMMENTS
By Jovel. What a crowd. An hour before the kick-off, too!! Except for some reserved vacancies on the grand stand and a few previous in the mountain of humanity at the town end of the ground every inch of space is occupied. Where are all the thousands still pouting on the ground through a score of turnstiles going o fix themselves? Talk about sardines in a box!-
One could fancy more demonstration from such number wedged together under such circumstances. Rattles and horns one can hear, and snatches of the “old bull and bush.” But the pervading sound is a dull murmur- a tangible solid sort of noise, pierced by the martial notes of the Artillery Band as it plays its quick steps round the cycling track, halting here and there for the delectation of a favoured section of the multitude. Excited, eager conversation is going on everywhere. It is the huge neutral element that is keeping the excitement in bounds. The partisans can be distinguished by the colours they affect. Strange as it may seem the Everton colours -blue and white -seem to be the more in evidence. Perhaps the unadorned are chiefly partisans of the Staffordshire team. So far as one can gauge the popular feeling, Everton are rather favourites. But the Villa’s past achievements are present in the mind of everybody, and none except the rabid partisans are expressing any certainty as to the result. Now the excitement is growing. All eyes are turned to the embarkment at the Town end where some enthusiastic Liverpudlians are carrying a banner bearing a legend which the glasses make out to be “Play up Toffees.” Electricity is in the air, and the more enthusiastic can’t restrain their feelings. The mouth is the safely value, and the excitement taken vociferous shape. Popular choruses are being sung all round the ground. The gates at the Town end have been closed ten minutes. The density of humanity there has reached its limit. The crowd is now probably the greatest ever seen on the Stoke ground. The teams are almost due. The last few moments of suspense are departing for numbers of men who have clambered on to the iron roof at the popular end are being pelted with oranges. Suddenly from the Butler-street stand comes a cheer which is soon taken up round the field, for here come the Villa in their claret and blue shirts and spotless knickers. A minute later there rises a still louder cheer as Everton take the field in their blue jerseys and white pants. Both team have come on in that buoyant fashion which means “gameness.” The ground is like a billiard table. There is no sun, no wind; in fact, the conditions are ideal. The Villa start towards the Boothen end amid terrific excitement. From the first exchanges one gathers that every man is going to put forth the best that is in him. The Birmingham contingent are the first to get near the goal. Bache makes a weak attempt to centre, but he’s offside. . The Everton right rush the ball three-quarters the length of the field, but a foul sets the Villa off again. Ball shoots over the bar when Brown has put across. Quickly Crelly gives one corner and Taylor another—both unproductive—and between whiles Roose handles the ball for first time. It reaches him, bouncing, having alighted somehow 'twixt Bache and Balmer. The ex-Stoke man kicks away deliberately, but he is evidently as excited as he can be, for in another minute he rushes almost to the touch-lane to kick away when the ball would pass harmlessly out.  Brawn covers the ground as lightly as a gazelle, and centres magnificently, but the ball is shot wide from the left wing. The Villa are thus far by far the smarter eleven. Their backs, keeping well down, appear impassable—in contrast to the Toffee backs, who are not receiving the same half-back support.  Magnificent play by Leake initiates a forward movement, which is only checked by a smart save by Roose. At last Everton have a look in. A magnificent ran by Settle results in Sharp securing. Racing up the wing he puts in a shot which George can only punch over the bar. The corner is only kept at the expense of another which is only kept up by a miracle. The constant offside decisions, quite properly given against Everton, are annoying the crowd. The Villa go forward again, and Hampton receives from his left wing in an uncovered position. It is apparently much more difficult for him to fall than to succeed, but the ball strikes the upright, rebounds into play, and Balmer clears. Now Everton begin to show their tip-top form, and the erstwhile superiority of the Villa is put into the shade. Nothing finer than their forward play could be imagined. Time after time George can only save his charge at the expense of a corner. Every man of the quintette is playing like a demon. George keeps a fine goal, but more than once the Fates assisted him. The Villa flashed down, and Hampton finds himself sitting under the net after Roose has coolly kicked away. This is the last time the Everton custodian is called upon for some time. Everton press with determination, only equalled by their scientific passing and splendid marksmanship. There is a lull when Hardman hurts his shoulder, and another while Leake recovery from an injury. From now until the interval play is more even than it has been all through the half. and the whistle announces the close of a terrific first half with a blank score sheet.  
The Villa resume sensationally. Hampton toucher to Garratty who swings the ball clean across the field to Brawn. A characteristic centre follows, and Balmer Just dashes up in time to intercept Hall’s, shot. Though the corner is cleared, Everton can't got out of their quarters, and Roose makes some excellent saves. When Settle gives a foul just over the line he saves a lightning grubber from Miles, and a minute later a fearful shot from Garratty. A spasmodic attempt or two by Everton threaten no danger. The Villa are up again in a twinkling, and Roose in saving a terrific volley from Brawn gives a corner. With difficulty this is kept back, the ball going out to Brawn. Very deliberately he lifts it amongst the players thronging the goal. Hall gets his head to it, and hey, presto! the Villa are one up. It is the consummation of ten minutes' combined play, which is very inadequately described as brilliant, and the deafening cheers which ascend are well deserved. Everton are soon down towards the Villa goal, but their shooting seems to have lost its sting. Truth to tell, their half-backs at this stage are failing them. Sharp gets in one shot which George has to punch out, but the Villa goalkeeper is not troubled for another ten minutes. His backs are doing all that it required. Leake is working like a Trojan, and the forward are giving the Everton backs a warm time of it.  Once George saves a stinger from Young, but his subsequent position is a sinecure until Sharp causes him some anxiety. The Everton man sweeps down on his own, but Spencer comes to meet him, and thus baulked, Sharp loses the ball to George.  Half-way through the mooed moiety it looks as though the Villa have the game in hand. The Everton forwards. however, are still game, and McDermott and Young each give George a warm handful. The Toffee's halves are falling away, but the forwards are still all vim and dash.  Such sportsmanship deserves success, and it is achieved, seven minutes from time, Sharp equalising amid a tremendous uproar.
TIME TABLE
3.15- There is a huge swaying crowd of 40,000
3.20 -A roar! Aston Villa trip on and indulge in ball practice.
3.21 ½ -Another roar? Everton receive a vociferous welcome, especially from the Stoke end of the ground.
3.27.- Mr. Kingscott and the other officials bring in the new ball.
2 27 ½ .- Everton win the toss and choose the Boothen end.
3.29.- Villa kick off. Everton made the first raid. Leake checks their advances.
3.32.- Hall and Bache perform a “duo” on the Villa left, but Balmer supervenes.
3.33.- Abbott is compelled to give a corner when Brawn rushes in.
3.33 ½ .- Crelly clears the wide flag-kick.
3.35.- Shap sprints away on Everton right, but Miles relieves.
3.37.- Hampton shoots over; then Garratty is hurt in a collision , but there is no stoppage.
3.38.- Villa are keener on the ball, and Taylor gives a second corner.
3.40.- Makepeace dashes clear, but Spencer and Miles are superb in defence, and Brawn treats the spectators to a fine run and grand centre, which Bache tries to convert, but Balmer baulks him.
3.45.- Leake is in the thick of every Everton attack, and works like a Trojan, and Young cannot pass him.
3.46.- Hampton heads on and Roose saves with Bache on him.
3.47.- Settle passes to Sharp but he’s off-side.
3.48.- Sharp is off again, this time all right, and George gives a corner.
3.48 ½ .- Everton are crowding the Villa goal but cannot force through
3.52.- Hampton is going through on his own, and so easily. A yell! He has hit the post.
3.53.- In go Villa again and Roose saves just as Hampton goes head over heels into the net.
3.54.- Away go Everton. They are working now? And George stops a grand shot from Taylor.
3.57.- Sharp centres. Young compels a corner from Pearson.-
3.57.- Everton gain another corner. Then as the ball goes rapidly towards Roose, Balmer dispossesses Hampton, and Sharp tries to run through.
3.59.- A respite for the Villa, but Pearson and Brawn fail.
4.0.- Spencer is beaten and shoots, but George throws away a slow shot.
4.1.- George saves wonderfully from Young, and Spencer clears.
4.2.- Settle is penalised for jumping at Spencer. Then at
4.3.- McDermott and Hardman go through and amid cries of “Goal!” Hardman’s shot goes over.
4.4.- Corner given by Miles
4.5.- Stoppage -Hardman is charged. His right collar bone hurt. He soon resumes.
4.8.- Villa are on the defensive and hard pressed.
4.9.- Settle puts in a cannon shot which George does well to save and McDermott narrowly misses the mark from George’s repulse.
4.10.- Villa try to work through, but Hampton is offs-side.
4.10 ½ Leake is accidentally kicked by Taylor, and there is a stoppage for his attention
4.12.- Play resumed, and
Unfortunate rest of time line is on crease on the newspaper is cut in half and impossible to read.
For the record half time is call at 4.14 ½ and resumed at 4.25. 4.35 Villa one up and 5.2 Sharp scores, 5.11 time call.

INTERNATIONAL CAPS FOR ROOSE, AND HARDMAN
March 26, 1905.
Played at Anfield England v Wales, England winning by three goals to one, in front of 20,000 spectators, Hardman scoring the 3 rd goal.

FINE FIGHTING FINISH AT STOKE
Athletic News - Monday 27 March 1905
By Tityrus
In the distance one could hear the raucous voices of the street hawker vending;- “Memory cards of Everton.”  These productions are pestilential, but it is a free country.  The sellers of this trash were, however, too previous, and in the end they were badly sold themselves, as their funeral wares suffered a slump.  The Evertonians were in dire distress.  Aston Villa seemed to be ready for the Final.  But eight minutes from the cessation of hostilities and one and only jack Sharp rose to the demands of the occasion, and was the chief instrument in scoring the goal which will cause both teams to meet again at Nottingham on Wednesday.  The Aston Villa men had their chance on Saturday, and they will be lucky if they meet Everton in the same vein a second time.  When I went to stoke I conjured up visions of the memorable final which the same clubs gave us at the Crystal Palace in the diamond Jubilee year.  A repetition of such a historic struggle was too much to anticipate.  That standard was never reached. Nor did we see play by either team to equal that of Manchester City against Sheffield Wednesday at Everton twelve months ago, although we had the pleasure of assisting at a battle that was desperately fought for the whole 90 minutes.  Possibly the Villa ought to have been the victors, but they did not take fortune at the flood, and 34,000 people were strangely divided in their sympathies and opinions when “Cease firing” was signaled.  Let it at once be said that the arrangements left nothing to be desired.  The spectators were comfortable, the players had everything in their favour until the rain intervened, and there was enough enthusiasm to keep everybody warm.  The teams live to fight again another day, but Everton may thank their stars that they have another chance of travelling the royal road to the Crystal Palace.  Aston Villa commenced in a style that indicated an intention strictly honourable and laudable of deciding the game in the first quarter of an hour.  Their quick footed centre never forgot to ply Hall, the outside left, who was ever a source of danger.  Brawn, too, was most serviceable, and I liked his long passes to the left –but nothing more than a corner-kick or Hall shooting high over the bar was the result of that maneuvering.  On the other hand Sharp now and again showed his heels to the Villa men, but the outstanding feature of the early play was the work of Hall.  Everton seemed slow and labored in their play, and their backs did not inspire confidence.  Much of the ineffectiveness of Everton at this juncture was due to the fact that Leake was very vigilant when Young tried to set his wings going.  Once Leake, Garraty, and Bache combined so deftly that Hampton headed in, but Roose saved cleverly despite the attention of Bache.  Gradually Everton improved, and Young at length sent Sharp an acceptable pass.  Literally he flew over the ground, and centred so grandly that George could only parry the ball at the expense of a corner kick.  Makepeace headed in beautifully, and the Villa custodian gave a second corner kick, which was not made the most of, for Brawn broke away, only to be eventually mastered by Crelley.  But the “Villians” returned in rare style.  Crelley flastered, and Hampton, with not an antagonist to hamper him, had only Roose to hoodwink.  The use of the adverb “only” is not intended to convey the impression that Roose is a mere detail.  Hampton tried to place the ball where the Welsh international was not, and he put some sinew behind the ball, which cannoned back from the wooden framework.  How that post shivered!  This was a miraculous escape for Everton, but Roose was equal to a fine effort by Bache and at the other end George barred the way to Young.  Everton now showed better football than ever they had done before, and in the last twenty minutes of the first half they gave George many an opportunity of proving that he is still a worthy man to guard the breach.  Young and Sharp were the most aggressive but save a succession of corner kicks Everton went empty away.  Once Settle gave to Hardman, who made a delightful centre.  Settle was there with a grand drive, but George repelled, and Sharp sent over the bar, and so the first half passed away without a goal.  On reversing the “Villians” were again the quicker to make their presence felt.  Bache and Hall, with Brawn, were still the principal factors in forcing the game, but Roose kept a fine goal.  He was smart in fielding a tremendous drive from Leake, who engineered a free kick very neatly.  But Roose excelled himself in cutting out a shot from Hampton, who trapped a long pass from Hall, and at short range, after turning round, he troubled Roose with a messenger that would have scored against most men.  But not so against Roose.  However, even Roose could not hold out for ever.  Hampton flashing along in the centre swished the ball out to Brawn, who centred.  Roose conceded a corner, which was accurately placed.  But the ball was returned to Brawn, who again lobbed it into the goal mouth.  Hall saw his opportunity and headed in.  Roose did not seem to espy the shot until it was right under the bar and going away from him all the time.  His effort was too late, and the Villa at the end of nine minutes were a goal in hand.  Everton rallied, but their forwards were never able to complete any attack, although Makepeace came near scoring with a ball that grazed the outside of the net.  Sharp was responsible for a mighty drive, which George diverted at the expense of a corner kick.  The Evertonians, however, seemed a beaten side, for their backs made me pause, and Sharp seemed to me the only hope of the side, although Young made a commendable shot on the target.  Sharp was the man who seemed to take the game in his hands.  He led one raid which brought George out of goal.  He was only partially successful, and Young sent wildly over the crossbar.  But Sharp by a signal asked Tom Booth, who was looking on, how long there was to play.  The Everton captain, who is still resting for repairs, appeared to indicate five minutes. Sharp saw another chance, and took it.  With what fine speed he dribbled the ball along!  Just before Windmill and Miles had been too much for him, but Sharp never spared himself on this occasion, and when well within the penalty area he crossed to Hardman who came in and returned to the goalmouth.  The ball was passed and repassed by Settle and Young until Sharp consummated the movement by shooting past George when he was very near goalline.  It was a good goal, and admirably worked for.  Some of the Villa officials were at the utmost in their opinion that the point was illegitimate and urged that Hardman at least was off-side, but I was right on a line with the players and the goal, to my view was the best of the match. So Everton were saved by Sharp and the game was drawn.  At the same time, I hold that Aston Villa showed the better football.  The eleven were more cool and calculating, their defence taken as a whole was sounder, their half-back play much superior, and their attacks more artistically conceived and more skillfully executed.  The Villa were not so dangerous in front of goal as Everton when they did arrive-and herein lay the salvation of the Lancastrians.  The Astonians began each half in such spirited manner that they created a tremendous impression, and yet their adversaries always had sufficient strength to finish well.  The Goodison Park team were unquestionably slower to the ball, and their want of speed made them appear much the weaker side, and yet I should not like to express that opinion.  On the whole the Villa more nearly realized their highest standard of play than theirs opponents, and Everton mist show considerable development to win at Nottingham.  George, much more ponderous than he was, showed a slight tendency to misfield ground shots.  I dare say he wishes that his solid flesh would melt when he has to bend, but nevertheless he had nothing to reproach himself for.  The backs in front of him were a strong pair.  Miles has studied Spencer to some purpose, and with due deference to his tutor the left back of the Birmingham club (avaunt, Small heath!) was the finest of the four defenders.  Spencer stands for judgement and Miles for vivacity, pace, and instinct in getting to the ball.  As a pair they are most reliable and help each other.  I should not omit to mention that Spencer once or twice actually charged Hardman.  Although Leake was twice in the wars, for his head was cut and the sole of Taylor’s boot went into his stomach, the veteran of the side was in rare form at centre half.  Windmill ably seconded, and Pearson was not far behind his confreres.  Garraty was almost stunned when the right side of his face was in Collison, but like Leake he is as tough as an ash sapling.  The inside right is a persistent plodder, and he understands what Brawn requires.  With ever so slight a start of his opponents Brawn with his giant stride rushes up the wing in taking style.  Give Brawn a clear course, and he is at once dangerous, for his centres and long passes to the other wing are not surpassed by those of any other player.  His long leg often enables him to secure the ball when a man of less reach would fail, and his centres are generally of such a “strength” that they can be taken.  Many men make more theatrical centres than Brawn, who evidently has thought out “middles” and the rattling long pass to the left wing.  Nothing so harries and worries a pair of backs as accurate work from wing to wing, for the point of attack is changed with such rapidity.  Once an inside right, Hall has been transformed into an able outside left, and with his old Stourbridge clubmate, Bache, he never lacks opportunities.  But everybody plied Hall, who showed an admirable disposition, and never tired.  He can dribble double back on an opponent, centre, and shoot.  What more could a man do?  Save that Bache was inclined to “mix” matters with McDermott and did not shoot too well, I could find no fault with him.  Although Hampton never attempted any dazzling individual performances, such as he is sometimes credited with, he was most unselfish.  He never forgot that he was the pivot and not the piston rod.  The Villa centre does nothing so well as look after his wings.  Such generally commendatory remarks cannot be made concerning Everton, Roose on springs may convey an impression of his agility in expanding himself over eight yards by eight feet.  The famous Welshman never seems to have a bad day, and I feel sure that he never saw the shot that beat him until he was helpless.  Roose stands out boldly as the best custodian in the British Isles.  Neither Balmer nor Crelley was as safe as the Bank of England.  I have seen both perform more creditably for there was neither length nor direction about their kicking.  The ball flew off their boot at tangents, and to the most unexpected localities.  The occasion was too much for Crelley, and Balmer was too anxious I am not forgetting that the ball became sliddery, and I often thought it was well that Roose was in the rear.  The Lancashire half-backs revealed unsuspected weaknesses.  Both Abbott and Taylor were woefully slow.  Nor were they too clever, so that Makepeace once again proved the best of the three, all of whom were quite mediocre in defence and very apt to loft the ball instead of setting their forwards going by ground passes.  One saw the difference on the other side, as the Everton forwards could swear.  McDermott, who lay more forward than usual, now and again was tricky with the ball, but on the whole he was put off his game, and Sharp had to help himself.  The Lancashire cricketer’s speed and skill were frequently seen.  Eleven sharps would have given the Villa much cause for uneasiness.  Young was very useful, especially towards the close of the first half, but he has often been more effective.  The Villa defence never allowed him much latitude, for that way lay danger.  The left wing was not at their best and Hardman who played against Liverpool and Southampton was not the Hardman we saw on Saturday, save in the matter of pluck.  Settle too, was well watched.  Aston Villa; George; Spencer, Miles; Pearson, Leake, Windmill; Brawn, Garraty, Hampton, Bache, and hall.  Everton; L.R. Roose; Balmer (W.), Crelley; Makepeace, Taylor, Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P. Hardman.  Linesmen F. H. Dennis (Middlesbrough) and Horace Walker (Reading).  Referee; A. Kingscott, Derby. 

ASTON VILLA 1 EVERTON 1 (fa cup Game 50)
March 27, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
F.A.Cup Semi-Final
A HARD STRUGGLE.
Everton failed to produce their best form in their match with Aston Villa. Indeed, the admission may at once be made that they were somewhat favoured by fortune in being permitted to fight the battle over again at Nottingham next Wednesday. For once in a way, anticipation as to the classiest exhibition of football of the season were scarcely realised, Both teams have often been seen to greater advantage-especially Everton. Porbably the excitement naturally associated with a great cup struggle affected certain of the player. Of this there is no doubt, that under ordinary circumstances cool and collected players “lost their heads” at times, with the obvious result that their play suffered. At the same time the 40,000 spectators had the satisfaction of witnessing a determined contest between two teams who had made up their minds to do what lay in their power to deserve, if they could not command success. While the crowd hailed the Villa's goal with the utmost delight, they were equally impressed by the spirit which the Evertonians displayed in endeavoring to stern the tide of adversity, and their enthusiasm was something to remember when Sharp, who it as popular a footballer as he is a cricketer, brought the scores level.
VILLA'S STRONG OPENING.
Prompt to time- in fact, shortly before the half-hour- the great rivals entered upon the fray. The Villa who not only looked, but are by far the heavier team, lost no time in settling down to serious business. There was method, too, in their movements, and the incisive nature of their attacks placed their followers in rare good humour. Roose, however, was in a happy mood on the ground, which he knows so well. Still, the run of the play was far from satisfying from an Everton point of view, and when Hampton, with a beautiful opening, crashed the ball against the upright, the followers of the “Blues” were intensely relieved. It took Everton representatives quite a long time to get into their ordinary game, but once the change occurred they fairly extended the Villa defenders. George, fortunately for his side, never faltered. He fisted out a brilliant shot from Sharp, and from the corner he again tipped the ball away as most of the spectators though it would pass under the bar. Several capital attempts were put in by the Everton forwards, but George repelled them all, and at the interval the score sheet was still untarnished.
A GOAL EACH.
As in the opening half, the Villa, after change of ends, dashed off in vigorous fashion. They made Everton look pretty small, and with the backs becoming shaky, Roose's position was no secure. The more work he had the better the Welsh international seemed to like it. Such sustained pressure was bound to tell sooner of later, and ten minutes from the restart, the Everton citadel was captured. It was a capital goal, too, which Hall obtained. From a corner Brawn centred beautifully, and the ball coming back to him, he placed to Hall, who took full advantage of his opportunity, beating Roose all the way with an effort against which, the keeper was utterly powerless. Although the Evertonians pulled themselves together, the Villa for some time after this appeared certainties for a visit to the Crystal Palace. But the resources of the Everton attack were not yet exhausted. Sharp caught the eye as the dangerous individual, and it was from his toe that the equalising point, so sincerely welcomed arrived. He himself led up to it. His speed enabled him to race round the opposing half, and, after a grand dribble, he put across to the leftwing. Hardman returned it, and in a twinkling the teams were on an equality. The Villa protested, but Mr. Kingscott had no doubt about the legitimacy of the point. Though exciting the closing stages brought no further goals.
THE PLAYERS.
The Everton players experienced one of their “ off-day”. They were almost as much below par as they were when they ousted Liverpool from the competition. It is to be hoped that next Wednesday will find them in a different vein. Roose, in goal, could not have been improved upon; indeed, the goalkeeping of both Roose and George was a feature of the match. Spencer and Miles were a better pair of backs than Balmer and Crelly. The latter was weak and brilliant by turns, while the Everton captain at certain periods of the game seemed quite unable to do the right thing. The Everton halves, for such a trio, performed indifferently, Makepeace being the best. On the other hand, the Villa half-backs line. Leake in particular, were in splendid form. Sharp was unquestionably the pick of the Everton forwards. He afforded another instance of the faculty, which he possesses of rising to a memorable occasion. Young had some hard luck in his shooting, and on one occasion, when he was brought down with the ball at his toes, many a referee would undoubtedly have awarded a penalty. Settle was scarcely as serviceable as usual, and neither Hardman nor McDermott distinguished himself. The Villa left wing placed finely, while Bache time after time centred accurately, and now may the better team win at Nottingham.
Teams: - Everton: - Roose goal, W.Balmer (captain), and Crelly backs, Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott half-backs Sharp, McDermott, Young Settle, and Hardman forwards. Aston Villa: - George goal, Spencer, and Miles backs, Pearson, Leake, and Windmill, half-backs Brawn, Garratty, Hampton Bache, and Hall forwards. Referee Mr.Kingscott.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 27 March 1905
The meeting of Everton and Aston Villa in the semi-final of the Football Association Cup competition at Stoke was generally regarded as the tit-bit of the day’s games. Both teams had been exhibiting their form in recent matches and seldom had the issue of any Cup-tie been so difficulty to prognosticate as this one. The result a draw of one goal, thus bears eloquent testimony as to the well-matched character of the combatants and on the day’s play the final figures accurately represent their respective abilities. Everton did not display anything like their customary excellence; there was not that keenness in their work that has been such a marked feature of their play recently, but they live to fight again and at Nottingham on Wednesday they may possibly show to better advantage. It is a curiously and likewise a coincidence that both first and second half were fought out in precisely the same fashion. To begin with, the Villa went off with rare dash and spirit, and for twenty minutes gave their opponents a terribly anxious time. Their forwards were vigorous and clever, and the Everton defence was sorely harassed. On one occasion Hampson went clean through and when within six yards from Roose shot against the upright. This was a stroke of good luck for Everton, and gave them heart for afterwards they improved and showed the crowd that they were not the third rate set of footballers that they had been made no appear by the resistless Villa advances up to this juncture. Gradually they were down the Midlanders, and peppered George with some lovely shots. He was tested more than Roose had been, and cleared in grand style repeatedly. Young was badly fouled inside the penalty area, but this was disregarded by the referee who certainly cannot be complimented upon the manner in which he conducted the game. Everton had matters their own way up to the interval, but strange to relate when the teams reappeared the Villa again asserted themselves and after ten minutes Hall headed a centre from Brawn into the net, completely out of the reach of Roose. This was a staggerer for the Blues, but they never gave up, and six minutes from time Sharp eluded Miles, and sent diagonally across the goal to Hardman, who when nearly on the line returned it to the centre, and the right winger promptly netted. With the exception of the last twenty-five minutes of the first half, when some fine football was shown, Everton did not exhibit satisfactory form, and they appeared to be overcome by the importance of the occasion. The forwards very inclined to play the inside game instead of keeping the wing men employed and it would have been more advantageous to Everton had Sharp been plied more consistently than was the case. In the second half he left Milne in the lurch on two occasion the first of which gave Young an open goal, which was nulled and another which led to the equalising goal. McDermott was off colour, and seldom displayed these deft touches for which he is usually so noticeable and this naturally had a detrimental effect on the work of the extreme right winger. Whenever Sharp did obtain possession he invariably made excellent use of his opportunity and he was easily the best forward on the Everton side. The pity is that he was not more assiduously tended otherwise Everton might now have been ready for the final. Young was responsible for some capital work, though he was closely shadowed by Leake, and Settle also indulged in some skilful footwork at times; but Hardman was not very prominent for the simple reason that he was provided with few chances. As a line the forwards were not altogether satisfactory, though at certain periods of the game, to which reference has already been made, they were excellent; but they confined the play too much and these tactics suited Leake especially and the Villa defence generally to a nicety. Such a high standard of play has been set by the Everton half backs and forwards that any deviation from the original is immediately noted.  Such was the case against the Villa though the calibre of their opponents naturally made it impossible to expect them to romp through the Midlanders as they had done previously through Southampton and Stoke. Even taking this into consideration, it cannot be said that the half-backs were particularly effective. The Villa outside right, Brawn was frequently left unmarked and often when the ball was driven out to this wing the tall and stately Midlanders had a clear course. There may have been some method in all this, but to the ordinary observer it was not apparent. The Everton trio were not sufficiently resourceful for the Villa vanguard and, as will ne gathered from the foregoing, the attack of the Goodison Park eleven was capable of improvement. That this will be forthcoming in the replayed tie is a matter sincerely to be desired. Further behind, Balmer and Crelly were weak, the former making many blunders, and his kicking at times was inexplicably erratic. His partner also interspersed much that was only moderate amongst his work, and Roose was thereby given every opportunity of showing his worth. And right well did he perform the task, high shots and low shots being splendidly dealt with. Everton will probably do better on Wednesday, but they must keep their heads cooler than they did at Stoke. During the periods when the Villa were outmanoeuvring their rivals they showed excellent form, and Hampton may never have such another chance of earning fame as fell to him when he ahd the goal at his mercy and missed. This cost the Villa the match, and gave Everton another chance. There was not the same stylishness about the forward play of the Midlanders as in previous years, but they were terribly energetic, and tremendously in earnest. Hampson is a most promising centre forward, who knows the game, and even the watchful Taylor could not keep him in check. At times the whole line combined cleverly, and Bache put in some capital work all through the game, whilst his partner. Hall, is a distinctly smart footballer. Their methods were, however, not such as are usually associated with the Villa, for the ball was kept too often in the air instead of along the ground, but their rousing rushes were always dangerous and required some stopping. When the ball came to his feet. Brawn made good use of his chance, but he is not prone to over-exertion, thought he centred splendidly, he was, however, very mildly treated, and given ample latitude to exhibit his fine turn of speed. Leake was the most conspicuous of the half backs, and he was an indefatigable worker throughout. Hands, head, feet, and tongue were all brought into operation, and though lacking in style he was the most useful member of the rear division. Windmill and Pearson are capable players, but the former has yet to learn how to keep his temper. By their physical superiority in the matter of height the Villa enjoyed a great advantage, and to this perhaps more than anything else must be attributed their ability to hold the Everton forwards and half backs. Spencer and Miles were fairly sound in defence, but the honours in this respect were carried off by George, who in the first half saved his side from disaster. In fact, the goalkeeping on both sides was excellent and this department alone upheld the reputation which has been associated with the teams. Little can be said favourably about the referee’s rulings, and there was more room for improvement here than in any particular department of either set of players.

TO FIGHT ANOTEHR DAY
Liverpool Echo - Monday 27 March 1905
BRILLIANT METHODS AT THE STOKE FOOTBALL GROUND
Everton save the game
By Bee
Time must show. We are not yet settled which club shall meet Newcastle at the Crystal Palace on April 15. The problem remains- Everton or Villa for the final? On Page 3 I have described some scenes at the ground; now for the details of the match. At the outset I say there was hardly a goal difference between the clubs, yet, honestly speaking the Villa were early a goal better than their adversaries.  It was strange that the game should be split up into four sections. For the first twenty-five minutes Villa applied a terrific pressure on Balmer, Crelley, and Roose. After that point, and up till the interval, Everton were all round the superior team. From the restart to halfway through the forty-five Everton were on the defensive and then the remaining time was spent in efforts to beat George. Throughout it was a fast, exciting game and although it did not compare with the 97 final still there was full value for the money, inasmuch as the result was decidedly open until the last moment. Everton showed that wonderful tenacity which has pulled them through so often this year. Up to within six minutes before time the Villa supporters were confident that the game was theirs. By brilliant methods Everton saved the game in the last few minutes, and the credit of the equalising kick by John Sharp was led up to by each of the forwards. The Villa man for man were taller and heavier than their opponents, and on the day’s play were cleverer, but, mark you, the wearers of the blue jersey were quite below their usual form, added to which the Villa hesitated in front of goal. This was their fatal fault, and made the difference between a triumphant victory and an honourable draw. It is not often that one has a word to say against the Everton halves or backs, but on Saturday they were completely off form. Balmer quite lost himself and miskicked quite a number of times. He appeared more than any of the others to suffer from nerves. Even the worthy John Taylor made many mis-passes-an altogether unusual fault with him. Abbott laid on hard to Garratty, thus leaving Brawn a very wide berth. Makepeace, when once he got the measure of Hall and Bache, put in some very clean work, and yet he was a long time settling down. Never before have I seen the usually strong division of the club so incompetent. Of course this threw extra duty on the backs. Balmer failed; Crelley rose to the occasion. Crelley’s tackling was typical of him. Roose played marvellously when called upon but this was seldom. Nevertheless when the Villa did shoot it was with great force. For instance, when Leake sent in a terrific shot from fifteen yards’ range Roose picked the ball up like A.C. McLaren would pick up the cricket ball in the slips. Leake feinted to take a free kick, yet let Miles take it. Roose got to the ball in magnificent style. The men were all crowded round about him. The shot, a ground shot, travelled towards the corner of the post. Roose’s view of the ball seemed to be totally blotted out; yet he got to it, and saved. He is an extraordinary goalkeeper. He was beaten eventually by Hall, who headed in a fast centre from Brawn, and no possible complaint could be laid against him on this account. The Brum men adopted quite new methods. They hustled their opponents off their feet in the first quarter of  an hour, and would not let them settle down to their usual style pf play. Then another variance from the typical Villa form was the long, strong, and swinging passing they showed. The ball was transferred to extreme men to opposite wings and yet the opportunities were thrown away at times. Once “merry Hampton” let fly and shivered the left upright, and with Roose beaten. The ball rebounded, and Roche also in front of the custodian, shot outside. The Villa’s inside wing forwards did not give of their best in the shooting department. The Everton forwards were ably led by Young, who gave George some very hot shots to negotiate. George was very safe, though a trifle lucky with one from the centre forward which nearly knocked him over. Sharp was the best forward, and the pity was that he was not plied with judgement by McDermott, who lay too far back and got at logger, heads with Bache. In my opinion Mr. Kingscott made an error in granting the equaliser as the offside rule had been infringed. This failing, if it was a failing, was levelled up, because Mr. Kingscott missed seeing a most flagrant case, which should certainly have been penalised with the penalty kick. There was a quick breakaway on the part of the Everton forwards. Sharp swung the ball across to Hardman. After all the forwards had helped in the movement Hardman propelled it back to his colleague, and before George could make up his mind whether to run out or stay on his line the Lancashire cricketer had saved the gamer for his side. What a roar went up! John Sharp was the most dangerous of the attacking party. Young came next, and Settle next. Poor Hardman had his shoulder hurt again, and this upset his play. McDermott was at times brilliant and at times very poor. The Villa defence was excellent. Leake was thrice laid out, and yet he was the most prominent player on the field. The backs were clean kickers, and there was little to choose between them. In my opinion the Villa can hardly hope to meet the Blues on such medium form as on Saturday, and when we go to Nottingham on Wednesday it will be with the confidence that Everton, having now the measure of their rivals, will pull the game through.
EVERTON FOR THE CUP
That is my fancy.

MIDST THE MIGHTY THRONG
Liverpool Echo - Monday 27 March 1905
INCIDENTS OF A JOURNEY TO AND FROM STOKE
SCENES AT THE GROUND
By Bee
I sat midst the mighty throng! What a memorable sight! A vast expanse, a sea of faces, excitement at its highest pitch, yet good humour withal. The sight of the crowd of football enthusiasts of every grade of life of many varied nationalities -one heard the Lancashire dialect one moment. Yorks another Birmingham another, muggy staffs following, along with Welsh, Scotch, Irish and other doggerel. This mighty  throng was concerned about the play of Everton and Aston Villa in the semi-final tie of the English Cup at Victoria grounds. Train load after train load of followers of the game were taken to Stoke by the railway companies, and it is said that forty excursions in all were run in connection with the match. Even this number was insufficient. To hundreds who had gathered at Edge-hill Station the railway officials said, “Get in the first ordinary train to Crewe, the carriages are full at Liverpool, and you may never get to Stoke.” This was a bright outlook for men who had given up work for the day rather than fail to get a view of the match of the season! However they were bound to carry them to their destination, and though additional coaches were linked on, the average number of persons in each compartment was fifteen. In the carriage I squeezed into ten people were seated and seven were standing. One of the unfortunates, whose ruddy nasal organ lit up the carriage when we passed through the three miles long Harecastle Tunnel, declared his intention to “have a nap.” The sixteen others objected and being in the great majority the ruddy one was not able to have even “forty winks.” The ruddy one next exclaimed, “Ay, Bob, if it rains tha’ll cum wi’ me and we’ll drain t’ barrel at t’ pub.” It is a probability that Bob and his friend did not get to Victoria Grounds, even though rain did not fall until after four o’clock.
Arriving at Stoke in good time, the thirsty and hungry souls looked about for refreshment and much oftener for other houses. Stoke is not flushed with restaurants, cafes or public houses, and the rush on the Staffordshire people’s preserves was enormous. The shopkeepers had made more complete arrangements for the feeding of their visitors on Saturday than on the occasion of the previous visit of Liverpool persons a month or so ago, in the second round but these arrangements were totally insufficient and there was a rare scramble for food and drink. As the town became filled, the locals left work  and from the striking of twelve o’clock till after the time of kick-off there was one continual stream of enthusiasts wending its way towards Boothen-road. In fact, the route was black with people. The spirit of the crowd was jovial. “Friends all” was the motto. Before the match the Villa supporters seemed to imagine that their chances were excellent. Villa supporters, taken generally, are distinctly bigoted and one-sided. You cannot drum into them that there are other first-class clubs in the country. They won’t have it at any price. However, they had their eyes opened before the conclusion of the game. Before operations commenced, the general view of the Evertonians was that the match was anybody’s, and that victory might go to either club. Their wish was “May the best side win” -and a rider adding, “May that side be Everton.” 
At the ground, those who had been there before noticed many welcome improvements. The Football Association had many things altered and all of them were for the best. O looked round the enclosure for the Everton mascot, the tall lady member who has so regularly seen Everton win. The familiar lilac decorations of her hat were missing. Was it a bad omen? Those two comics “The Hatters,” with a banner bearing the lines.
“Play Up Toffees.”
Lancashire’s Last Hope.” Were soon making themselves known. Other persons to amuse were those who climbed on to the corrugated iron roof of the refreshment room, and defied the police officials to fetch them down. Words were useless. The men had an excellent view of the playing space, and were not going to move for anyone-so they said. But when a fire hose was procured and was put in order for giving them a small thunderstorm, they slid down the roofing in double quick time. A contingent of the Staffordshire Volunteers was present, and a paltry population like that of Tamworth provoked enthusiasts to fill fifteen coaches on the London and North Western Railway line; while it was computed that 5,000 of Crewe’s railwaymen were present at the match. The band of the local artillery regiment discoursed popular airs, and at three o’clock there must have been 35,000 people present.
The secretary of the Stoke Club, who was asked his opinion of the dimensions of the crowd, said; “I really can’t say. We never get out ground filled like this.” Undoubtedly the selection of the Stoke enclosure for such an important meeting came just as the right moment, as the club has not this year received much money from league gates. It was not Everton’s first experience of semi-finalists at the Potters’ ground. In 1897 they beat Derby County there by 3 goals to 2 being eventually thrown out of the competition by their opponents of Saturday. Five times the Stoke ground has been honoured with a semi-final tie.
The orange sellers on Saturday did a roaring trade, and the purchasers created a deal of fun when they made targets of them men who had climbed on the roofs of houses, grand stands, &c. At twenty minutes past three Spencer led his men on the field, and they received a tremendous reception. Trainer Grierson got them very fit at Rhyl. Soon afterwards Balmer and his companies received royal welcome. It will interest the correspondent who wrote a few days ago about the club’s jerseys to know that the new jerseys, of a dark blue hue, were used for the first time. They have been bordered with a white collar, and the combination is very effective. Roose however, still continue to wear the dirty knickers- I presume as an omen of good luck. There was an excellent spirit of friendship between the two sides, and a deal of handshaking was indulged in, while Leake the doyen of the Villa Club, early on made the crowd roar with laugher.
The game over, the honours even, and- then for the exits. There was one solid mass of humanity crammed into the smallest possible space being carried along. Where the crowd went everyone went. There was nothing to the left or right unless the swaying of the multitude on it. Again, the difficulty of getting food, and how often did the hoarse throated supporter say to his friend. “I have got a thirst on me!” There must have been many hundreds who neither ate nor drank from three o’clock till ten. The first train steamed out of the goods yard at 6.30 and others followed in quick succession, the latest being due to leave at 10.50. a number of enthusiasts were left behind on the platform, and others were put in cells for safety for the night.
The return journey enabled supporters to discuss the afternoon’s sport, and more particularly the prospects of a win on Wednesday. The consensus of opinion went favourably for the Blues, and for this reason, that they have now got the measure of the lively Villans, and are more likely to hold their own on Wednesday. “Had they had another five minutes to go they would have won,” said an Evertonians; and I agree with -BEE.

REVISED FOOTBALL DATES.
Liverpool Evening Express - Monday 27 March 1905
At a meeting of the Football League, held this morning at the Alexandra Hotel, Liverpool, the dates for the Everton v. Woolwich matches were left to the respective clubs, who fixed upon April 5th at Goodison-park and April 22d at Woolwich. Everton play Notts Forest on Easter Monday. -
EVERTON v. ASTON VILLA
In view of Wednesday’s replayed cup semifinal, the Everton players are paying a visit to the brine baths at Northwich to-day.

SOUTHPORT CENTRAL 2 EVERTON RESERVES 1
March 28 1905. The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire Senior Cup Final
The destination of the Lancashire Senior Cup was decided at Southport last evening, when Southport Central and Everton met in the Final-tie. Owing to their match with Aston Villa today, the reserve team represented Everton, and this robbed the match of a good deal of interest, it would have possessed in view of Southport's defeat of Liverpool in the same competition. Southport were at full strength, the teams being: - Southport Central: - Dent, goal, Spink, and Rimmer, backs, Sinclair, Edmonds, and Chorlton, half-backs, Dawson, Stadbolt, Smith, Lawson, and Danson, forwards. Everton: - Scott, goal, R.Balmer, and Wildman, backs, Ashworth, Booth (Captain), and Chadwick, half-backs, Rankin, McLoughlin, Roberts, Caldwell, and Dilly, forwards. Referee John Lewis.
This was the second time in succession that Southport appeared in the cup final, for they met Blackburn Rovers in the match last year, at Preston, and were defeated by a narrow margin. Everton won the toss, and set the local lads to face a strong wind. Play opened in a determined fashion, and Smith work himself into a good position, when Balmer rushed across, and took the ball from his toe. The Blues had a brisk look in, and then a neat bit of passing between Shadbolt and Dawson took play to the other end, where Smith failed to take Dawson's centre. Rankin went rapidly away, but put the ball out. Smith shone in a magnificent run, but he lost the ball when he had almost reached the goal. Wildman coming up behind and robbing him. A miss by Edmonds let in Roberts, who sent in a hard shot just wide. A corner to Everton from a throw-in near the flag, and a series of wild kicks on the part of Southport players put the home goal in danger, but at last Sinclair relieved the pressure. Smith, who was playing a great game, beat Balmer, and this led to a beautiful goal. Sinclair sent in a centre from the line, and the ball curled in, Lawson met it with his head, and the first goal was scored. The Central success was received with great cheering. Everton made a desperate effort to draw level, and forced a corner from which Chadwick shot wide. The Blues pressed hard, but the home defence held out grandly, although Dent once dallied almost too long in clearing. A moment later Chadwick hit the upright. Then the Central broke away, and Smith sent in a shot, which Scott just managed to stop, but could not gather, and from the rebound Smith tipped the ball into the net. Everton kept the ball in the White's half, and seemed able to do anything but score. Scott saved rather luckily at the other end. Booth started a pretty movement of the Everton forwards, and the visitors were still pressing when the whistle went for half-time, with the score, Southport Central 2, Everton nil.
On resuming Rankin and McLoughlin made tracks for the home goal, but Chorlton broke up their passing and sent the ball down the field. Everton returned, and Dent fisted out from a bully in front of goal. Danson got off, but was checked by Chadwick, and then McLoughlin raised the hopes of the Everton supporters, present by a grand run, which, however, Edmonds interrupted. A big kick by Balmer only temporarily stopped a rush by the Central, and Scott was called upon to save from Smith. The game was fast, and hotly contested, but was free from fouls. After a long spell of pressure by Central, Dilly broke away, and passing Spink had no difficulty in beating Dent. The goal put heart into the Blues, and Dilly was once more in full cry when pulled up for offside. Scott saved a dropping shot from Shadbolt in good style, and had to save again from Lawson a moment later. Everton had another try, and, playing in fine fashion, were very dangerous, but Rimmer kicked away, Danson forced Scott to give a corner. This came to nothing, but during the next few minutes Everton custodian was a busy man, saving right and left. The sustained attack was one of the finest bits of play. Southport put on during the game. After some exchanges Dilly forced a corner, but placed it wretchedly. Everton were dangerous from another grand run by Dilly, Dent give a corner, but this was cleared, and Scott had to save a bouncing shot from Dawson. Afterwards Everton playing for all they worth, swarmed around the home goal, but at last the great joy of the home crowd, when Edmonds cleared. Result Southport Central 2, Everton 1.

EVERTON REVIEW
March 28 1905. The Liverpool Courier
The indecisive result of last Saturday's Association Cup semi-final at Stoke has rendered necessary another struggle between football giants. This afternoon Everton and Aston Villa will meet on the well-appointed enclosure of the Nottingham Forest Club to settle which will be pitted against Newcastle United in the final at the Crystal Palace. Of course there are possibilities of another draw, but both clubs, in view of numerous other engagements which have to be fulfilled, will be only too glad if the issue is decided one way or the other. One team will eventually have to be disappointed. Let us hope it will not be Everton. Excellent arrangements have been made by Mr. Hallam and the other Forest officials to accommodate the spectators who will pour into the lace capital from all parts of the country. It is estimated that quite 35,000 people can be provided with places from which to obtained a good view of the game. Even the officials do not expect such a large crowd at a midweek match, although they agree that Aston Villa v Everton is one of the most attractive fixtures that could have been sent to Nottingham. Naturally the Villa will be favourities, but after all the Nottingham spectators are good sportsmen, and dearly like to see a fine exhibition of football. While the Villa have been continuing their training at Rhyl, the Everton players have remained at home since Saturday. On Monday they paid another visit to the Northwich brine baths, from the use of which they have derived so much advantage. Yesterday they did no hard work. They travelled last evening by the Great Central route to Nottingham leaving the Central Station at half-past six o'clock. The Victoria Station Hotel will be their headquarters, and they will drive from there to the Forest ground an hour before the match. The teams will be exactly the same as that which pulled the game out of the fire at Stoke. Two players from each side L.R.Roose and H.P.Hardman of Everton, and Leake, and Spencer of the Villa participated in the Welsh match, so that in this respect the international calls will place neither at a disadvantage. The Everton players themselves are pretty confident that they will be able to improve upon Saturday's game. They admit that their form was not of the best they can give. As Mr. W. C.Cuff, the secretary, when questioned yesterday, remarked “I do not think the team can do otherwise than improve on Saturday's display.” This is a view shared by thousands of Everton supporters. May it materialise!

INTERNATIONAL ENCOUNTER AT LIVERPOOL
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 28 March 1905
ENGLAND v  WALES
The fourth of the Association international contests of the season took place on the ground of the Liverpool Club yesterday afternoon, when England and Wales tried conclusions for the twenty seventh time. Up to the kick-off England could claim nineteen wins to two standing to the credit of Wales the other five games having terminated in draws. The successes of the Welshmen date back more than twenty years, but, although no victory has recently rewarded their efforts, the last three meetings between the two counties in Wales have all ended in draws, and two seasons ago at Portsmouth England were somewhat lucky to win by an odd goal. Moreover, against Scotland twelve months ago Wales held their own at Dundee, and at the beginning of the present month gained a victory ay Wrexham by 3 goals to 1 in the thirtieth match of the series. In the face of this marked improvement the English authorities could not mow run the risk of placing experimental teams in the field against Wales, and selected their eleven with almost as much care as that to meet Scotland for yesterday’s encounter the side chosen to represent England included the same three half backs that took part in the drawn game with Ireland at Middlesbrough last month, and four of the same forwards. That there would be no alteration in the half back line was generally expected, but seeing how ineffective the forward line proved on that occasion, there was reason to anticipate more changes in the front rank. Having at last beaten Scotland, the Welsh executive naturally did not consider it necessary to make many alterations in their eleven against England. At the last moment Parry, who was to have captained the Welshmen, could not play, and so Lathom, of the Anfield Reserve, took his place. Atherton and Blew also cried off, and the Manchester City and Nottingham Joneses were included. The full teams were;-
England.- H. Linacre (Nottingham Forest); H. Spencer (Aston Villa, captain), Herbert Smith (Reading); S. Wolstenholme (Blackburn Rovers), C. Roberts (Manchester United), A. Leake (Aston Villa); R. Bond (Preston North End), S. Bloomer (Derby County), V. J. Woodward (Tottenham Hotspur), S.S. Harris (Corinthians), and Harold P. Hardman, (Everton).
Wales.- L.R. Roose (Everton); C. Morris (Derby County), Jones (Nottingham Forest); Lathom (Liverpool), E, Hughes (Tottenham Hotspur), J. Hughes (Liverpool); W. Meredith (Manchester City), Jones (Manchester City), M.W Watkins (Sunderland), A.G. Morris (Nottingham Forest), and A. Oliver (Bangor).
At three o’clock there were quite 15,000 people present. The trips run by the railway companies from all parts of the Principality were well filled, and there was a preponderance of the Welsh language to be heard on all sides of the playing space. The stands presented an unusual and pretty spectacle and the officials had banners flying and placards bearing the inscription, “God Save the King,” and “Hen Wald Fy Hhadau” {“Land of Our Fathers”} The sun shone brilliantly, but the turf was rather heavy after the downfall of yesterday morning. Crowds of people rolled up to the ground, and near the time of the kick-off there must have been 20,000 spectators. The Englishmen were the first to appear, and they were formally photographed in the presence of an admiring crowd. The men from the Principality appeared a few moments later, and they in turn submitted to the ordeal of having their counterfeit taken. The referee and his linesmen were a little late in starting the game, but the enthusiastic crowd did not mind the slight delay. England won the toss, and the Welshmen had to face Old Sol, who was in full flare. The Taffies made a brave effort to force the pace on their left, but Wolstenholme offered stern opposition. Wales was not to be denied, however, and Oliver and Morris finally got away with a rare burst until H. Smith interposed successfully but the Reds stuck to it in the Rose territory and once more the Reading back was called upon. Now the English team came away for the first time, and Roose had to a swift ground shot from Bloomer, which was not troublesome. England then took up the attack on the left wing, and Hardman got along, but he was checkmated by C. Morris. Then a breakaway on the left was finely stopped by Spencer, and the English front rank once more invaded Welsh territory, where a free kick enabled Morris to once more show his mettle. Watkins now removed the venue, but Meredith was offside, and then the English left attacked in fine style and Harris tested Roose with a regular beauty. It was a low, swift shot, which Roose dealt with in his very best style. Soon after danger came again from the English left, when Hardman just missed by inches. Bloomer then ran through in his own inimitable way and he finished with a glorious low shot, which Roose cleared magnificently. After Roose had taken a free kick, Roberts had to exert himself to stave off a stiff rush of the Principality, Fifteen minutes had now gone, and it was clear that the English lot were immensely superior. After a throw in from the corner flag, a goal kick brought relief to the Taffies. The Englishmen still pressed, and then came a fine bit of passing all along the English front. Bloomer opened out to Harris, who immediately responded with a really grand shot. The Welsh backs were hard pressed, and Morris had to deal with a hot one from Hardman. Then came another from England, which was cleverly turned to their own account by the visitors, Meredith and Jones promising well until the latter unfortunately put outside. Returning to the attack, Harris tested Roose with another of the electrical shots, which went just outside of the upright. The Welshmen did not seem capable of a really decent effort, and were held at every point, even Meredith’s lightning rushed proving abortive against the cool defence of the Reading amateur. A little looseness among the English backs gave Jack Hughes an opportunity of putting his side in possession. Spencer missed his kick, and A.G. Morris had the goal at his mercy, but failed egregiously, and though L. Jones also had an opportunity of making amends, he also made a mull of it, and Wales thus lost an excellent chance of opening their account. After this lucky escape the English right invaded Welsh territory, and Bond shot across to Hardman, who failed to receive. Then his brother amateur Harris tried to retrieve the fault, but Blew was much too smart. Now came a fine dashing move from the Welshmen which completely upset the calculations of Spencer and Smith and Linacre was in great jeopardy when Meredith put the leather to Morris, who had an admirable chance of beating the English warden at close quarters, but a moment’s hesitancy was taken advantage of by Linacre, who dashed out and cleared superbly. Thus had Wales missed two splendid openings. Once more the Rose took up the attack and some neat sequences of passing transpired, Bond ultimately swinging across to Woodward, who tried a long shot, which, however, the breeze deflected. Thus far, although the game had been mostly in favour of England, the Welsh attack always had dangerous elements in it, but there was vacillation and hesitancy. The English front rank were capital individually, but there was not nearly enough combination to seriously trouble Roose or his backs, and Jack Hughes of Liverpool, also did good work for the Leek. During a lull Harris got at the ball and drove it in with terrific force, and although Roose had no chance whatever of saving the fickle leather struck the crossbar and rebounded into play. Towards the interval the Welshmen tried hard to drive ahead and Oliver, running through had rather the best of both Roberts and Spencer but though the latter was grassed he managed to divert the direction of the ball. Meredith tried to force matters on the right, but he was too closely watched by Leake, and the Manchester City flyer was rarely allowed to get away. A fine breakaway by the England left looked like putting them ahead, and Harris did his best to secure this, for he shot with terrific force, but Roose was not to be caught napping and he cleared magnificently. For some time the English forwards monopolised the pressure, and a hot volley in front of goal was rather daringly cleared by Blew, who punted strongly. The men of the Principality replied with a spirited attack on the left, but the home backs were both cool and collected, and they easily beat the invaders back. A burst away by the English left ended in Hardman sending across, but Bloomer was obviously offside when he rushed the ball and himself into the net, and then crowd laughed merrily, and Roose patted the famous international on the head. At moment later half-time came, the score being; England nil, Wales nil.
The teams returned at 4.29, Woodward leading off a minute later. A clever back-heel move by Meredith tricked Leake, who had all along paid unwelcome attention to the City player. Smith checked Meredith cleverly, and the English lot occupied Welsh territory, when a miskick by Blew enabled Roose to show his alertness in clearing unexpected danger; but England would not be denied, and they pressed with such vigour that Roose was surrounded, and a goal seemed quite certain when Woodward managed somehow to put the leather outside the post. It was a most remarkable escape for Roose. After a temporary breakaway by Wales the “Bulls” encroached once more, and Roose rushed out to clear from Woodward. The English right made a very fine rush, but the Tottenham centre-half pulled them up in gallant style, and a huge punt by Blew changed the venue to English territory, where Meredith swung across to Morris, and them Forester gave Linacre a big handful with a smart header. The Taffies stuck to their work stubbornly, until Hardman got away with a fine sprint down his wing. Then ensued some splendid passing along the line of English forwards to which Wales offered futile opposition, and effective work between Bond and Bloomer led to a grand opening for Woodward, who beat the mighty Roose with a short, sharp shot at very close quarters. Hardly had they restarted when Roose was shot from the toe of Hardman. Latham tackled Hardman roughly, but got badly damaged in the collision and had to retire for repairs. Hardman also got a nasty bump. Wales, with only ten men, got on fairly well, but on Latham’s return Woodward raced down, Roose came out, but could not get the ball away, and it looked as if Bloomer should have scored. Meredith next forced a corner off Smith, and just afterwards, slipping by the Reading amateur, he slung the ball right across the goal mouth. Grenville Morris, dashing up headed through, and so equalised amid tremendous applause. Having got on terms, the Welshmen played up with rare dash, and they should have taken the lead, for again Meredith got in a fine centre after eluding Smith, and Watkins had an almost open goal, but he lifted the ball over the bar, this throwing away the easiest chance of the game. There followed a very pretty movement started by Leake, Harris putting the ball over to Hardman, who ran down and centred, Harris at close quarters putting the ball into the net, and so placing England ahead again. The Welshmen made desperate efforts to get on terms again, and Linacre had to jump up to save from W.L. Jones, while Meredith also went very close. The game was then almost over, but in the last minute Bond centred well, and, out of a scrimmage, Woodward scored England’s third goal. The match ended;-
England 3 goals, Wales 1
Linacre had not a great deal to do, but what little work came his way he dealt with in skilful fashion. Neither Spencer nor Smith, although each got in some fine kicks, were as safe as could have been desired, and towards the end the latter quite failed to hold Meredith, Leake, as usual, played a sound and resourceful game, and Roberts acquitted himself creditably; but Wolstenholme fell considerably below his best form. Of the forwards, Harris and Woodward greatly improved upon their performance against Ireland, dribbling neatly, taking their passes well, and the former shooting with plenty of power. Hardman was very prominent in the second half, but the right wing did not work well. Bloomer rarely making much ground, and Bond confining his efforts mainly to sending the ball across to the other wing. Roose kept goal brilliantly, and could not really be blamed for any of the three points registered against him. C. Morris defended strongly at back, but A.T. Jones, his colleagues, was far from safe. Latham and J. Hughes were the most prominent of the Welsh halves before the interval, E. Hughes doing the best work after the change of ends. The forward line did not combine so well, but Meredith was always clever, and really brilliant towards the close; while Grenville Morris, except for one had miss, played a fine dashing game, and was one of the most dangerous forwards on the field. England all things considered were the better side, but the form did not attain to the excellence desirable in view of next Saturday’s match with Scotland. Of the twenty seven matches now played, England have won twenty, Wales two, and five have been drawn.
RESULTS OF PAST MATCHES
1879- At the Oval England won 2 goals to 1
1880 At Wrexham, England won 3 goals to 2
1881- At Blackburn, Wales won 1 goal to nil
1882- At Wrexham, Wales won 5 goals to 3
1883- At the Oval England won 5 goals to nil
1884- Wrexham England won 4 goals to nil
1885- At Blackburn, Drawn 1 goal each
1886-At Wrexham England won 3 goals to nil
1887- At the Oval, England won, 4 goals to nil
1888- At Crewe. England won 5 goals to 1
1889- At Stoke, England won 4 goals to 1
1890- At Wrexham, England won 3 goals to 1
1891- At Sunderland, England won 4 goals to 1
1892- At Wrexham, England won 2 goals to nil
1893- In England, England won 6 goals to nil
1894- At Wrexham, England won 2 goals to nil
1895- In London, Drawn 1 goal each
1896- At Cardiff, England won 9 goals to 1
1897 -At Sheffield England won 4 goals to nil
1898- At Wrexham-England won 3 goals to nil
1899- At Bristol England won 4 goals to nil
1900- At Cardiff- Drawn 1 goal each
1901- At Newcastle-on-Tyne, England won 6 to nil
1902- At Wrexham, Drawn nothing scored
1903- At Portsmouth, England won 2 goals to 1
1904- At Wrexham, Drawn 2 goals each
ENGLAND v  SCOTLAND
At the conclusion of the international match the Selection Committee chose the following team to represent England against Scotland at the Crystal Palace, next Saturday;-
Linacre (Notts Forest), goal; Spencer (Aston Villa), and H. Smith (Reading), backs; Ruddlesdin (Sheffield Wednesday), Roberts (Manchester United), and Leake (Aston Villa), halves; Sharp (Everton), Bloomer (Derby County), Woodward (Tottenham Hotspur), Bache (Villa), and Bridgett (Sunderland), forwards.
At the meeting of the Scottish Selection Committee held last night, the following were selected to represented Scotland;-
Lyall (Sheffield Wednesday), goal; McCombie (Newcastle United), and Watson (Sunderland), backs; Aitken (Newcastle United), Thomson (Heart of Midlothian, captain), and McWilliam (Newcastle United), half-backs; Walker (Heart of Midlothian), Howie (Newcastle United), Young (Everton), Somers (Celtic), and G. Wilson (Heart of Midlothian), forwards.

THE EVERTON TEAM
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 28 March 1905
Yesterday the members of the Everton team, with the exception of Settle and Hardman, again visited Northwich, where they had brine baths as an aid to their preparations for the great replayed tie tomorrow with Aston Villa. Arrangements had been made for their descent into Baron’s Quay Salt Mine, but, instead, they drove to Winsford to join the early train to Liverpool, in order to witness the international match, England v Wales, at Anfield.
LIVERPOOL SECONDARY SCHOOLS CHALLENGE SHIELD
The final of the Liverpool Secondary Schools Challenge Sheid between Liverpool Institute and Liverpool College, to be played at Goodison park, has been postponed from tomorrow till the following Wednesday on account of the ground being otherwise occupied.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 28 March 1905
By Bee
The Everton team has been chosen, and is to be the same as on Saturday. The team leaves Liverpool to-night at 6.30 and will return to-morrow at 9.30 at the Great central Station. Again I would advise spectators not to take their watches and this avoid “lost time.” Several spectators at Stoke have reported to the police that their pockets had been picked. John Smith was remanded yesterday charged with stealing a gold watch, valued at £36, from the pocket of one spectator.
The City Ground, Nottingham was formerly a favourable locale for replayed semi-finals. The enclosure will comfortably hold 40,000 people and during the last two seasons, it has been vastly improved. A disastrous fire during last summer destroyed the whole of the big pavilion on the west side, but the new one which replaced it is probably the finest of its kind in the country. Thursday is the day set apart in Nottingham for the tradesmen’s half-holiday but the natives will doubtless patronise the match in large numbers.
Interviewed Howard Spencer said, “I think we shall win the replayed tie. I have never seen such confidence among the players as there exists at the present moment. Our forwards will not play the football they have shown during the last three months; but if they show their true form on Wednesday no defence in the world can hold them.” The view of the Everton captain, W. Balmer- very curiously the skipper of each side is the right back of his team- was very similar to that of Spencer, though applied to his own side instead of the Villa. He, too, thoughts his forwards had played below their club form, and in a less degree the criticism was true of the other departments. He believed that Everton would do better on Wednesday and assert their right to enter the final for the third time.
At five o’clock this evening Southport Central will receive a visit from the Everton team in the final for the Lancashire Cup. The Central team will be as follows;- Dent, goal; Spink and Rimmer, backs; Sinclair, Edmonds, and Chorlton, half-backs; Dawson, Shadbolt, Smith, Lawson, and Dawson, forwards. The trophy is now on view at Ellidge’s Eastbank-street and it is expected it will be presented to the winning team at the close of the match. Everton sends purely a reserve team.
A meeting of the Football League was held at the Alexandra Hotel, Liverpool, yesterday Mr. Bentley presiding. The dates of the Everton v Woolwich matches were left to the respective clubs, and their representatives having met subsequently fixed upon April 5 for the game at Goodison Park, and April 22 for the replayed match at Woolwich. The League ordered that Everton should play Notts Forest on Easter Monday.

LANCASHIRE CUP FINAL
Liverpool Daily Post - Wednesday 29 March 1905
SOUTHPORT CENTRAL v  EVERTON RESERVE
Last evening on the Scarisbrick-road ground, Southport, Southport Central and Everton met in the final for the Lancashire Cup. The Central team has done very well this season against Liverpool clubs. It drew with Everton Reserves at Everton, on September 17th, in the Lancashire Combination, with a score of 1 goal each; it beat Liverpool Reserves by 1 goal to nil in the Combination, on December 27th, it beat Everton Reserves in the return match, on January 2nd, by 2 goals to nil; it beat Liverpool Reserve with the same score on January 14th in the semi-final for the Lancashire Cup; and it beat Liverpool Reserves away on Saturday last by 3 goals to 2 in the Combination. Consequently the supporters of the Central team were very hopeful that they would be able to add another and still more important point to their list of victories, although the transfer of Garvey, their goalkeeper, to Bradford City had left them with a defence a little uncertain in quality. The attendance was quite up to anticipations, considering the rain which had fallen during the alteration, and the match being played on a week day. Although there were between 5,000 and 6,000 persons present. At five o’clock the team lined up as follows;-
Southport Central.- F. Dent, goal; F. Spink (captain), and J. Rimmer, backs; J. Sinclair, T. Edmonds, and F. Chorlton, half-backs; W. Dawson, J. Shadbolt, S. Smith, R.O. Lawson, and H. Danson, forwards.
Everton.- Scott, goal; R. Balmer and Wildman, backs; Ashworth, Booth, and Chadwick, half-backs; Rankin, McLoughlin, Roberts, Caldwell, and Dilly, forwards.
Referee Mr. J. Lewis, Blackburn.
Central losing the toss, were put to play against the wind. Smith started, and the ball was taken into Everton quarters, where Balmer returned. In the home half Chorlton and Edmonds did some useful work, and then Dawson getting possession made a nice run on the right. He centred beautiful, but the point was not improved upon and play verging again towards the home goal, Rimmer made a good return. The pressure by the visitors at this point was very great, and the defence was kept busy. Roberts put in a smart shot, which was safely dealt with. A corner followed, and after a little play in front of the home goal Dawson raced away and centred to Smith, who shot wide. The visitors’ forwards ran down the field, and Roberts shot over. Rimmer put in some useful defensive work, and Danson made a fine run on the left, the ball going over near the corner flag, Sinclair was fouled by Booth, and the ball was shot to Spink into the goalmouth where it was headed out. Lawson and Dawson were conspicuous on the left, where they were finally robbed by Wildman, but the home forwards stuck to their work, and were rewarded by Lawson heading through the first goal in beautiful style amid the enthusiastic cheers of the supports. On restarting Everton took up the running with a vengeance and put in some smart shots. They gained a corner which was well put in, and Chadwick shot over. The Everton left wing was pulled up for offside, but the ball was kept chiefly in the home half. Dawson made some progress on the right, where he was pulled up by Wildman and on the other wing Danson was ruled offside. This enabled the visitors to make a rush, and Chadwick put in a terrific shot which struck the upright. The home forwards made a capital run, and Smith and Lawson attacked with vigour. Scott partially cleared and Smith sent the ball into the net, giving Central a lead of two goals. Resuming play, the visiting forwards got well down, and Roberts shot over, yards too high. Lawson and Danson worked well on the home left, and gave Scott a chance to throw out. Half-time arrived with Central still leading by two to nil.
On changing ends Central had the advantage of the wind, but the opening exchanges were in the home half, and Dent fisted out a fine shot from the left. Spink put in a fine shot, and from Wildman’s return the Everton left raced away. Spink failed to stop the rush, though he might have passed to Dent, and Dilly scored with a grand shot. The Central forwards pressed strongly; Sinclair kicked over, and Shadbolt shot into Scott’s hands. Then Lawson called on Scott to throw out, from which the Everton right wing got away, and the Central defenders were kept busy for a time. Danson made a good shot at the Everton goal, and Scott tipped the ball over the bar. The corner kick was cleared, Danson, Spink and others had shots at goal, but Scott was causal to all emergences, though the pressure at times was very great. Play was taken into the home half, where Dilly was very noticeable for the speedy runs and smart shooting. Dawson took a flying kick at the Everton goal, and the shot just went outside. Smith got hurt, and for a time was not of much use, although some good opportunity presented themselves. Danson skimmed the bar after which Everton gained a couple of corners, the outcome of some smart work by Dilly and Caldwell. Danson had a couple of shots, at goal, Scott throwing out and on the second attempt the ball went just over. Occasionally Southport’s play was very erratic and without much cohesion. Then a pass from the left Rankin became dangerous but Chorlton robbed him in the nick of time. From the Central attacked, Dawson centred beautifully, and Lawson just missed a grand opportunity of scoring. Everton rushed away, and Edmonds cleared at a critical moment. Southport next attempt was represented by a shot by Smith, which went just over the bar, and then the whistle sounded for time, the score being Southport Central 2 goals Everton 1.
Immediately after the match the cup was presented by Mr. Woolfall, the president of the Lancashire Football Association, who complemented the Southport captain on the excellent of the team’s play. Speaking from an association point of view, he regretted that the he took place at a time when clubs were in much occupied, but he thought another year the association would make an effort to remedy that, because they considered that trophy ought to take front rank applause.

FOOTBALL ITEMS
Liverpool Daily Post - Wednesday 29 March 1905
The City Ground, Nottingham, was formerly a favourite locals for replayed semi-finals. The enclosure will comfortably hold 40,000 people, and during the last two seasons it has been vastly improved. A disastrous fire during last summer destroyed the whole of the big pavilion on the west side, but the new one which replaced it is probably the finest of its kind in the county. Thursday is the day set apart in Nottingham for the tradesmen’s half holiday, but the natives will doubtless patronise the match in large numbers.
Interviewed, Howard Spencer said. “I think we shall win the replayed tie. I have never seen such confidence among the players as there exists at the present moment. Our forwards will not play the football they have shown during the last three months, but if they show their true form on Wednesday best defence in the world can hold them.”
The view of the Everton captain, W. Balmer- very curiously the skipper of each side is the right back of the team-was very similar to that of Spencer, though applied to his own side instead of the Villa. He too, thought his forwards had played below their club form, and in a less degree the criticism was true of the other departments. He believed that Everton would do better on Wednesday, and assert their right to enter the final for the third time.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 29 March 1905
By Bee
Southport Central defeated Everton by 2 goals to nil, and won the Lancashire Senior Cup. Everton were represented by a reserve team, but Southport gave a fine display, and are to be congratulated on winning the trophy for the first time in the history of the club. The Everton forwards were very disappointing. Dilly and Rankin did not play up to reputation, and it was in the forward work that the Everton men were beaten Mr. D.B. Woolfall presented the cup to Fred Spink, the veteran captain of the Central, amidst much enthusiasm. Everton have played in five final ties and have been successful in three of them.

SECOND ATTEMPT
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 29 March 1905
TO-DAY’S RE-PLAYED SEMI-FINAL
EVERTON v  ASTON VILLA
GREAT GAME AT NOTTINGHAM
HAMPTON SCORES
VILLA LEAD AT HALF TIME
DEFEAT OF EVERTON
Everton and Aston Villa appeared to-day at the City Ground, Nottingham, to fight again their semi-final English Cup tie, which the stubborn game at Stoke on Saturday had left undecided. Today, if the ninety minutes struggle brought about no definite result, the encounter would be extended an extra half-hour.
The Nottingham enclosure has been the venue of semi-finals in days gone by, and will accommodate 40,000 spectators though nothing like the number was expected to-day, as Everton’s supporters could hardly be expected, however faithful, to leave business and make the long journey. The railway companies anticipated plenty of outside support, and offered facilities in the way of numerous excursions. An encouraging incident for Everton is the fact that Sharp and Young have been picked for the English v. Scotch match. Local supporters who journeyed down to the lace centre this morning did not allow their ardour to be damped by remembering that the Blues exhibited disappointing form at Stoke on Saturday. They argued, justly enough, that if their side was off colour and the Villa in form and yet unable to beat the Blues, then surely if Everton only did themselves justice to-day their chance of success was very evident. Everton’s weakness on Saturday was where least expected-particularly at back, and to some extent also in the half-back line; and there was every reason to hope that this faultiness would be effectually remedied to-day. As a matter of fact, in Saturday’s game both of the custodians played a gallant part, and a little bit of ill-luck either way might easily have won the game or lost it. More perfect custodianship has seldom been witnessed, and George must have stopped a full score of dangerous shots.
The home supporters although admitting the prowess of the Villa, were probably imbued with the spirit of F.E.H., who writes;-
The hardy mariner who steers
  His barque twixt Charybdis and Scylla
Has lesser reason for his fears
   Than they who go to fight the Villa.
Yet Everton, with stern intent,
And eager eyes upon the Chalice,
Will make the battle by the Trent
A stepping stone towards the Palace
Hardman, although damaged at Stoke, showed he was none the worse by his plucky and smart performance on Monday in the international match at Anfield. The Everton executive saw no reason to make any change in the team, nor, indeed, did the Villa, and the men turned out as at Stoke. Everton left Liverpool at 6.60 last night for Nottingham. The teams;-
Everton.- L.R. Roose; Balmer (captain) and Crelly; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P. Hardman.
Aston Villa.- George; Spencer (captain) and Miles; Pearson, Leake, and Wilkes; Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall.
The floods of the night luckily gave way to a morning of brilliant sunshine, and the journey to Nottingham was made under the most delightful conditions. The Midlanders were as much indebted to Jupiter Pluvius as those on the banks of the Mersey, and there was every prospect this morning of the ground drying up nicely, and the game being fought out under capital conditions. There was not nearly so much local enthusiasm as might have been expected, but this was accounted for by the feeble show so far made by the two Notts clubs. There was a further fact. Thursday is the half holiday, and not Wednesday. The Everton team arrived safely last night, and put up at the Victoria Station Hotel where they took matters easy. Nothing unusual was observable in Nottingham up to noon but at two-o’clock there was palpable evidence of the arrival of numerous excursions. The Villa, who had been staying at Rhyl since Saturday night made one alteration. Wilkes being substituted at left back in place of Windmill, who was indisposed. Apart from the alteration, the teams were exactly the same as at Stoke. When the players turned out there were fully 25,000 people present, and they were still trooping in. Mr. Kingscott of Derby, was the referee- the same as on Saturday. The gate for the popular side had to be closed ten minutes before the start. Spencer won the toss, and decided to attack the Bridgford goal with the sun and a slight breeze behind him. The Villa early became aggressive, but Balmer dispossessed Bache neatly and some clever manoeuvring by the Everton right wing saw Sharp centre with capital judgement, but Leake got his head in the way, and performed a similar service, directly afterwards when Miles gained a corner, to keep McDermott out. Anticipating a long pass from Garratty, Hall landed Balmer and dropped him. A taking centre to Bache’s shot cannoned back off Taylor, and after this Everton confined the game for a while to midfield. Miles was settled finely when he was making for goal at a tremendous pace, and the Everton forwards returned with some very pretty passing. Young was penalised for a foul charge. Following this foul against Miles, Hall worked through to essay a fast grounder, which travelled a couple of yards wide of the mark. Another burst by the Aston left wing furnished shot, but Roose, leaving his goal, cleared with ease. A characteristic dribble and centre by Brawn aroused some enthusiasm, but Hampton was ruled offside as he shot at the keeper, and a rapid movement on the Everton left won a corner out of Pearson, which Spencer cleared. So far Everton had done very well, and their form raised hopes in the breasts of their supporters. There was plenty of spirit and dash in their attack, and Balmer seemed to have regained his coolness in defence. Brawn initiated another promising movement and Hall forced a passage, only to be swept off his legs by Balmer just outside the penalty area. No capital was made out of the free kick, but the Villa were much more the aggressive side. In the course of another spirited advance Balmer blundered terribly in trying to intercept a pass from Brawn, and running in Hampson had no difficulty in beating Roose when the game had been in progress sixteen minutes. The Villa pressed steadily, and Balmer was penalised for a deliberate trip against Hampton, when the centre seemed to have a clear course. Nothing came of the free kick, however, and when the Everton forwards at last moved down in line Settle put the ball forward to George very finely, but the keeper cleared without any trouble. A
Pretty individual effort by Young carried him through but Miles managed to deflect his shot, and following the flag kick Crelley went a foot too high with a neat drive from long range. Villa swept back in capital formation, and after Brawn had lifted the ball well in front Bache furnished Hampton with a fine opening, only to see the centre shoot the wrong side of the post. Sturdy play by Young placed the Birmingham goal in jeopardy, but he lost the chance by dallying, and when the Villa returned to the attack, Bache was absolutely offside. The Everton supporters were sorely disappointed at Balmer’s display, which was a repetition of Saturday’s and they were also keenly disappointed that Young had not taken advantage of the splendid opportunity to equalise. The Everton left wing were now instrumental in changing the scene, and Settle got in a fine centre almost off the line, but George fielded it admirably, and the Villa forwards attacked again in fine style, only to see Bache miss the mark with practically an open goal. The Villa continued to hold the upper hand, and after a temporary stoppage through an injury to Hampton, who came into violent collision with Crelley Roose applied a swinging fist to a big header from Bache. Except for the occasion on which Hardman worked through and tested George with a fine try Everton rarely got dangerous the game for the most part being entirely confined to their quarters. From a free kick against Settle for tripping Pearson the Everton goal had a very narrow escape, Roose clearing after Hampton and Bache had both failed in an attempt to reach a centre from Hall. Following upon this Brawn ran down the wing and shot right into the goalmouth from a very difficult angle, but Balmer diverted the ball around the post at the expense of a corner, which was without result.
A moment later half-time arrived, the score then standing –
Aston Villa 1 goal, Everton nil.
There could be no mistaking the fact that the Birmingham team had shown superior football, and it was quite evident that unless Everton showed very much improved form in the latter half their chances of travelling to the Crystal Palace were exceedingly remote. Among the great crowd of spectators the preponderating element was obviously in favour of the Villa’s chances, and they cheered lustily as the claret and blue left the arena. When the game was resumed Everton attacked and forced a corner on the right, but Hardman shot into the side of the net from the corner kick. Following upon this there was some exceedingly pretty passing between Bache and Hall, thus enabling the latter to race through from a rather suspiciously offside position, and from his centre Garratty nipping in and scored a second goal after Hampton had missed the ball. This success came within two minutes of the restart and it naturally put the Birmingham contingent on the best of terms with themselves. Young broke through, but was easily pulled up by Miles and the Villa soon attacked desperately, Balmer hooking the ball out from almost underneath the bar, when Hampton and Bache both dashed in. a better understanding between the Everton forwards gave them a footing in their opponents’ quarters, but they met with a very stubborn resistance, and were rarely allowed to get within shooting range. Hardman dealt weakly with a corner conceded by Spencer, and Leake stopped Settle and Young very cleverly when they were heading for goal in ominous fashion. The Goodison Park forwards, moving in greater precision again failed to make any capital out of the corner, and Hampton was whistled offside as he ran forward to take a pass from Brawn. Everton began to attack in spirited fashion, and pressing most persistently, George had to dispose of a magnificent shot from Sharp, Abbott again set his forwards moving in beautiful fashion, and a fine piece of manoeuvring ended in Leake relieving the Villa line. Hardman, however, returned to the attack, and threading his way through centred well, but without result. A moment later a second centre was put in by the little amateur and Sharp taking the ball hooked it into the net, well out of the reach of the custodian. This success came after the second half had been in progress twenty minutes, and of course it infused new life and vigour into the Everton players, who now began to assert themselves and enjoy rather the better of the game. A brillaint run by Brawn brought relief to the Villa but a long drive from Hall blew straight across the goal and from the goal kick the Everton forwards rushed straight down in line and delivered attack after attack the Villa goal. Twice George had to give corners in dealing with short straight shots from McDermott and Young and from the last of these a terrific scrimmage ensued in front of the Villa goal. Bache hooking the ball almost off the goal line. Nothing daunted the Goodison Park forwards spurted back, and there was another exciting visit to the Villa goal, George again being compelled to give a corner, when McDermott was almost through. Following the corner kick the Liverpudlians experienced the worst of luck. Young and Settle both seeing their shots cannoned on the back of the opposing defenders. There was no mistaking the superiority of Everton. It was such that the Villa defence was fairly pressed to check their determined adversaries. On another occasion McDermott and Young forced a passage, but Miles breaking in at top speed took the ball right off the centre forward’s toe. Final- Aston Villa 2, Everton 1
THE GATE
No fewer than 34,843 people paid for admission.
SCENE AT THE “ECHO” OFFICE
AN AMUSING MISUNDERSTANDING
A large number of persons assembled in Victoria-street this afternoon under the impression that the results of the scores of the Cup-tie, Everton v. Aston Villa “would be flashed every few minutes.” This was owing to an unfortunate misreading of an announcement in the “Echo,” which stated as plainly as possible that the scores every few minutes would be flashed “to” the “Echo” office. Flashlights are not usually employed as a means of communication from distant places during the day, and it is difficult to understand how any person of intelligence could have imagined that the flashes meant anything but electrical flashes, or the use of ordinary telegraphic communication especially as it was so clearly enunciated that the results were to be “flashed to the office,” and not from any part of the building. The Education Committee would do well to look to the results of educational effort.

ENGLISH CUP
Liverpool Evening Express - Wednesday 29 March 1905
REPLAYED SEMI-FINAL
EVERTON v ASTON VILLA
EVERTONIANS OUTCLASSED
VILLA IN GRAND FORM AND LEADING AT HALF-TIME
EVERTON WERE BELOW PAR.
Glorious weather prevailed for the replayed Semi-final tie in the English Cup competition at Nottingham to-day. Probably it was more favourable to the spectators than to the players, for the brilliant sun was bound to bother the players to some extent. Still the sunshine was very welcome after the recent visitations of rain. That exceptional interest was taken in the replay between two such famous clubs as Everton and Aston Villa was evidenced from the numbers of people who poured into the Lace Capital from all parts of the country. Speculation was rife as to the outcome of the match, the majority of people in Nottingham favouring the Villa's chances. Still it was borne in mind that at Stoke on Saturday, when each side scored a goal, the Villa were pretty well at the top of their form, while Everton were below par.
That Everton could play two such games consecutively was considered out of the question by those who were anxious to see them visit the Crystal Palace. This, however, was a matter to be decided on the field of play. A large number of people travelled from Liverpool by the Great Central and Midland Companies’ trains, among the noted football figures being Mr. John McKenna and Mr. Tom Watson. The ground of the Nottingham Forest is well adapted for a big Cup tie. There is adequate stand accommodation, and, moreover, the playing pitch could hardly be improved upon. To-day, in spite of the rain, the ground looked its best. The Everton players arrived in Nottingham last night, but the Villa did not put in an appearance until this morning. Everton relied upon the same team as last Saturday, but one change was made on the Villa side, Wilkes taking the place of Windmill, who had not been well since Saturday’s match. The Villa were the first to turn out on the field to-day, and they were loudly cheered, and Everton five minutes later came in for an equally cordial reception. The teams were as follows:—
Everton: L. R. Roose, goal; Balmer (captain) and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H. P. Hardman, forwards. . Aston Villa: George, goal; Spencer (captain) and Miles, backs; Pearson, Leake, and Wilkes, half-backs; Brawn, Garrity, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards.
The Villa won the toss, and had the advantage of playing with the sun at their backs. Hampton passed over to the left wing and endeavoured to centre, but Crelly cleared. Everton got down on the right, and after a stoppage had occurred in order that another ball might be obtained they FORCED A CORNER. Sharp took the kick, but it came to nothing. The Villa got away, and Hampton, Bache, and Hall were responsible for a pretty movement. Balmer, however, was in fine form and robbed his opponents. Still the Villa were more prominent, and all tricked Balmer, whose mistake, however, did not scarcely affect his side. A moment later Balmer intercepted a hot shot, and then, after smart tackling by Taylor, Young raced off. His career was not of long duration, and the next item of interest was Abbott being fouled. The free kick was not utilised, and Hall dashed along the wing, only to be pulled up by Balmer. The stiff breeze was all against Everton. Twice Wilkes stopped rushes by the Everton left wing, and then Sharp receiving from McDermott was pulled up by Miles. Everton were now improving, and Young nearly got through. Miles was too good for him, and a free kick to the Villa changed the scene of hostilities. Pearson initiated a pretty move, and Baché, receiving from Hall, shot yards wide. A series of throws-in near the half-way line ended in Bache shooting, Roose being forced to leave his charge and clearing nicely from Hampton. Settle next gave to Young, who was no match for Miles. The Villa forwards broke away on the right. Brawn centred beautifully, and Hampton had a clear course. Roose cleared his shot just as the whistle blew for offside. This was the most rousing movement so far. Young forced a corner smartly from Spencer, but nothing accrued. Sharp got well away on the right. Then, coming down in great style, the Villa were awarded a free kick not many yards from the Everton goal, McDermott sending clear.. Resuming the attack, Taylor clean missed the ball, but Balmer cleared. The Villa were still in a dangerous mood. Garrity SCORED FOR THE VILLA after fifteen minutes’ play. The goal was the outcome of Balmer missing his kick. Garratty raced on with only Roose to beat, and he accomplished his task with ease. The point was received with unbounded delight, and on the play the Villa deserved their success. They were playing the more consistent game. Settle had a chance, but instead of passing out to the left he shot weakly at George, who cleared with ease. The Villa continued their aggressive tactics, but Sharp brought relief with a run down the right. Pearson was responsible for a smart clearance on the left, but Balmer cleared a centre from Brawn. Young beat Leake and forced a corner, from which Crelly sent in a high dropping shot which just shaved the crossbar. This was a capital effort, which was deservedly applauded. A free kick to Everton was well placed in the goal mouth by Balmer, the ball, however, being headed over the line by Abbott. By this time the ground was packed to its utmost capacity, which would represent an attendance of 35,000 people. At any rate, people were turned away from the gates. The Villans came down with a rush on the left, but Balmer kicked out. From the throw-in Roose had to fist clear. Brawn was penalised for pushing Hardman, but the Villa came again, and Hampson JUST MISSED THE POST, while a moment later Brawn in trying to centre sent the ball out of the ground. There was no denying that the Villa so far were the smartest side. Their halves prevented the Everton forwards getting into their stride. Moreover, one or two of the players did not forget to use their weight. Young receiving from Settle looked-liked scoring, but found his way barred by Spencer. The game continued to be of a fast and exciting character, and the ball went from end to end with great speed. Roose was called upon to handle by Bache, his task, however, was not a difficult one. It was quite a relief to the Everton portion of the spectators when Hardman and Settle indulged in some pretty passing. Pearson kicked into touch, and following a throw-in Settle put in a grand centre, which George dealt with in a masterly fashion. Away went the Villa again, and Crelly was just in the nick of time when he took the ball from the toe of Bache. A moment later Hall flashed the ball the wrong side of the upright. Play slackened down somewhat, and A FREE KICK TO EVERTON resulted in a combined attack by the Everton forwards, which Hardman ended in giving George a hot one, which he dealt with capably. Hampton was heavily grassed near the Everton goal, but soon recovered amid applause. An enterprising snap-shootist was at once in evidence, and created some amusement among the crowd. The Villa continued to press, their concerted methods  contrasting with the straggling play of the Evertonians, who were showing even to less advantage than at Stoke. Perhaps it was the wind and sun in some degree. In any rate this was the hope of their supporters. Settle was penalised, and from the free kick a most exciting scrimmage occurred in the Everton goalmouth. Roose’s tall frame came to the rescue of his side, and when he fisted clear, surrounded by his opponents, he was loudly cheered. The Villa, however, were in a most aggressive mood, and the Everton goal had a narrow escape, the ball going over the bar by one of their own players. The corner came to nothing, and just as Balmer had taken a free kick the whistle blew for the interval. Half-time Aston Villa 1 Everton 0
The wind was stronger than it appeared to be from the press box, and the sun had played a great part in the fortunes of the teams in the opening half. At the same time it must be conceded the Villa were deserving of their goal lead. They were nippier on the ball than the Evertonians, and were especially well served by the halves, who broke up all attempts at a combined game on the part of the Everton front line, unless the wind and sun made all the difference. Everton’s chances of figuring at the Crystal Palace looked very dismal. After a longer interval than usual the teams were restarted at half-past four. The Villa broke away, but were soon repulsed. McDermott compelled Miles to kick out, Everton showed up better, and Hardman had bad luck in shooting past the post. Suddenly Hall dashed off and dropped the ball in the goalmouth. Hampton missed it, but Garrity seized the opportunity and scored the VILLA’S SECOND GOAL. This success was unexpected as it was unpalatable to the Everton contingent. Although the Blues raced away the Villa for a time were all over their opponents, and the Everton defenders seemed to loose their heads, and another goal was likely when Abbott effected a timely clearance. The Everton forwards tried hard to change the fortunes of the game, but they could do nothing right. Sharp was easily robbed, and the Villa had more of the play than their opponents. Spencer was forced by Young to concede a corner, but Hardman failed to put it to account, sending the ball the wrong side of the upright. The Villa were distinctly playing a winning game. The Everton forwards were very weak in front of goal, and were time after time beaten by the Villa halves and backs. At the other end Hall shot in strongly. Roose kicked away and next a SCORE FOR EVERTON. Sharpe scored for Everton after seventeen minutes.
Final Result Aston Villa two goals, Everton one goal.

EXTRAORDINARY SEQUEL TO INTERNATIONAL.
Dundee Evening Post - Thursday 30 March 1905
EVERTON GOALKEEPER STRIKES ' IRISH CHAIRMAN.
A hitherto unreported incident which occurred after the international match between Scotland and Ireland at Glasgow on Saturday, the 18th inst., has developed such an extent that the matter cannot any longer be kept a secret. It seems the Irish goalkeeper, while in a discussion with Mr. Chairman of the Irish Association, certain financial matters, struck the latter official a heavy blow in the face with his clenched fist. The Irish Association, having privately discussed the affair, have officially reported the entire facts to the committee of the Football Club, which the player in question belongs. It is almost certain the same individual will never again be chosen in Irish international team.

ASTON VILLA 2 EVERTON 1 (Fac Game 51)
March 30, 1905. The Liverpool Courier
Fa Cup Semi-Final Replay
EVERTON UNLUCKY
Glorious weather prevailed for the replayed semi-final tie in the English Cup competition at Nottingham yesterday. Probably it was more favourable to the spectators than to the players, for the brilliant sun was bound to bother the players to some extent. Still the sunshine was very welcome after the recent visitations of rain. That exceptional interest was taken in the replay between the two such famous clubs as Everton and Aston Villa was evidenced from the numbers of people who poured into the Lace capital from all parts of the county. Speculation was rife as to the outcome of the match, the majority of people in Nottingham favouring the Villa's chances. Still it was borne in mind that at Stoke on Saturday, when each side scored a goal, the Villa were pretty well at the top of their form, while Everton were below par. Those who were anxious to see then visit the Crystal Palace considered that Everton could play two such games consecutively out of the question. This however, was a matter to be decided on the field of play. A large number of people travelled from Liverpool by the Great Central and Miland Companies' trains among the noted football figures being Mr.John McKenna and Tom Watson. The ground of the Nottingham Forest is well adapted for a big cup tie. There is adequate stand accommodation, and, moreover, the playing pitch could hardly be improved upon. Yesterday in spite of the rain, the ground looked its best. The Everton players arrived at Nottingham on Tuesday, but the Villa did not put in an appearance until yesterday morning. Everton relied upon the same team as last Saturday, but one change was made on the Villa side, Wilkes taking the place of Windmill, who had not been well since Saturday's match. The Villa were the first to turn out on the field, and they were loudly cheered, and Everton five minutes later came in for an equally cordial reception. The teams were as Follows: - Everton: - L.R.Roose, goal, W.Balmer (captain), and Crelly, backs, Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott half-backs, Sharp McDermott, Young Settle, and H.P Hardman, forwards. Aston Villa: - George goal, Spencer, and Miles, backs, Pearson, Leake, and Wilkes, half-backs Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards . The Villa won the toss and had the advantage of playing with the sun at their's backs. Hampton passed over to the leftwing and endeavored to centre, but Crelly cleared. Everton got down on the right, and after a stoppage had occurred in order that another ball might be obtained they forced a corner. Sharp took the kick, but it came to nothing. The Villa got away, and Hampton, Bache, and Hall, were responsible for a pretty movement. Balmer however, was in fine form, and robbed his opponents. Still the Villa were the more prominent, and Hall tricked Balmer, whose mistake however, did not seriously affect his side. As moment later Balmer intercepted a hot shot and then smart tackling by Taylor, Young raced off. His career was not of long duration, and the next item of interest was Abbott being fouled. The free kick was not utilised and Hall dashed along the wing, only to be pulled up by Balmer. The stiff breeze was all against Everton. Twice Wilkes stopped rushes by the Everton left wing, and then Miles pulled up Sharp receiving from McDermott. Everton were now improving, and Young nearly got through. Miles was too good for him, and a free kick to the Villa changed the scene of hostilities. Pearson initiated a pretty move, and Bache receiving from Hall, shot yards wide. A series of thrown in near the half-way line ended in Bache shooting, Roose being forced to leave his charge, clearing nicely from Hampton. Settle next gave to Young, who, was no match for Miles. The Villa forwards broke away on the right. Brawn centred beautifully, and Hampton had a clear course, Roose cleared his shot just as the whistle blew for offside. This was the most rousing movement so far. Young forced a corner smartly from Spencer, but nothing accrued Sharp got well away on the right, but his centre was cleared, and coming down in great style, the Villa were awarded a free kick, not many yards from the Everton goal, McDermott sending clear. Resuming the attack, Taylor clean missed the ball, but Balmer cleared. The Villa were still in a dangerous mood, and Garratty scored for them after fifteen minutes' play. The goal was the outcome of Balmer missing his kick. Garratty raced on with only Roose to beat, and he accomplished his task with ease. The point was received with unbounded delight, and on the play the Villa deserved their success. They were playing the more consistent game. Settle had a chance, but instead of passing out to the left he shot weakly at George, who cleared with ease. The Villa continued their aggressive tactics, but Sharp brought relief with a good run down the wing. Pearson was responsible for a smart clearance on the left, but Balmer cleared a centre from Brawn. Young beat Leake and forced a corner, from which Crelly sent in a high dropping shot, which just shaved the crossbar. This was a capital effort, which was deservedly applauded. A free kick to Everton was well placed in the goalmouth by Balmer, the ball, however, being headed over the line by Abbott. The Villians came down with a rush on the left, but Balmer kicked out. From the thrown-in Roose had to fist clear. Brawn was penalised for pushing Hardman, but the Villa came again, and Hardman just missed the post, while a moment later Brawn in trying to centre, sent the ball out of the ground. There was no denying that the Villa so far were the smarter side. Their halves prevented the Everton forwards getting into their stride. Moreover, one or two of the players did not forget to use their weight. Young receiving from Settle looked like scoring, but found his way parried by Spencer. The game continued to be of a fast, and exciting character, and the ball went from end to end with great speed. Roose was called upon to handle by Bache his task, however, was not a difficult one. It was quite a relief to the Everton portion of the spectators when Hardman and Settle indulged in some pretty passing. Pearson kicked into touch, and following a throw in Settle put in a grand centre, which George dealt with in masterly fashion. Away went the Villa again, and Crelly was just in the nick of time when he took the ball from the toe of Bache. A moment later Hall finished the ball the wrong side of the upright. Play slackened down somewhat, and a free kick to Everton resulted in a combined attack by the visiting forwards which Hardman ended in giving George a hot one, which he dealt with capably. Hampton was heavily grassed near the Everton goal, but soon recovered amid applause. Settle was penalised, and from the free kick a most exciting scrimmage occurred in the Everton goalmouth. Roose's tall frame came to the rescue of his side, and when he fisted clear, surrounded by his opponents, he was loudly cheered. The Villa, however, were in a most aggressive mood, and the Everton goal had a narrow escape, the ball going over the bar by one of their own players. The corner came to nothing, and justed as Balmer had taken a free kick the whistle blew for the interval. Half-time Aston Villa 1, goal Everton nil.
The wind was stronger than it appeared to be from the press box, and the sun had played a great part in the fortune of the teams in the opening half. At the same time it must be conceded the Villa were deserving of their goal lead. They were nipper on the ball than the Evertonians, and were especially well served by the halves, who broke up all attempts at a combined game on the part of the Everton front line. After a longer interval than usual the teams were restarted at half-past four. The Villa broke away, but were soon repulsed. McDermott compelled Miles to kick out, Everton showed up better, and Hardman had bad luck in shooting past the post. Suddenly Hall dashed off and dropped the ball in the goalmouth, Hampton missed it, but Garratty seized the opportunity and scored, the Villians second goal. This success was as unexpected as it was unpalatable to the Everton contingent. Although the Blues raced away the Villa for a time were all over their opponents, and the Everton defenders seemed to off their heads, and another goal appeared likely when Abbott effected a timely clearance. The Everton forwards tried hard to change the fortune of the game, but they could do nothing right. Sharp was easily robbed, and the Villa had more of the play than their opponents Spencer was forced by Young to concede a corner, but Hardman failed to put it to account, sending the ball the wrong side of the upright. The Villa were distinctly playing a winning game. The Everton forwards were very weak in front of goal, and time after time beaten by the Villa halves, and Hampton shot over at lighting speed. Everton forced play on the left, a fruitless corner being the only reward. A moment later from a neat pass by McDermott, both Young and Settle had a grand chance of shooting but owing to a misunderstanding neither took a kick, and Taylor propelled the ball high over the bar. Then Everton put in their best attack of the day, and George repelled in brilliant style, a grand attempt by McDermott. For some time the Villa defence was hard pressed, and ultimately the goal was captured. The Everton forwards and halves played more like themselves, and after exciting exchanges in the goalmouth Sharp secured and defeated George with a beautiful shot, the ball sailing into the net just underneath the bar. This success imparted increased life into the game, each side being visited in turn. Roose saved a couple of fine shots and then Everton again hotly assailed the Villa goal, which had two or three remarkable escapes. Everton undoubtedly were making magnificent efforts to save the situation. Corner after corner fell to them as the result of splendid determination, which deserved to be rewarded. A grand attempt by Sharp led to a corner, which was followed by a another, the ball bobbing about the Villa goalmouth. No praise could be too high for the Everton men, the effort at this period of the game. They were all over the Villa and them grand efforts earned unstinted applause. The excitement was at fever heat, and it was felt that if Everton could maintain such extraordinary pressure they would be rewarded. The Villa defenders were very stubborn, and survived many trying ordeals. Hall created a temporary diversion, but Everton were soon back again, Harassing played up with splendid spirit. Following a clever piece of tackling by Balmer, Sharp forced Miles to grant a corner, from which the ball dropped in front of George. It was headed from one player to another, but into the net it could not be sent. It ever a team deserved to equalise Everton did. Luck was against them. Wilkes handled justed outside the penalty area, but Everton did not turn the free kick to advantage. Everton had all the best of the finish, but had to retire defeated. They certainly deserved to equalise on account of their wonderful exhibition during the greater portion of the second half. Result Aston Villa 2, Everton 1.
COMMENTS ON THE GAME.
Everton were decidedly unlucky to loss. They might have drawn, and might as easily have won if fortune had favoured them. Still they cannot always have the luck. In the first half their display was decidedly below par, and the ineffectiveness of the attack was mainly due, apart from the disadvantage of having to face the sun, and to contend against the vagaries of the wind to the wonderful skill and tenacity of the Villa half backs, who never allowed the forwards to enter upon any sort of combination which could be turned to profitable account. After the Villa obtained their second goal a couple of minutes from the restart. Everton looked absolutely a beaten team. Suddenly they pulled themselves together, and rarely if ever has a finer example been given of plucky determination to pull the game out of the fire. About half an hour the contest received itself into a continual bombardment of the Villa goal. Corner after corner was forced, but only tangible success was the beautiful goal which Sharp registered. Time and again the Villa defence seemed to be tied in knots, but with George closely attended by half his side, and with Leake in particular, here there, and everywhere, the ball could not be forced into the net. Although beaten Everton supporters have the satisfaction of knowing that their team in the later stages of the game made one of the most marvellous efforts to stem the tide of misfortune which has been witnessed in an important football match.

VILLA IN THE FINAL
Daily News (London) - Thursday 30 March 1905
MAGNIFICENT EFFORT BY EVERTON TO SAVE THE GAME
The groat struggle between Aston Villa and Everton is over, and it is the former, and not favourites for the Cup, who will meet Newcastle United in the final at the Crystal Palace on April 15th. I ventured to prophesy in Monday’s issue that yesterday’s replayed semi-final between the stalwarts of Lancashire and the Midlands would live in history, and in that, at least, I will surely not be denied. Judged upon the whole ninety minutes of its course, the game was inferior in quality to the one at Stoke, but it provided one of the greatest finishes within memory. Had the play continued as it began, the match would have been handed down to posterity as a huge disappointment, but a magnificent effort, after losing two goals and appearing to be hopelessly beaten, Everton once more proved themselves one the finest aggressive teams which were ever moulded. For once, however, they failed in their endeavour to turn almost certain defeat into thrilling victory, but that failure does not detract in the least from their excellence. Within minute of the resumption after the interval came along the Villa’s second goal. Up to that moment the leaders had been immeasurably the better team, without having approached their form of Saturday. From that moment to the end Everton smote their opponents hip and thigh, their halves crushing the life out of the Villa attack, and their forwards overwhelming the defence to the goal line. Their only reward was one really brilliant goal, and, of course, that availed them nothing. They retired beaten in the result, but with the honours of the day thick upon them.
A TAME FIRST HALF
The first half was unworthy lengthy description, the play of both elevens being considerably below concert pitch. As I have indicated the Villa were the better team and fully deserved lead of one goal at the interval; but the disadvantages which Everton had laboured under were not realised until the Birmingham team had to contend with them in the second half. A glaring sun blinded the Everton players whenever the ball was in the air, and a high wind helped the Villa not a little. It should be stated that the only change in the teams from the first game was Wilkes for Windmill on the left the Villa half-back line, the latter being reported indisposed. Over anxiety accounted for the early shortcomings. Hardman and Brawn shooting tamely behind for their respective sides. Only eighteen minutes had gone before the Villa were leading. It was a point discreditable Crelly, the Everton left back, for with plenty time to steady himself he completely missed the ball thirty yards from his goal, and before he could recover Hampton, who was abreast of him at the time, had flashed ahead. Gaining possession well out of reach his pursuers the young Villa centre, keeping a cool head, made bee line for goal, and when Roose rushed out in an attempt to confuse him—the only thing the custodian could do under the circumstances—he slipped the ball into the net with admirable judgment. Crelly was directly responsible for Everton's disaster. It was not his first blunder, nor it his last, and Balmer was equally unreliable the Villa, playing the better midfield game all the while, had several openings presented to them before the interval; but they finished so badly that Roose was given very little do. On the other hand, the Villa defence was sound as rock, thanks largely to the activity of their halves, and, incidentally, to the repeated mispassing of the Everton forwards. Settle, above all others, being a sorry offender. Sharp and Hardman on the extreme wings rarely got the ball, and the three inside men could make impression.
EVERTON’S AWAKENING
The reopening was sensational, in that Hardman nearly scored for Everton, and Garratty actually did in the first minute. Brawn initiated the latter attack with clever run, during which not only tricked Balmer. but he contrived draw the Everton defenders upon himself before placing across to be met by Hampton and Garratty, who had kept in line with him. Crelley made no attempt to reach either of his opponents, but, getting the ball first, Hampton was so hurried that he missed the ball in front of Roose. Not so Garratty. who fired high and obliquely into the left corner of the net. Roose having no chance whatever. Any other team but Everton would have given up the ghost. Put not so the Light Blues. They had saved themselves for the second half, and gradually they gained mastery over their opponents. The real revival came with thirty five minutes to go, and in that time they gave the Villa defenders more work to do than they can have had in the whole the previous rounds of the competition. The game resolved itself into one long-sustained bombardment of George’s charge. George was the hero of the siege. Abbott was the first to show his paces with a forced run past four opponents, then placing to Settle, and from Hardman’s cross. Sharp tested the Villa goalkeeper with a magnificent volley, Abbott next dropping the ball into George’s hands. There was isolated breakaway by the Villa, which Hall ended with a cross shot, only Just wide. Everton returned to their guns, and the ball was fired in upon George and beaten out often that it would be impossible to relate each incident. For the most part George was content to throw or kick behind his own lines for momentary relief, but at length he was beaten. Settle had the first finger in the pie, and unselfishly fed his partner, who dropped the ball perfectly into goal, and Settle, taking it on the run, reduced the Villa’s lead with wonderful left shot. As the pressure continued, an equaliser was considered inevitable. Spencer and Miles were run off their legs, and even Leake was hard put to it to keep pace with the determined attackers, whilst Wilkes and Pearson were seldom to be seen. Bache and Garratty fell back into their own penalty area, and rendered valuable assistance in the staving off of the invaders, but it was George who did most work with his fists, and he was never happier than when conceding corners. Nor did the backs and halves hesitate to kick the ball far out of play. Mr. Kingscott twice having to take time off to defeat their object, which was, of course, waste time. But by hook and by crook the defence prevailed. All honour the Villa for withstanding such a terrible onslaught. That they were lucky to survive no one will gainsay. Once, from a corner kick, when George was being sorely tried, Everton stoutly claimed that the ball had entered the net, and it certainly appeared to me to have crossed the line, but Mr. Kingscott was in far better position for Judging, and he would have none of the suggestion.
HONOUR TO THE LOSERS.
Everton are entitled much sympathy in their hour of defeat. They made a gallant fight Yet they were poorly represented full-back, and it was here they were badly let down. Balmer and Crelly always displayed bad judgment when rushed, and the kicking of the pair, even when unattended, left much to be desired, whilst both the Villa’s goals were traceable to their weakness. Makepeace was the most consistent of the halves, though Abbott was the one to shine after the interval. Taylor, as at Stoke, was not nearly so effective usual. The form of the forwards may be quickly criticised. In the first half, against the sun, it was execrable; in the second it was brilliant, and each man must take his share of blame and praise. George was undoubtedly the saviour the Villa. The backs opened admirably, but tired during the siege. Leake was easily the most effective half, and Hampton and Bache were the pick of clever forward line. The Notts Forest ground was well chosen for the game in every respect, and the day being beautifully fine there was a rare mid-week crowd, 24.845 people paying for admission, whilst hundreds were refused admission. The receipts amounted to £1,439 s.

ENGLISH CUP REPLAYED SEMI-FINAL
Birmingham Daily Post - Thursday 30 March 1905
ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
The semi-final tie in the English Cup competition between Aston Villa and Everton having been left drawn at Stoke on Saturday last, the teams met again yesterday on the ground of Nottingham Forest. The weather was beautifully fine, and there was a magnificent attendance. As was the case on Saturday a number of special trains were run from the Birmingham and the Liverpool districts, and both teams had large numbers of supporters present, who did not forget to make their presence heard. Everton were able to place in the field the eleven that represented them at Stoke, but it was found necessary to make one alteration in the Villa team. Windmill was indisposed, and it was deemed wise to play Wilkes in his place. The teams, therefore, were as follows;-
Aston Villa.- George, goal; Spencer (captain) and Miles, backs; Pearson, Leake, and Wilkes, half-backs; Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards.
Everton.- Roose, goal; Balmer (captain) and Crelley, backs; Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott,  Young, Settle, and Hardman, forwards.
Referee; Mr. A. Kingscott, Derby.
The ground was in beautiful condition, and everything was favourable for a fast game. Spencer won the toss and decided to defend the goal near Trent Bridge. His side thus enjoyed the advantage of playing with the sun at their backs. Everton were the first to attack, and they quickly forced a corner. The ball was admirably placed by Sharp, but Leake cleared, and the next moment saw the Villa aggressive, and Hall, centreing accurately, it appeared probable that Hampton would secure an opening. He was, however, prevented from doing so by the backs, and the next moment the ball was in the Villa half. The Everton forwards were unable to make any impression on the defence, and Hall was then prominent for some smart work on the left wing. The defence, however, prevailed, and during the next few minutes Miles was given the opportunity to distinguish himself, and was not found wanting. So far neither goalkeeper had been tested, but Roose was now called upon to save a long shot from Hall. He gathered the ball easily, and, eluding Hampton’s rush, cleared in efficient style, and the Everton forwards, displaying nice combination, forced a corner, which was unproductive. Some fine work on the part of Brawn was spoiled by Hampton getting offside, but the outside right centred the ball a few moments, later, and Crelley failing to head it Hampton ran close in and easily beat Roose. The goal was scored eighteen minutes from the start, and was well deserved, for the Villa had been quicker on the ball, and had played more effective football than their opponents. A rush by Everton was finished by Settle kicking the ball straight to George, and another attempt was terminated by Crelley shooting over the bar. The Everton forwards were clever, but they lacked dash. They required time also to gather the ball, and frequently allowed the keen half-backs of the opposing side to rob them of it. They did not threaten as much danger when they attacked as did the Villa forwards, who passed accurately and quickly, and went straight for goal whenever they obtained the opportunity. The consequence was that Roose had far more work than George, whose position up to that point had been a sinecure. At length Everton attacked in promising style, and from a throw-in near the corner-flag Settle tried a shot which George easily cleared. Several good runs by the Villa forwards were spoiled through players getting offside, though on one occasion Bache shot out with a nice opening. Then came the best attack witnessed so far on the part of the Everton forwards, and George was applauded for cleverly fielding a flying shot from Hardman. The Villa, who were distinctly the better team, continued to attack and Roose proved himself an able and efficient custodian. Just before the interval Brawn executed a clever run, and centred right in front of goal, where Balmer kicked over. It was a risky bit of play, for he might easily have put the ball into his own goal net. The corner-kick yielded no result, and the Villa, who had played the better football, were leading at the interval by a goal to nil.
Interval; Villa 1, Everton 0
Everton were the first to become prominent after the interval, and some skilful work on the right forced a corner-kick, which was, however, unproductive. Then the Villa forwards came away, and a pretty pass from Bache enabled Hall to centre. Hampton stopped the ball, but could not shoot, and Garratty getting possession of it put it into the net, thus scoring a second goal for the Villa two minutes and a half from the start. The latter, encouraged by their success, exhibited even greater dash than had previously marked their efforts, and the Everton backs were in difficulties on many occasions. They struggled on very pluckily, and, generally speaking, cleared well, though at times the Villa forwards, who were clever as well as dashing, found shooting positions, and then Roose was afforded the chance of distinguishing himself. The attack, however, was not always at one end. Everton occasionally worked their way to the other end, but the methods of their forwards lacked decision, and George was rarely troubled. As time went on, however, an improvement in this respect was noted, and George was cheered for stopping a magnificent shot from Young, the first really difficult one of the match. Rarely two minutes had elapsed when Everton attacked again, and this time Sharp, who was well placed, succeeded in beating George. The latter, indeed, had no possible chance of stopping the shot. Everton’s success which was secured eighteen minutes after the interval, invested the game with added interest. The Liverpool men played up with more zest and vigour, and during the next few minutes deemed likely to equalise. Then, however, the Villa recovered themselves, and Hall narrowly missed scoring with a lovely shot. Directly afterwards the ball was at the other end, and two corners were forced by Everton from the second of which they nearly succeeded in drawing level. Everton were now showing form worthy of their reputation, and some fine play was witnessed. Fortunately, however, the Villa defence was very sound, and several grand attacks were beaten off. George was in magnificent form in goal, and two of his saves, the one from a centre by Sharp and the other from a corner kick, were wonderfully clever. There was no doubt as to which side were playing the better football at this point. The ball was continually in the vicinity of the Villa goal, and it was really wonderful how it escaped capture on several occasions. The siege was at length raised, and Hall sent in a capital centre, which went begging, nobody being at hand to take it, and the Villa goal again became the objective of the attack. A corner was won, but like those that had preceded it, was useless, and the Villa forwards carried the ball to the opposite end, where Brawn was pulled up for being offside. A fine long kick by Crelley gave Everton the attack once more, and Miles was penalised for handling near goal. Fortunately the kick was charged down, and a run by Brawn served to relieve the pressure. The relief, however, was only momentary, but try as hard as they would Everton could not equalise, and retired beaten by two goals to one.
Result; Villa 2, Everton 1
Taking the game as a whole, the Villa were lucky to win; a draw would more accurately have represented the character of the play. The Villa were certainly the better team in the first half, when George did not have a really difficult shot to shop, and they maintained their superiority for ten minutes in the second half, by which time they had established a lead of two goals to nil. Everyone anticipated that the Birmingham team were destined to win easily, but these expectations were soon falsified, for Everton commenced to reveal their true form, and having scored a goal eighteen minutes after the interval they were far and away the better team. As a matter of fact, they literally penned the Villa in, and were distinctly unfortunate that they did not equalise. There was only one occasion in the last half-hour that the Villa were realty dangerous, and that was when Hall got past the backs and missed the far post by only a few inches. The Villa defenders mist be praised for their work, and to George in particular the club owe a debt of gratitude. He was highly tried, and acquitted himself brilliantly. Miles and Spencer were both in great form, and of three excellent half-backs Leake was undoubtedly the best. Everton were assisted in their efforts by the fact that the Villa players as a whole adopted defensive tactics. Had they played the same game as they had previously bene playing they would in all probability have had the ball more frequently in the Everton half. Wilkes was seen to more advantage than Windmill was at Stoke. Brawn played a fine game before the interval for the Villa, running and centring admirably, but afterwards he was weak. He was well fed by Garratty, who worked hard from start to finish, accomplishing a lot of useful work around goal when the Everton pressure was at its greatest. Hampton led many good attacks in the first half, and as was the case on Saturday, passed well to his wings. We have seen Bache play better, but Hall accomplished some very useful runs. Roose was a safe custodian for Everton, whilst Balmer was seen to advantage at back, though as a pair the Everton backs were not as good as the Villa’s nor were their half-backs equally as accomplished. Sharp, on the whole, was not as prominent as on Saturday but Settle and Hardman played very well, particularly in the last half-hour. It was a curious match, but nevertheless was most exciting, and the Villa forwards undoubtedly made a mistake in falling back on the defence too soon. It gave Everton the opportunity to attack, they promptly embraced it, and might easily have drawn level. There were about 25,000 persons present, and the receipts amounted to £1,439 3s.

SEMI-FINAL REPLAYED TIE
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 30 March 1905
EVERTON v  ASTON VILLA
After a very close struggle, in which there was little if anything to choose between the teams, Aston Villa beat Everton by 2 goals 1 on the Forest ground at Nottingham yesterday, and so qualified to meet Newcastle United in the final at the Crystal Palace on the 15th of next month. The display of football did not equal the high level reached when the teams scored one goal each at Stoke on Saturday, but the finish was again intensely exciting, Everton, who were two goals to the bad, making tremendous efforts for a period lasting fully a quarter of an hour. They completely controlled the play, penning the Villa in their own half, and giving George endless trouble, but only one goal rewarded them, and during the last ten minutes play slackened, as it was bound to do after such a wonderful burst. By reason of this great attempt when apparently a beaten side, Everton could be regarded as unlucky to lose; but previously they had been cleverly outplayed, the methods of their opponents being superior in every respect. The fact that the Villa won the toss and had the bright sun and fresh wind behind them in the first half, no doubt had its effect on the game, but ends were changed with only one goal obtained, and it was the second point, which came soon after the restart, that really settled matters. Considering at what a splendid pace, and with what superb skill they played late in the game, it was wonderful that Everton should have been so slow and uncertain during the greater part of the match. Not only did the Villa more than hold their own when the conditions favoured them, but for some time afterwards their sound, robust work enabled them to assert themselves in a very decided manner. When Everton set the pace they always seemed to have the ball, their quickness and sureness in passing making any result possible. They were undoubtedly unfortunate to get only one goal, but at the same time credit must be given to the Villa defence, which underwent a very severe trail when the all round excellence of the side looked to have made victory certain. Glorious weather favoured the match, the sun shinning throughout the afternoon; and there was a very large attendance, the official return of those paying for admission being 24,843 and the full receipts £1,439 3s. The ground could not have been in better condition, but after the wonderful pace shown throughout the match on Saturday the game began comparatively slowly, and only rose above the commonplace when Everton did their wonderful piece of work. The Villa who had Wilkes at left half instead of Windmill this being the only change in the teams soon began some useful attacks. Everton rarely becoming dangerous in the early part of the game, and bothered somewhat by the sun, their backs and halves could not hold the Villa forwards of whom Brawn was very prominent. Still, there was no  marked difference in the sides until Brawn put the ball into the centre, and Balmer, failing to head away, allowed Hampton to dash through the centre unmarked. The Villa forward made no mistake, and, with Roose running out, he shot the first goal less than twenty minutes from the start. Directly afterwards Hampson nearly got through against and though Everton set up a few attacks, they were not often troublesome. Owing to the sure tackling of the Villa halves (of whom Leake was very useful), and the accurate kicking of Spencer and Miles more chances of scoring came to the Villa, Bache twice failing; and the Everton goal had a remarkable escape. Brawn passing into goal, and Makepeace, in trying to kick away, shying the ball over the bar. Just three minutes after the change of ends the Villa increased their lead. After passing Bache, Hall made a lofty pass right in front of goal. Hampton, dashing up, missed the ball, but Garratty, quite unopposed had time to gather the ball and shoot high into the net. The Villa continued to have a good share of the play, although Hardman forced a couple of corners; but at length Sharp put in one of the best shots of the match, which George saved. However, a minute later Hardman centred, and Sharp, having closed in again, hooked the ball into the net very cleverly. This occurred eighteen minutes after resuming, and then came Everton’s great display of offensive football, which made the game memorable. George saved all kinds of shots, and though corner after corner was forced, he always got the ball away. The more they pressed the keener the Everton men became. All the team were in the Villa half, and frequently all but the backs and Roose swarmed round the goal. Very rarely did the Villa forwards break away, and as it seemed certain that Everton would draw level, intense excitement prevailed. In the middle of a series of eight corners Sharp made a beautiful run, out-pacing Miles and centreing right into goal; but George handled the ball past the goal, and cleared the subsequent corner. After all this constant pressure on the Villa goal Hall broke away, but was unsupported, and once Makepeace stopped Brawn. Twice from free kicks, one for hands just outside the penalty area, Everton were very dangerous, but the Villa defence prevailed, and Everton could not get on terms, play quietening towards the close. Teams;-
Everton.- L.R. Roose, goal; Balmer (captain) and Crelly, backs; Makepeace, Taylor and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
Aston Villa.- George, goal; Spencer (captain) and Miles, backs; Pearson, Leake, and Wilkes, half-backs; Brawn, Garratty, Hampton, Bache, and Hall, forwards.

FAR FROM DISGRACED
Liverpool Echo - Thursday 30 March 1905
EVERTON RETIRE FROM THE ENGLISH CUP
A TERRIFIC BOMBARDMENT
By Bee
You know the result. Perhaps you don’t know the circumstances of the great replayed cup tie. Let us start at the beginning. We took the Great Central route; passing through Stockport, Sheffield, and bordering on the Manchester water supply, then rose up through Buxton right up to the top of the Peak. The waterworks provided a pretty sight, and one expressed wonder that such a supply was described as being insufficient. The black-coated sheep caused one wag to suggest that the shortness of water was due to the gallons used by Manchester people in their whiskey, there being none remaining to wash the sheep. All through the journey the sun shone magnificently. Arriving at the banks of the Trent we rushed for the ground and found it practically filled; and (a most sensible idea this) mounted police to trot round and tell the people that the stands were already filled. Standing at the back of the goalposts a “kind friend,” apparently one of the many of Birmingham “sharps,” edged up suspiciously near to me. After a few words of warning he moved along to other spheres of labour. Whether he was successful or not cannot be said, but certainly there were many spectators bemoaning the loss of purse, watches, and other valuable articles. Granville Morris, the Forest player, has a large signpost telling the visitors to the ground that he is not only a hard-working footballer, but that he is a colliery agent, I like to see a player fill up his spare time with other work. The ground is a very neat, compact one, and there would be few of the 24,843 spectators (the receipts amounted to £1,439, and probably there would be 28,000 people on the ground in all) who did not see the whole of the match. The band kept things lively until Spencer turned out with his men. Then there was a roar, which was only exceeded in volume when the Everton men turned out. The game must be split up into halves. In the first “45” Nottingham Forest people said they did not expect such a poor show from the Blues. “Why, Forest play better than that,” said one man. There was that awful hesitancy in front of goal, space looking longingly at the forwards and without avail; the men would not shoot. The Villa had the sun to help them, and a cross-wind, favoured them. They did not make full use of the conditions, though it was not Balmer’s fault they failed. It was generally thought that Balmer was at fault in letting Hampton get the first blood. Roose, however, acts in a most commendable and sporting spirit. He refuses to let Balmer have the brass of the goal, and says very distinctly that Balmer was not at fault. The full back judged the ball as accurately as was possible under the circumstances and attempted to breast it. The swirling wind rose strongly at the critical moment and carried the ball to side of him. I am only too pleased to be able to correct an erroneous impression and to give thanks to Roose for his share in righting the wrong. Nevertheless, Balmer was woefully weak in his clearances and as on Saturday his inability led to Crelley being overworked again. He stood up to it manfully and the way he volleyed in the last twenty minutes was a treat to behold. Hampton got the first goal and Garratty the second. Had Roose run out he might have saved it. But how can one lay a charge of not running out at the feet of Leigh Richmond? Why, it would be preposterous. It is usually our wish that he would not leave his charge. There you are! In the second moiety the Villa ran down three times in the flashlight style, scored, and then there was a terrific bombardment of the Villa defence. The like of it has never been seen before, and I fancy a repetition will never he seen again. For over half an hour the Villa never moved out of their penalty box. I never saw such a complete overwhelming of a club, and yet, confound it, the ball wouldn’t go in, save once when Jack Sharp screwed in a most excellent effort which no keeper in the world would have stopped. I counted up thirteen corners in ten minutes, and then I gave up, because there was no cessation. Corner followed corner; shot after shot rained in, but the wily Leake, noticing that the Villa were outplayed, brought every one of his forwards except Brown right into the goalmouth. Their attention was solely on kicking out and keeping out that ball. Young shot, Settle shot; Abbott, the best half-back on the field, tried to go through the whole lot of them. It was all useless-the Fates, not the Villa, were refusing the Blues their just reward. The excitement was in keeping with the game -terrific; and the match will stand more vivid in my memory than the 1897 final. I don’t like to walk about luck; but, honestly, had Everton won by 6 goals to 2 the Villa could not have murmured against the leeway. How aggravating that Everton should play that insipid, slovenly game in the first half. However, let us not moan over out defeat; let us start on a new track. The best of luck go with the boys in the fight for the League championship. On the Villa side George stood out head and shoulders above the remaining players, and Billy Bassett, Needham, and Foulke all declare they had never seen him play a better game. From the incessant succession of corners he repeatedly got his hand to them, and even when bowled clean over he was able to save his charge. How? I give it up. Spencer and Miles defended beautifully. The veteran lasted the game very well. He could not do so were he not a steady, sensible fellow. The halves were not up to their usual form, but Brawn’s passes from dead on the touchline were magnificent. Hall ran him very close for honours, but the inside man did not do a great deal.  All was quiet on the return journey, but the crowd that gathered at the station showed true sportsmanship by raising loud cheers for the men who had fought the good fight.
Interviewed after the match, the Villa captain expressed himself as well satisfied with the result. He considered the forwards at fault for their failure to open out the game when Everton were attacking so fiercely. “But,” he said, in extenuation, “they were undeniably excited, and now that they have gone through the experience of a replayed semi-final- and there’s no better experience than that-they will know what to do at the Palace.” New-street Station rang with cheers when the train bearing the victorious team drew up on Platform 2. Long before the train arrived large crowds had gathered on the platform. The vaulted station resounded again and again with the cheers. There was a rush for the saloon in which the team travelled. The directors also came in for a great reception. In Stephenson-place the scene was still more animated. People went wild with their enthusiasm. Never since the Reservists were departing for South Africa have there been such scenes. Leake, whose wife had met him at the station, was recognised and borne along by a crowd of admirers, and his better half was left lamenting. Hampton came in for the greatest reception. He sought refuge in a cab, but the driver found a difficulty in starting. “Take the horse out” was the repeated cry from the crowd, in whose eyes Hampton was indeed a hero. George and Garratty had great difficulty in getting through the crowd. There were demands for Howard Spencer, but he was not seen outside the station.
At Wrexham last night, the following eleven were chosen to represent Wales against Ireland, at Belfast, on April 8th-
L.R Roose (Everton), goal; H. Blew (Wrexham) and C. Morris (Derby County), backs; M. Parry (Liverpool), E. Hughes (Tottenham), and J. Hughes (Liverpool), half-backs; W. Meredith (Manchester City), M.W. Watkins (Sunderland), W. Davies (Wrexham), A.G. Morris (Notts Forest), and R. Atherton (Middlesbrough), forwards. A.G. Morris will captain the team.

FOOTBALL FEATURES
Liverpool Echo - Friday 31 March 1905
By Bee
Tomorrow, Everton have a rest.
One of the funniest letters I ever received came from “Jimmy Osh,” who sent his “kind regards” and addressed me as the “Everton Bee.” The Everton colours adorned the rim of the envelope, the face of which was illustrated by a bee sketched in artistic style. I could readily tell he was a Liverpolitan, because he could see no good in Everton, and I might say some Everton correspondents are equally blind of anything good in Liverpool’s play or players. He seems to think that I have a partiality for Everton. Once for all, let me say my favourite team is neither Everton, Liverpool, nor Aston Villa, but to be candid Small Heath. I shall be grateful if correspondents will realise that my “buzzings” will be directed to the matters of most interest irrespective of club and if Liverpool play in a semi-final readers can depend on the dealing out of just as much news as I can possibly get concerning the Anfielders.

TEAM ARRNAGEMENTS TOMORROW
Liverpool Evening Express - Friday 31 March 1905
Everton Res v Nelson
Combination Match at Goodison Park 3.30
Everton.- A,N. Other, goal; Wildman and McCartney, backs; Chadwick, Booth, and Hanlin, half-backs; Rankin, McLoughlin, Thorburn, Caldwell, and Dilly, forwards.